{"totalResults":22,"totalHitCount":115,"results":[{"fields":{"id":"14294","branchid":"12864","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada Award cites LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12864,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12849,12854,12855,12856,12857,12858,12859,12860,12861,12862,12863,12864,12865,12871,12877,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,13944,14014,14320,14321,14343,15798,16050,17371,18079,18137,18647,18674,18931,19141,19175,19501,19638,19673,20124,20212,20419,20890,20895,21709,21834,2","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"7","children":"0","orderno":"21190","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12864","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14294","parentid":"12854","documenttagid":"88093","sourcedocumentid":"12864","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336079","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":8,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"14293","branchid":"12864","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada Award cites LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12864,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12849,12854,12855,12856,12857,12858,12859,12860,12861,12862,12863,12864,12865,12871,12877,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,13944,14014,14320,14321,14343,15798,16050,17371,18079,18137,18647,18674,18931,19141,19175,19501,19638,19673,20124,20212,20419,20890,20895,21709,21834,2","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"7","children":"0","orderno":"21190","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12864","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14293","parentid":"12854","documenttagid":"88093","sourcedocumentid":"12864","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336078","paragraph":"fn179","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":8,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"14292","branchid":"12863","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> Award notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada Award notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12863,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12849,12854,12855,12856,12857,12858,12859,12860,12861,12862,12863,12864,12865,12871,12877,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,13944,14014,14320,14321,14343,15798,16050,17371,18079,18137,18647,18674,18931,19141,19175,19501,19638,19673,20124,20212,20419,20890,20895,21709,21834,2","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"7","children":"0","orderno":"21191","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,12863","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14292","parentid":"12854","documenttagid":"91761","sourcedocumentid":"12863","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> Award notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"344062","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":8,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11100","branchid":"10828","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada Award cites LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"0","orderno":"110","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10828","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11100","parentid":"43353","documenttagid":"86738","sourcedocumentid":"10828","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"13954","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Cargill, Incorporated v. United Mexican States, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/05/2, Award, 18 September 2009 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"333129","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"12415","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":8,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11099","branchid":"10828","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada Award cites LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"0","orderno":"110","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10828","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11099","parentid":"43353","documenttagid":"86738","sourcedocumentid":"10828","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"13954","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM>&nbsp;Award cites <EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Cargill, Incorporated v. United Mexican States, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/05/2, Award, 18 September 2009 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"333128","paragraph":"fn179","disputeid":"12415","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":8,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11664","branchid":"11200","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"0","orderno":"111","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"11200","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11664","parentid":"43353","documenttagid":"86739","sourcedocumentid":"11200","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"13954","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","referencecitation":"Cargill, Incorporated v. United Mexican States, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/05/2, Award, 18 September 2009 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"333130","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"12415","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11622","branchid":"11174","branchname":"<EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> cited by <EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey cited by Merrill & Ring v. Canada for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"11162,11167,11174,11163,11167,11168,11169,11170,11171,11172,11173,11174,11175,11179","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"0","orderno":"621","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"11162,11167,11174","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11622","parentid":"11167","documenttagid":"88096","sourcedocumentid":"11174","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> cited by <EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336083","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11621","branchid":"11174","branchname":"<EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> cited by <EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"LG&E v. Argentina and PSEG v. Turkey cited by Merrill & Ring v. Canada for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"11162,11167,11174,11163,11167,11168,11169,11170,11171,11172,11173,11174,11175,11179","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"0","orderno":"621","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"11162,11167,11174","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11621","parentid":"11167","documenttagid":"88096","sourcedocumentid":"11174","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>LG&amp;E v. Argentina</EM> and <EM>PSEG v. Turkey</EM> cited by <EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> for the view that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336082","paragraph":"fn179","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11246","branchid":"10909","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"10834,10906,10909,10835,10854,10856,10859,10866,10878,10888,10906,10907,10908,10909","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"0","orderno":"528","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10834,10906,10909","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11246","parentid":"10906","documenttagid":"88098","sourcedocumentid":"10909","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336085","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11245","branchid":"10908","branchname":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","hierarchicalparentids":"10834,10906,10908,10835,10854,10856,10859,10866,10878,10888,10906,10907,10908,10909","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"0","orderno":"529","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10834,10906,10908","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11245","parentid":"10906","documenttagid":"88097","sourcedocumentid":"10908","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill &amp; Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"336084","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"10788","branchid":"10623","branchname":"<EM>Merrill & Ring v. Canada</EM> notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"0","orderno":"180","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10623","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=10788","parentid":"42644","documenttagid":"84375","sourcedocumentid":"10623","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill & Ring v. Canada</EM> notes further that where there is no measure of profitability, a future scenario will be characterized more by speculation than by educated estimate, an approach that has not been favoured by arbitration tribunals","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"328239","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"10787","branchid":"10622","branchname":"<EM>Merrill & Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","branchnametext":"Merrill & Ring v. Canada notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"0","orderno":"181","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10622","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=10787","parentid":"42644","documenttagid":"84374","sourcedocumentid":"10622","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"19206","sourcecitation":"<EM>Merrill & Ring v. Canada</EM> notes that future estimates are based on assumptions, but these are \"inevitably drawn from specific information provided by a historical record of profitability, or other elements that allow for an educated estimate\"","referencecitation":"Merrill & Ring Forestry L. P. v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. UNCT/07/1, ICSID Administrated, Award, 31 March 2010","documenttypes":"Final Awards on Jurisdiction, Merits or Damages","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"328238","paragraph":"pa264","disputeid":"13304","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":5,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21239","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21239","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339140","paragraph":"pa225","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21238","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21238","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339139","paragraph":"pa224","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21237","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21237","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339138","paragraph":"pa223","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21236","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21236","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339137","paragraph":"pa222","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21235","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21235","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339136","paragraph":"pa221","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21234","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21234","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339135","paragraph":"pa220","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21233","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21233","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339134","paragraph":"pa219","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21232","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21232","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339133","paragraph":"pa218","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21231","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21231","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339132","paragraph":"pa217","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"21230","branchid":"16191","branchname":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","branchnametext":"Mobil and Murphy v. Canada Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"1","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"0","orderno":"8805","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343,16191","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=21230","parentid":"7343","documenttagid":"89587","sourcedocumentid":"16191","documenttagtypeid":"5","referencedocumentid":"14010","sourcecitation":"<span style=\"font-style: italic;\">Mobil and Murphy v. Canada</span><span style=\"font-style: normal;\"> Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum considers that the ordinary meaning of services is broad enough to encompass research and development and education and training requirements </span>","referencecitation":"Mobil Investments Canada Inc. and Murphy Oil Corporation v. Government of Canada, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/07/4, Decision on Liability and on Principles of Quantum, 22 May 2012 [Redacted]","documenttypes":"Partial Awards or Decisions on the Merits","language":"English","documenttagvalueid":"339131","paragraph":"pa216","disputeid":"12422","isfollowtopicdisable":"0","refjuriscount":"0","proceedingstageid":"0","issubsequentdevelopments":"0"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":4,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"14327","branchid":"12883","branchname":"Valuation methods","branchnametext":"Valuation methods","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12849,12854,12877,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,18137,18931,20124","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"5","children":"3","orderno":"21225","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14327","parentid":"12826"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"14280","branchid":"12854","branchname":"Discounted cash flow (DCF)","branchnametext":"Discounted cash flow (DCF)","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12849,12854,12855,12856,12857,12858,12859,12860,12861,12862,12863,12864,12865,12871,12877,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,13944,14014,14320,14321,14343,15798,16050,17371,18079,18137,18647,18674,18931,19141,19175,19501,19638,19673,20124,20212,20419,20890,20895,21709,21834,21840,2","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"6","children":"59","orderno":"21205","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826,12883,12854","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14280","parentid":"12883"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"14241","branchid":"12826","branchname":"Quantification of damages","branchnametext":"Quantification of damages","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,12826,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,12827,12828,12841,12881,12883,12884,12895,12909,13253,13301,13644,18137,18931,20124","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"9","orderno":"21303","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591,12826","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=14241","parentid":"12591"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"13797","branchid":"12591","branchname":"Compensatory damages","branchnametext":"Compensatory damages","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,12591,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,8563,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12592,12601,12604,12606,12622,12721,12755,12826,13253,13301,13644,18137,18931","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"3","children":"8","orderno":"21524","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218,12591","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=13797","parentid":"12218"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"13299","branchid":"12218","branchname":"Damages and interest","branchnametext":"Damages and interest","hierarchicalparentids":"4,12218,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,9643,10375,10725,11486,11636,12218,12219,12221,12222,12591,12606,12622,13253,13644,18137,18931","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"True","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"9","orderno":"21602","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4,12218","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=13299","parentid":"4"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11613","branchid":"11167","branchname":"ICSID cases","branchnametext":"ICSID cases","hierarchicalparentids":"11162,11167,11163,11167,11168,11169,11170,11171,11172,11173,11174,11175,11179","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"3","children":"7","orderno":"628","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"11162,11167","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11613","parentid":"11162"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11608","branchid":"11162","branchname":"Non-NAFTA cases on damages cited by NAFTA tribunals","branchnametext":"Non-NAFTA cases on damages cited by NAFTA tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"11162,11163,11167,11175,11179","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"4","orderno":"633","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"11162","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11608","parentid":"42583"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11240","branchid":"10906","branchname":"Use of the discounted cash flow (DCF) valuation method generally","branchnametext":"Use of the discounted cash flow (DCF) valuation method generally","hierarchicalparentids":"10834,10906,10835,10854,10856,10859,10866,10878,10888,10906,10907,10908,10909","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"3","children":"3","orderno":"531","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10834,10906","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11240","parentid":"10834"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"11107","branchid":"10834","branchname":"General statements in the caselaw","branchnametext":"General statements in the caselaw","hierarchicalparentids":"10834,10835,10854,10856,10859,10866,10878,10888,10906","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"8","orderno":"608","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"10834","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=11107","parentid":"42955"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"9963","branchid":"10079","branchname":"Under NAFTA","branchnametext":"Under NAFTA","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,18369,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"3","children":"9","orderno":"8819","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=9963","parentid":"7336"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"4775","branchid":"7343","branchname":"General findings of tribunals","branchnametext":"General findings of tribunals","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,10079,7343,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7337,7338,7339,7340,7341,7342,7343,7344,7345,7346,7347,7348,7350,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,7989,8128,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,16191,16193,16194,18369,19533,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"4","children":"10","orderno":"8812","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336,10079,7343","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=4775","parentid":"10079"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"4768","branchid":"7336","branchname":"Performance requirements","branchnametext":"Performance requirements","hierarchicalparentids":"16,7336,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,8245,8398,9148,10079,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,18369,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"True","isactive":"True","depth":"2","children":"2","orderno":"8820","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16,7336","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=4768","parentid":"16"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"16","branchid":"16","branchname":"P","branchnametext":"P","hierarchicalparentids":"16,2684,4771,7330,7333,7336,7355,7362,7364,7399,7402,7405,7648,8245,8398,10346,11825,11859,12200,15204,15399,16170,18369,24579","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"1","children":"23","orderno":"16","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"16","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=16"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null},{"fields":{"id":"4","branchid":"4","branchname":"D","branchnametext":"D","hierarchicalparentids":"4,4664,4996,6050,6052,6055,6077,6090,6101,6102,7651,7743,9643,10375,11486,11636,12218,13253,13644","ispublished":"True","branchtypeid":"3","issubstantive":"False","isactive":"True","depth":"1","children":"18","orderno":"4","isdeleted":"False","selectednodes":"4","Filename":"db://vw_SubjectNavigatorSearch#Id=4"},"paragraphs":null,"hitCount":1,"highlightedFields":null}],"selectedNodes":"4,16,7336,7343,10079,10622,10623,10828,10834,10906,10908,10909,11162,11167,11174,11200,12218,12591,12826,12854,12863,12864,12883,16191","timeLog":["search: 48","collect results (22): 1","highlight fields: 0","collect hierarchy items (14 for 14 IDs): 25","total: 76"],"hardStop":false}