{"AppBuildDate":"20221004170039","TocInclude":false,"TocMaxLevel":3,"TocInsertBeforeId":null,"PdfFilePath":"L:\\Shared\\ISLG\\Content\\1 - Document Collection\\0 - Dispute Documents\\UN-0117-30 - PrivatBank and Finilon v. Russia - PO7 [Redacted].pdf","DocumentUIN":"UN011730","OCR_Type":1,"BlockIdMax":92,"DocumentBlocks":{"4":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":31,"columnEnd":31,"text":" Procedural Background","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h1","paragraphIdAuto":"hProcedural","paragraphId":"h1","paragraphLabel":"1.","rectangle":"99, 115, 112, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Procedural Background","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":31,"blockId":8,"value":"Procedural Background","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.92,"width":112.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64,"Value":"Procedural Background"}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64}},"3":{"pageNum":1,"columnStart":4,"columnEnd":26,"text":"<div> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </div><div><br></div><div>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </div><div><br></div><div>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </div><div><br></div><div>- between - </div><div><br></div><div>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </div><div>The Claimant </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </div><div>The Respondent </div><div><br></div><div>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </div><div><br></div><div><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></div><div>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </div><div>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </div><div>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</div><div><br></div><div><strong>Registry</strong> </div><div>Permanent Court of Arbitration </div><div><br></div><div>12 September 2019</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa0","paragraphIdAuto":"paIN","paragraphId":"pa0","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"78, 115, 438, 589","alignment":1,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </p><p><br></p><p>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </p><p><br></p><p>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </p><p><br></p><p>- between - </p><p><br></p><p>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </p><p>The Claimant </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </p><p>The Respondent </p><p><br></p><p>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </p><p><br></p><p><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></p><p>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </p><p>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </p><p>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</p><p><br></p><p><strong>Registry</strong> </p><p>Permanent Court of Arbitration </p><p><br></p><p>12 September 2019</p>","averageFontSize":7.644859813084112,"rowsOfText":23,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":4,"blockId":7,"value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":84.48,"y":115.92,"width":424.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":84.48,"MarginRight":509.28000000000003,"Value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":5,"blockId":7,"value":"ACCORDANCE WITH","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":128.16,"width":113.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.24,"MarginRight":353.52,"Value":"ACCORDANCE WITH"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":6,"blockId":7,"value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":78.0,"y":153.84,"width":438.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0,"Value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":7,"blockId":7,"value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":78.24,"y":166.56,"width":437.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.24,"MarginRight":515.28,"Value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":8,"blockId":7,"value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":110.16,"y":179.04,"width":373.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":110.16,"MarginRight":483.84000000000003,"Value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":9,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.0,"y":204.48,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.0,"MarginRight":312.48,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":10,"blockId":7,"value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":106.32,"y":229.68,"width":383.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":106.32,"MarginRight":489.59999999999997,"Value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":11,"blockId":7,"value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":202.32,"y":242.16,"width":191.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":202.32,"MarginRight":393.84000000000003,"Value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":12,"blockId":7,"value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":280.08,"width":114.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":355.44,"Value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":13,"blockId":7,"value":"- between -","fontName":"Times","fontSize":1.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":322.8,"width":51.12,"height":1.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":272.64,"MarginRight":323.76,"Value":"- between -"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":14,"blockId":7,"value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.6,"y":356.16,"width":114.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":243.6,"MarginRight":357.84,"Value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":15,"blockId":7,"value":"The Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":381.36,"width":64.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":265.92,"MarginRight":330.72,"Value":"The Claimant"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":16,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.96,"y":419.28,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.96,"MarginRight":313.44,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":17,"blockId":7,"value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":225.6,"y":457.2,"width":150.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":225.6,"MarginRight":375.84000000000003,"Value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":18,"blockId":7,"value":"The Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":260.16,"y":482.64,"width":76.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":260.16,"MarginRight":336.48,"Value":"The Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":19,"blockId":7,"value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":545.76,"width":150.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":223.2,"MarginRight":373.2,"Value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":20,"blockId":7,"value":"The Arbitral Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.76,"y":596.64,"width":104.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":245.76,"MarginRight":350.64,"Value":"The Arbitral Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":21,"blockId":7,"value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":608.64,"width":231.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":182.4,"MarginRight":413.76,"Value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":22,"blockId":7,"value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.12,"width":112.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":241.92,"MarginRight":354.48,"Value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":23,"blockId":7,"value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":254.16,"y":634.32,"width":88.08,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":254.16,"MarginRight":342.24,"Value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":24,"blockId":7,"value":"Registry","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":659.76,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":278.4,"MarginRight":318.0,"Value":"Registry"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":25,"blockId":7,"value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":228.96,"y":672.24,"width":138.72,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":228.96,"MarginRight":367.68,"Value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":26,"blockId":7,"value":"12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":697.44,"width":83.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":256.8,"MarginRight":340.56,"Value":"12 September 2019"}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0}},"5":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":32,"columnEnd":51,"text":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.1","paragraphId":"pa1.1","paragraphLabel":"1.1","rectangle":"72, 140, 454, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","averageFontSize":8.188065099457505,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":32,"blockId":9,"value":"1.1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":140.16,"width":11.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":33,"blockId":9,"value":"On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.1 On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":34,"blockId":9,"value":"Finilon LLC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":152.64,"width":56.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":35,"blockId":9,"value":"(“Finilon”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":152.64,"width":46.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":36,"blockId":9,"value":"and,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":214.08,"y":152.64,"width":17.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":37,"blockId":9,"value":"together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":237.36,"y":152.64,"width":60.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":38,"blockId":9,"value":"PrivatBank,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":302.64,"y":152.64,"width":51.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":39,"blockId":9,"value":"the “Claimants”) commenced these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":359.52,"y":152.64,"width":165.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Finilon LLC (“Finilon” and, together with PrivatBank, the “Claimants”) commenced these"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":40,"blockId":9,"value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":165.36,"width":134.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":234.72,"Value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":41,"blockId":9,"value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":179.52,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":42,"blockId":9,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":190.56,"width":35.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":43,"blockId":9,"value":"Cabinet","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":190.56,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":44,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ministers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.48,"y":190.56,"width":54.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":45,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ukraine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":241.2,"y":190.56,"width":49.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":46,"blockId":9,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":296.4,"y":193.2,"width":10.08,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":47,"blockId":9,"value":"the Encouragement and Mutual Protection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":312.72,"y":190.56,"width":198.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":48,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":190.56,"width":10.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001,"Value":"and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":49,"blockId":9,"value":"Investments dated 27 November","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":203.52,"width":145.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":50,"blockId":9,"value":"1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.08,"y":203.28,"width":275.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":51,"blockId":9,"value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.4,"Value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001}},"6":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":52,"columnEnd":52,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.2","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.2","paragraphLabel":"1.2","rectangle":"72, 241, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":52,"blockId":10,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":241.44,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"12"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}},"7":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":53,"columnEnd":54,"text":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa13","paragraphId":"pa1.3","paragraphLabel":"1.3","rectangle":"72, 342, 225, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":53,"blockId":11,"value":"13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":342.72,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":54,"blockId":11,"value":"The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":198.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32,"Value":"13 The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32}},"8":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":55,"columnEnd":79,"text":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.4","paragraphId":"pa1.4","paragraphLabel":"1.4","rectangle":"72, 367, 453, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","averageFontSize":8.510385756676557,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":55,"blockId":12,"value":"1.4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":367.92,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":56,"blockId":12,"value":"On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.92,"width":426.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"1.4 On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":57,"blockId":12,"value":"the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.16,"width":77.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":58,"blockId":12,"value":"Letters from the PCA, and that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":380.16,"width":142.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":59,"blockId":12,"value":"it considered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.28,"y":380.16,"width":57.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":60,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.2,"y":380.16,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":61,"blockId":12,"value":"content of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":381.6,"width":72.0,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":62,"blockId":12,"value":"letters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.76,"y":380.16,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":63,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":381.6,"width":7.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":64,"blockId":12,"value":"constitute","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":392.88,"width":42.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":65,"blockId":12,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":148.56,"y":395.52,"width":9.84,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":66,"blockId":12,"value":"objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":165.12,"y":392.88,"width":40.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":67,"blockId":12,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":211.92,"y":392.88,"width":10.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":68,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":392.88,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":69,"blockId":12,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":248.64,"y":392.88,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":70,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":394.32,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":71,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":72,"blockId":12,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":392.88,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":73,"blockId":12,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":392.88,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":74,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":412.08,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":75,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":392.88,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":76,"blockId":12,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.68,"y":392.88,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":77,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":497.52,"y":394.32,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":78,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":392.88,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":79,"blockId":12,"value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.6,"width":358.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.64,"Value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32}},"9":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":80,"columnEnd":113,"text":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.5","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.125","paragraphId":"pa1.5","paragraphLabel":"1.5","rectangle":"72, 431, 452, 85","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.546712802768166,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":80,"blockId":13,"value":"125","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":431.04,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":81,"blockId":13,"value":"On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"125 On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":82,"blockId":13,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":443.52,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":83,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":126.0,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":84,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":443.52,"width":53.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":85,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.24,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":86,"blockId":13,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":443.52,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":87,"blockId":13,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.68,"y":443.52,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":88,"blockId":13,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":298.08,"y":443.52,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":89,"blockId":13,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":443.52,"width":45.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":90,"blockId":13,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.92,"y":443.76,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":91,"blockId":13,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":443.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":92,"blockId":13,"value":"Rules","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.16,"y":443.52,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":93,"blockId":13,"value":"of Procedure,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.92,"y":443.52,"width":60.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":94,"blockId":13,"value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.24,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":95,"blockId":13,"value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":468.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":96,"blockId":13,"value":"were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":484.32,"width":20.88,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":97,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":125.76,"y":482.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":98,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":139.2,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":99,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":100,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":168.24,"y":481.92,"width":197.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":101,"blockId":13,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.28,"y":481.44,"width":33.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":102,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":481.44,"width":72.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":103,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":488.16,"y":482.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":104,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.6,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":105,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":521.04,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":106,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Defence and any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":494.64,"width":139.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":107,"blockId":13,"value":"Objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":494.16,"width":42.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":108,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":293.28,"y":495.6,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":109,"blockId":13,"value":"Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":494.16,"width":51.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":110,"blockId":13,"value":"and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.12,"y":494.16,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":111,"blockId":13,"value":"Admissibility,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":395.76,"y":494.16,"width":61.92,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":112,"blockId":13,"value":"including any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":494.16,"width":61.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":113,"blockId":13,"value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.64,"width":220.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":319.68,"Value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}},"10":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":114,"columnEnd":114,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.6","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.6","paragraphLabel":"1.6","rectangle":"72, 532, 12, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":114,"blockId":14,"value":"1.6","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.32,"width":12.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48,"Value":"1.6"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48}},"11":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":115,"columnEnd":125,"text":" The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure. The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the Tribunal. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.7","paragraphId":"pa1.7","paragraphLabel":"1.7","rectangle":"72, 557, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.364912280701754,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":115,"blockId":15,"value":"1.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":557.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":116,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.28,"width":91.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":117,"blockId":15,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":196.32,"y":558.72,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":118,"blockId":15,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":215.04,"y":557.28,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":119,"blockId":15,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":234.0,"y":560.16,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":120,"blockId":15,"value":"Statement of Defence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":243.84,"y":557.76,"width":97.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":121,"blockId":15,"value":"or any Objection to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":346.8,"y":558.72,"width":89.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":122,"blockId":15,"value":"Jurisdiction and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.36,"y":557.28,"width":84.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.7 The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":123,"blockId":15,"value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":570.0,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":124,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":582.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":125,"blockId":15,"value":"Tribunal.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.2,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":139.44,"Value":"Tribunal."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"12":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":126,"columnEnd":126,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.8","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.8","paragraphLabel":"1.8","rectangle":"72, 620, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":126,"blockId":1,"value":"1.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":620.88,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"1.8"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}},"13":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":127,"columnEnd":140,"text":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.9","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19","paragraphId":"pa1.9","paragraphLabel":"1.9","rectangle":"72, 671, 452, 96","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","averageFontSize":7.4953271028037385,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":127,"blockId":2,"value":"19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":671.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":128,"blockId":2,"value":"On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":671.76,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"19 On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":129,"blockId":2,"value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":393.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":130,"blockId":2,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":684.0,"width":27.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":131,"blockId":2,"value":"Procedural Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":696.72,"width":96.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":132,"blockId":2,"value":"2,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":201.6,"y":696.72,"width":7.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":133,"blockId":2,"value":"in which it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.32,"y":696.72,"width":49.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":134,"blockId":2,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":268.08,"y":696.72,"width":9.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":135,"blockId":2,"value":"ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":282.72,"y":696.48,"width":242.4,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":136,"blockId":2,"value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.44,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":137,"blockId":2,"value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":724.56,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":138,"blockId":2,"value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":734.64,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":139,"blockId":2,"value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":747.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":140,"blockId":2,"value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":761.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"14":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":145,"columnEnd":149,"text":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.063953488372093,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":145,"blockId":3,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":146,"blockId":3,"value":"Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":117.36,"y":115.44,"width":176.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":147,"blockId":3,"value":"Thereafter,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":298.8,"y":115.44,"width":47.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":148,"blockId":3,"value":"each Party had until 29 April 2016 to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":351.84,"y":115.44,"width":173.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":149,"blockId":3,"value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":127.92,"width":371.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":471.12,"Value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}},"15":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":151,"columnEnd":154,"text":" May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19.On24","paragraphId":"pa1.11","paragraphLabel":"1.11","rectangle":"99, 204, 426, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":6.793296089385475,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":151,"blockId":4,"value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":426.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":152,"blockId":4,"value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":153,"blockId":4,"value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":154,"blockId":4,"value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":243.36,"width":337.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":437.52,"Value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}},"16":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":150,"columnEnd":150,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.10","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.10","paragraphLabel":"1.10","rectangle":"72, 153, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":150,"blockId":1,"value":"1.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":153.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.10"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},"17":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":155,"columnEnd":161,"text":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12","paragraphId":"pa1.12","paragraphLabel":"1.12","rectangle":"72, 267, 452, 58","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":7.7176470588235295,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":155,"blockId":2,"value":"1.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":267.36,"width":17.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":156,"blockId":2,"value":"On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.36,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.12 On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":157,"blockId":2,"value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":158,"blockId":2,"value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":159,"blockId":2,"value":"thereon.I","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":51.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":160,"blockId":2,"value":"The Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":305.04,"width":109.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"thereon.I The Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":161,"blockId":2,"value":"submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":317.76,"width":98.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":198.0,"Value":"submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"18":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":162,"columnEnd":166,"text":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.113","paragraphId":"pa1.13","paragraphLabel":"1.13","rectangle":"72, 343, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.445652173913043,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":162,"blockId":3,"value":"1.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":343.2,"width":16.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":163,"blockId":3,"value":"On 10 and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":343.2,"width":47.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":164,"blockId":3,"value":"14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":343.2,"width":373.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.13 On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":165,"blockId":3,"value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":213.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":312.96000000000004,"Value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":166,"blockId":3,"value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":368.16,"width":314.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":413.28000000000003,"Value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},"19":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":167,"columnEnd":205,"text":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.114","paragraphId":"pa1.14","paragraphLabel":"1.14","rectangle":"72, 393, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.49737302977233,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":167,"blockId":6,"value":"1.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":393.84,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":168,"blockId":6,"value":"The hearing on jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":145.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":169,"blockId":6,"value":"admissibility was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":249.84,"y":393.6,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":170,"blockId":6,"value":"held in Geneva from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.88,"y":393.6,"width":95.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":171,"blockId":6,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.88,"y":393.84,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":172,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":395.04,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":173,"blockId":6,"value":"14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":393.84,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":174,"blockId":6,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":477.84,"y":393.6,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":175,"blockId":6,"value":"2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":393.84,"width":23.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"1.14 The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":176,"blockId":6,"value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":177,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":178,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":179,"blockId":6,"value":"was delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":62.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":180,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":166.56,"y":445.68,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":181,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":444.24,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":182,"blockId":6,"value":"Parties, and they were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":197.76,"y":444.24,"width":101.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":183,"blockId":6,"value":"granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":304.32,"y":444.24,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":184,"blockId":6,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":342.0,"y":444.24,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":185,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":445.68,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":186,"blockId":6,"value":"address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.56,"y":444.24,"width":32.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":187,"blockId":6,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":420.0,"y":444.24,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":188,"blockId":6,"value":"raised by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":465.84,"y":444.24,"width":41.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":189,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":444.24,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":190,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":191,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.56,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":192,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":155.76,"y":456.72,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":193,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.0,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":194,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":459.6,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":195,"blockId":6,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.48,"y":456.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":196,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":252.48,"y":459.6,"width":8.16,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":197,"blockId":6,"value":"other","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.16,"y":456.72,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":198,"blockId":6,"value":"matters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":293.52,"y":457.92,"width":31.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":199,"blockId":6,"value":"arising","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":330.96,"y":456.72,"width":29.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":200,"blockId":6,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":365.52,"y":458.16,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":201,"blockId":6,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":456.72,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":202,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":416.64,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":203,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":457.2,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":204,"blockId":6,"value":"post-hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":470.4,"y":456.72,"width":54.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":205,"blockId":6,"value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":193.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":293.28,"Value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},"20":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":206,"columnEnd":208,"text":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.15","paragraphId":"pa1.15","paragraphLabel":"1.15","rectangle":"72, 494, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.131147540983607,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":206,"blockId":7,"value":"1.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":494.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":207,"blockId":7,"value":"NThe Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":494.4,"width":145.68,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.15 NThe Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":208,"blockId":7,"value":"file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":507.36,"width":149.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":249.12,"Value":"file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"21":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":209,"columnEnd":212,"text":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.116","paragraphId":"pa1.16","paragraphLabel":"1.16","rectangle":"72, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":8.283154121863799,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":209,"blockId":8,"value":"1.16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.8,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":210,"blockId":8,"value":"On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.16 On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":211,"blockId":8,"value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.28,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":212,"blockId":8,"value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":558.0,"width":374.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":472.56000000000006,"Value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":526.56}},"22":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":213,"columnEnd":246,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </div><div><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </div><div><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.17","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.117","paragraphId":"pa1.17","paragraphLabel":"1.17","rectangle":"72, 583, 425, 147","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </p><p><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </p><p><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.421686746987952,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":213,"blockId":9,"value":"1.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":583.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":214,"blockId":9,"value":"The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":252.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":352.08,"Value":"1.17 The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":215,"blockId":9,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":608.88,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":216,"blockId":9,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":631.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":217,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":631.68,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":218,"blockId":9,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":631.68,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":219,"blockId":9,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":631.68,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":220,"blockId":9,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":263.76,"y":631.68,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":221,"blockId":9,"value":"assumed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":281.76,"y":631.68,"width":33.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":222,"blockId":9,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":320.64,"y":631.68,"width":43.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":223,"blockId":9,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":631.68,"width":22.56,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":224,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":396.72,"y":631.68,"width":11.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":225,"blockId":9,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":631.92,"width":25.68,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":226,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":443.76,"y":631.68,"width":7.44,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":227,"blockId":9,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":632.88,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":228,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":631.68,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":229,"blockId":9,"value":"Ukrainian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":643.2,"width":39.6,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":230,"blockId":9,"value":"investors","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":210.72,"y":643.2,"width":35.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":231,"blockId":9,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":253.44,"y":643.2,"width":13.92,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":232,"blockId":9,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":274.56,"y":643.2,"width":18.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":233,"blockId":9,"value":"investments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":643.2,"width":47.04,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":234,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":643.2,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":235,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":368.16,"y":643.2,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":236,"blockId":9,"value":"Crimean","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":387.12,"y":643.2,"width":34.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":237,"blockId":9,"value":"Peninsula","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":643.2,"width":38.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":238,"blockId":9,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":645.6,"width":7.92,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":239,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":643.2,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":240,"blockId":9,"value":"21 March 2014;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":654.72,"width":63.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":227.28,"Value":"21 March 2014;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":241,"blockId":9,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":677.76,"width":6.72,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":242,"blockId":9,"value":"there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":677.76,"width":332.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":496.55999999999995,"Value":"2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":243,"blockId":9,"value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":689.28,"width":222.72,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":386.88,"Value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":244,"blockId":9,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":712.08,"width":6.48,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":245,"blockId":9,"value":"the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":712.08,"width":332.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":496.31999999999994,"Value":"3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":246,"blockId":9,"value":"of the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":723.6,"width":53.28,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":217.2,"Value":"of the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":497.76}},"23":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":251,"columnEnd":253,"text":"<div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"127, 115, 368, 30","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":251,"blockId":10,"value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":115.2,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":252,"blockId":10,"value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":126.72,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":253,"blockId":10,"value":"of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":138.24,"width":68.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":196.8,"Value":"of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56}},"24":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":254,"columnEnd":261,"text":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.18","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.118","paragraphId":"pa1.18","paragraphLabel":"1.18","rectangle":"72, 162, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","averageFontSize":7.768421052631579,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":254,"blockId":12,"value":"1.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":162.48,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":255,"blockId":12,"value":"On 27 March 2017, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":162.48,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":256,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":213.84,"y":162.48,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":257,"blockId":12,"value":"re-issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":162.48,"width":39.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":258,"blockId":12,"value":"the Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":300.48,"y":162.48,"width":86.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":259,"blockId":12,"value":"correcting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":392.88,"y":162.48,"width":44.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":260,"blockId":12,"value":"four typographical","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.32,"y":162.48,"width":82.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.18 On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":261,"blockId":12,"value":"errors.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":177.84,"width":27.6,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":127.19999999999999,"Value":"errors."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"25":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":262,"columnEnd":270,"text":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.119","paragraphId":"pa1.19","paragraphLabel":"1.19","rectangle":"72, 200, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","averageFontSize":9.124809741248097,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":262,"blockId":13,"value":"1.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":200.4,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":263,"blockId":13,"value":"On 11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":200.64,"width":26.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":264,"blockId":13,"value":"July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.56,"y":200.4,"width":394.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.19 On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":265,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":213.12,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":266,"blockId":13,"value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":225.84,"width":426.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":267,"blockId":13,"value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":238.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":268,"blockId":13,"value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":251.04,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":269,"blockId":13,"value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":263.76,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":270,"blockId":13,"value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":276.48,"width":327.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":426.96000000000004,"Value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"26":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":271,"columnEnd":286,"text":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.120","paragraphId":"pa1.20","paragraphLabel":"1.20","rectangle":"72, 301, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","averageFontSize":8.218289085545722,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":271,"blockId":14,"value":"1.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":301.92,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":272,"blockId":14,"value":"On the same day,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":301.92,"width":75.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":273,"blockId":14,"value":"11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":301.92,"width":345.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999,"Value":"1.20 On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":274,"blockId":14,"value":"No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":314.64,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":275,"blockId":14,"value":"3,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":120.48,"y":314.64,"width":7.2,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":276,"blockId":14,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":314.4,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":277,"blockId":14,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":314.4,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":278,"blockId":14,"value":"addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.2,"y":314.4,"width":42.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":279,"blockId":14,"value":"15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":314.64,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":280,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":281,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Parties—4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":302.16,"y":315.84,"width":76.8,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":282,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":384.0,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":283,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Claimants and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":429.84,"y":315.84,"width":95.28,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties—4 questions to the Claimants and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":284,"blockId":14,"value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":100.8,"y":327.12,"width":424.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.8,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":285,"blockId":14,"value":"admissibility.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":339.6,"width":66.96,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":166.56,"Value":"admissibility.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":286,"blockId":14,"value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":352.32,"width":232.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":331.44,"Value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999}},"27":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":287,"columnEnd":293,"text":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.121","paragraphId":"pa1.21","paragraphLabel":"1.21","rectangle":"72, 377, 452, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.021645021645021,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":287,"blockId":15,"value":"1.21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":377.76,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":288,"blockId":15,"value":"On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":377.76,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.21 On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":289,"blockId":15,"value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":390.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":290,"blockId":15,"value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":402.72,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":291,"blockId":15,"value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":415.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":292,"blockId":15,"value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":429.36,"width":425.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":293,"blockId":15,"value":"Respondent did not provide any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":440.64,"width":190.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":290.15999999999997,"Value":"Respondent did not provide any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"28":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":294,"columnEnd":313,"text":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.122","paragraphId":"pa1.22","paragraphLabel":"1.22","rectangle":"72, 466, 452, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":8.05043227665706,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":294,"blockId":16,"value":"1.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":466.32,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":295,"blockId":16,"value":"A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":466.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.22 A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":296,"blockId":16,"value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":478.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":297,"blockId":16,"value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":491.28,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":298,"blockId":16,"value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":504.0,"width":331.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":299,"blockId":16,"value":"all presented by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":436.32,"y":504.0,"width":88.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":300,"blockId":16,"value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":516.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":301,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":529.2,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":302,"blockId":16,"value":"transcript was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":529.2,"width":62.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":303,"blockId":16,"value":"delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":529.2,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":304,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":250.32,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":305,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":263.28,"y":529.2,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":306,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":281.28,"y":529.2,"width":52.8,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":307,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":338.88,"y":529.2,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":308,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":356.88,"y":529.2,"width":55.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":309,"blockId":16,"value":"further granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.6,"y":529.2,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":310,"blockId":16,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":529.2,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":311,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":312,"blockId":16,"value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":541.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":313,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":554.64,"width":163.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":263.03999999999996,"Value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"29":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":314,"columnEnd":316,"text":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.123","paragraphId":"pa1.23","paragraphLabel":"1.23","rectangle":"72, 579, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":314,"blockId":17,"value":"1.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":580.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":315,"blockId":17,"value":"NThe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":367.44,"y":579.6,"width":157.92,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.23 NThe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":316,"blockId":17,"value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":592.56,"width":183.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":282.96000000000004,"Value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"30":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":317,"columnEnd":319,"text":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.124","paragraphId":"pa1.24","paragraphLabel":"1.24","rectangle":"72, 618, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.61344537815126,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":317,"blockId":18,"value":"1.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":618.0,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":318,"blockId":18,"value":"By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.24 By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":319,"blockId":18,"value":"from the Parties,|G","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":630.48,"width":358.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.15999999999997,"Value":"from the Parties,|G"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}},"31":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":320,"columnEnd":335,"text":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.25","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.25","paragraphLabel":"1.25","rectangle":"72, 655, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":7.85064935064935,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":320,"blockId":19,"value":"1.25","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":655.92,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":321,"blockId":19,"value":"On 4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":322,"blockId":19,"value":"February","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.08,"y":655.92,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":323,"blockId":19,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":175.68,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":324,"blockId":19,"value":"having","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":206.4,"y":655.92,"width":29.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":325,"blockId":19,"value":"deliberated,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":242.16,"y":655.68,"width":51.12,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":326,"blockId":19,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":655.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":327,"blockId":19,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.96,"y":655.68,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":328,"blockId":19,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":362.88,"y":655.68,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":329,"blockId":19,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.24,"y":658.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":330,"blockId":19,"value":"unanimous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":655.92,"width":47.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":331,"blockId":19,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":461.04,"y":655.68,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":332,"blockId":19,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":495.6,"y":655.92,"width":29.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":333,"blockId":19,"value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":668.64,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":334,"blockId":19,"value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":335,"blockId":19,"value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":693.84,"width":155.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":254.88,"Value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"32":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":340,"columnEnd":363,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </div><div><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </div><div><br></div><div>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</div><div>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.26","paragraphId":"pa1.26","paragraphLabel":"1.26","rectangle":"72, 115, 425, 148","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </p><p><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </p><p><br></p><p>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</p><p>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.01875,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":340,"blockId":22,"value":"1.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":115.44,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":341,"blockId":22,"value":"The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":248.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":348.48,"Value":"1.26 The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":342,"blockId":22,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":140.64,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":343,"blockId":22,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":163.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":344,"blockId":22,"value":"the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":163.44,"width":287.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":451.43999999999994,"Value":"1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":345,"blockId":22,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":186.72,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":346,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":186.48,"width":160.32,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":324.24,"Value":"2. PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":347,"blockId":22,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":209.76,"width":6.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":348,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":349,"blockId":22,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":209.52,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":350,"blockId":22,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":220.08,"y":209.52,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":351,"blockId":22,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":268.8,"y":209.52,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":352,"blockId":22,"value":"breached","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":288.48,"y":209.52,"width":36.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":353,"blockId":22,"value":"Article","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":330.72,"y":209.52,"width":27.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":354,"blockId":22,"value":"5","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":364.8,"y":209.76,"width":3.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":355,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":375.84,"y":209.52,"width":8.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":356,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":390.0,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":357,"blockId":22,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":408.24,"y":209.76,"width":25.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":358,"blockId":22,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":440.64,"y":209.52,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":359,"blockId":22,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.32,"y":210.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":360,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":209.52,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":498.0,"Value":"3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":361,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s investment.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":221.04,"width":100.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":264.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s investment."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":362,"blockId":22,"value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":245.04,"width":368.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.32,"Value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":363,"blockId":22,"value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":258.0,"width":267.12,"height":5.52,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":395.04,"Value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":498.0}},"33":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":364,"columnEnd":364,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.27","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.27","paragraphLabel":"1.27","rectangle":"72, 280, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":364,"blockId":23,"value":"11279","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":280.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999,"Value":"11279"}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999}},"34":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":365,"columnEnd":368,"text":" On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.28","paragraphId":"pa1.28","paragraphLabel":"1.28","rectangle":"72, 355, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.117647058823529,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":365,"blockId":24,"value":"1.28","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":355.2,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":366,"blockId":24,"value":"On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.2,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.28 On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":367,"blockId":24,"value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.68,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":368,"blockId":24,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":54.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":154.56,"Value":"proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},"35":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":369,"columnEnd":391,"text":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.29","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.129","paragraphId":"pa1.29","paragraphLabel":"1.29","rectangle":"72, 405, 452, 59","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","averageFontSize":8.882488479262673,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":369,"blockId":25,"value":"1.29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":405.36,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":370,"blockId":25,"value":"By","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.36,"width":12.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":371,"blockId":25,"value":"letter","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":119.04,"y":405.12,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":372,"blockId":25,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.08,"y":405.12,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":373,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":163.44,"y":405.12,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":374,"blockId":25,"value":"same","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":183.84,"y":407.76,"width":21.6,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":375,"blockId":25,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":212.4,"y":405.12,"width":20.4,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":376,"blockId":25,"value":"22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.0,"y":405.36,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":377,"blockId":25,"value":"March","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":257.52,"y":405.12,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":378,"blockId":25,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":405.36,"width":24.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":379,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":323.76,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":380,"blockId":25,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":405.12,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":381,"blockId":25,"value":"recalled","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":388.08,"y":405.12,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":382,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":429.12,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":383,"blockId":25,"value":"finding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":405.12,"width":31.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":384,"blockId":25,"value":"made","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.2,"y":405.12,"width":23.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":385,"blockId":25,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.44,"y":406.56,"width":7.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.8800000000001,"Value":"1.29 By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":386,"blockId":25,"value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":417.6,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":387,"blockId":25,"value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":430.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":388,"blockId":25,"value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":443.04,"width":390.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":389,"blockId":25,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":494.88,"y":443.28,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":390,"blockId":25,"value":"April","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":443.04,"width":22.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":391,"blockId":25,"value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.76,"width":320.64,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":420.24,"Value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}},"36":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":392,"columnEnd":419,"text":" On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going forward. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.30","paragraphId":"pa1.30","paragraphLabel":"1.30","rectangle":"72, 480, 452, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.335540838852097,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":392,"blockId":27,"value":"1.30","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":480.48,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":393,"blockId":27,"value":"On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":480.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.30 On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":394,"blockId":27,"value":"comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.4,"width":44.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":395,"blockId":27,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":492.96,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":396,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.36,"y":492.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":397,"blockId":27,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":196.56,"y":492.96,"width":54.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":398,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":492.96,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":399,"blockId":27,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":276.0,"y":492.96,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":400,"blockId":27,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":492.96,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":401,"blockId":27,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.8,"y":492.96,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":402,"blockId":27,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.08,"y":492.96,"width":46.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":403,"blockId":27,"value":"5,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":459.12,"y":493.44,"width":7.2,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":404,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":473.04,"y":492.96,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":405,"blockId":27,"value":"which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.96,"y":492.96,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":406,"blockId":27,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":519.84,"y":492.96,"width":5.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":407,"blockId":27,"value":"determined that,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.44,"width":72.72,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":408,"blockId":27,"value":"absent any reasoned","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.6,"y":505.44,"width":91.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":409,"blockId":27,"value":"application by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":274.32,"y":505.44,"width":64.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":410,"blockId":27,"value":"Finilon","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.2,"y":505.44,"width":31.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":411,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":506.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":412,"blockId":27,"value":"continue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":505.44,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":413,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":506.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":414,"blockId":27,"value":"participate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":447.84,"y":505.44,"width":46.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":415,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.2,"y":505.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":416,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":505.44,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":417,"blockId":27,"value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":518.16,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":418,"blockId":27,"value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":530.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":419,"blockId":27,"value":"forward.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":543.36,"width":36.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":136.32,"Value":"forward."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"37":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":420,"columnEnd":449,"text":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.31","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.131","paragraphId":"pa1.31","paragraphLabel":"1.31","rectangle":"72, 568, 452, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","averageFontSize":8.667431192660551,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":420,"blockId":28,"value":"1.31","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":568.32,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":421,"blockId":28,"value":"By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":568.56,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.31 By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":422,"blockId":28,"value":"useful","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":580.56,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":423,"blockId":28,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":131.52,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":424,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":425,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.28,"y":580.56,"width":81.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":426,"blockId":28,"value":"further submissions on damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":580.56,"width":146.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":427,"blockId":28,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":580.8,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":428,"blockId":28,"value":"take","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":580.56,"width":17.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":429,"blockId":28,"value":"into","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":451.44,"y":580.56,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":430,"blockId":28,"value":"account","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":473.28,"y":582.0,"width":33.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":431,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":580.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":432,"blockId":28,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":593.28,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":433,"blockId":28,"value":"findings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":593.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":434,"blockId":28,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.92,"y":593.28,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":435,"blockId":28,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":208.8,"y":593.28,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":436,"blockId":28,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":593.28,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":437,"blockId":28,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":259.68,"y":593.28,"width":29.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":438,"blockId":28,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":593.52,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":439,"blockId":28,"value":"invited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.0,"y":593.28,"width":30.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":440,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":593.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":441,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.16,"y":593.28,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":442,"blockId":28,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":420.48,"y":594.72,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":443,"blockId":28,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":593.52,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":444,"blockId":28,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":464.88,"y":593.52,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":445,"blockId":28,"value":"revised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":493.44,"y":593.28,"width":31.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":446,"blockId":28,"value":"submissions by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":606.24,"width":68.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":447,"blockId":28,"value":"19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":606.0,"width":329.04,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":448,"blockId":28,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":507.12,"y":606.0,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":449,"blockId":28,"value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.96,"width":409.68,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":509.28,"Value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"38":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":450,"columnEnd":450,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.32","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.32","paragraphLabel":"1.32","rectangle":"72, 643, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":450,"blockId":29,"value":"1.32","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":643.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.32"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},"39":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":451,"columnEnd":453,"text":" By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s extension request by 21 May 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.33","paragraphId":"pa1.33","paragraphLabel":"1.33","rectangle":"72, 680, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":9.430769230769231,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":451,"blockId":30,"value":"1.33","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":680.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":452,"blockId":30,"value":"By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":681.12,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.33 By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":453,"blockId":30,"value":"extension request by 21 May 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":693.36,"width":153.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":253.44,"Value":"extension request by 21 May 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"40":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":454,"columnEnd":454,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.34","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.34","paragraphLabel":"1.34","rectangle":"72, 718, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":454,"blockId":31,"value":"1.34","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":718.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.34"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},"41":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":459,"columnEnd":459,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.35","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.35","paragraphLabel":"1.35","rectangle":"72, 204, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":459,"blockId":32,"value":"1.35","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":204.24,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.35"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}},"42":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":460,"columnEnd":460,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36","paragraphLabel":"1.36","rectangle":"72, 495, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":460,"blockId":33,"value":"1.36","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":495.12,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.36"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},"43":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":461,"columnEnd":461,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.i","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"128, 735, 10, 8","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":461,"blockId":36,"value":"~ —--~","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":735.12,"width":10.8,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96,"Value":"~ —--~"}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96}},"44":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":466,"columnEnd":468,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"127, 115, 372, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":466,"blockId":37,"value":"<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":115.2,"width":14.16,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":142.32,"Value":"<"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":467,"blockId":37,"value":"e","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.44,"y":126.72,"width":372.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"e"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":468,"blockId":37,"value":".","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.68,"y":138.24,"width":371.76,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.68,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"."}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44}},"45":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":470,"columnEnd":474,"text":" By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37","paragraphId":"pa1.37","paragraphLabel":"1.37","rectangle":"72, 174, 452, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.886426592797784,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":470,"blockId":41,"value":"1.37","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":174.0,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":471,"blockId":41,"value":"By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":174.24,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.37 By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":472,"blockId":41,"value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":186.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":473,"blockId":41,"value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":199.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":474,"blockId":41,"value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":211.92,"width":277.92,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":377.52,"Value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"46":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":475,"columnEnd":478,"text":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.38","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37.138","paragraphId":"pa1.38","paragraphLabel":"1.38","rectangle":"72, 237, 452, 19","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","averageFontSize":7.559523809523809,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":475,"blockId":42,"value":"1.38","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":237.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":476,"blockId":42,"value":"By letter dated 4 July 2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":237.6,"width":126.0,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":477,"blockId":42,"value":"at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":230.4,"y":238.8,"width":294.48,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.38 By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":478,"blockId":42,"value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":249.84,"width":300.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":399.84000000000003,"Value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88}},"47":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":479,"columnEnd":479,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.39","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.39","paragraphLabel":"1.39","rectangle":"72, 275, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":479,"blockId":43,"value":"1.39","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":275.52,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.39"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},"48":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":480,"columnEnd":480,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.40","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.40","paragraphLabel":"1.40","rectangle":"72, 351, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":480,"blockId":44,"value":"1.40","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":351.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.40"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},"49":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":481,"columnEnd":481,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.41","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.41","paragraphLabel":"1.41","rectangle":"72, 414, 16, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":481,"blockId":45,"value":"1.41","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":414.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56,"Value":"1.41"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56}},"50":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":482,"columnEnd":499,"text":"<div>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.42","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.42o","paragraphId":"pa1.42","paragraphLabel":"1.42","rectangle":"72, 439, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</p>","averageFontSize":6.321782178217822,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":482,"blockId":46,"value":"1.42","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":439.68,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":483,"blockId":46,"value":"o<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":439.92,"width":12.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":484,"blockId":46,"value":"a.!—fi[~ (¢}=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":118.32,"y":442.32,"width":19.44,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":485,"blockId":46,"value":"Q.©-[¢}o, oN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":439.44,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":486,"blockId":46,"value":"A=t[=]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":13.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":439.92,"width":9.36,"height":13.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":487,"blockId":46,"value":"=< o) P— \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":193.68,"y":442.32,"width":29.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":488,"blockId":46,"value":"-Bo H o=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":440.88,"width":29.04,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":489,"blockId":46,"value":"c=© B o©-Q&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":264.72,"y":442.08,"width":37.68,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":490,"blockId":46,"value":"o,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.36,"y":439.44,"width":5.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":491,"blockId":46,"value":"=©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.64,"y":439.44,"width":143.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":492,"blockId":46,"value":"-=o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":440.88,"width":12.96,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.42 o< a.!—fi[~ (¢}= Q.©-[¢}o, oN A=t[=] =< o) P— \\O -Bo H o= c=© B o©-Q& o, =©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO: -=o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":493,"blockId":46,"value":">","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":224.4,"y":446.16,"width":1.44,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":494,"blockId":46,"value":"[","fontName":"Times","fontSize":2.0,"color":null,"x":328.32,"y":447.36,"width":5.76,"height":1.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":224.4,"MarginRight":334.08,"Value":"> ["},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":495,"blockId":46,"value":"’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":263.52,"y":452.64,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":263.52,"MarginRight":265.2,"Value":"’"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":496,"blockId":46,"value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.04,"width":162.72,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":497,"blockId":46,"value":"w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":455.04,"width":59.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":498,"blockId":46,"value":"2o P","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.76,"y":452.4,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":499,"blockId":46,"value":"&< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":353.28,"y":452.4,"width":90.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":443.28,"Value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8= w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@& 2o P &< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}},"51":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":500,"columnEnd":513,"text":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.43","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.143","paragraphId":"pa1.43","paragraphLabel":"1.43","rectangle":"72, 477, 452, 33","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","averageFontSize":5.817204301075269,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":500,"blockId":47,"value":"1.43","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":477.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":501,"blockId":47,"value":"low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":477.84,"width":139.68,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":502,"blockId":47,"value":"—=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":246.0,"y":478.8,"width":279.12,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.43 low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O —=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":503,"blockId":47,"value":"2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":484.08,"width":1.44,"height":2.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":241.92,"Value":"2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":504,"blockId":47,"value":"<=(=\"","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":492.96,"width":17.76,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":505,"blockId":47,"value":"Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":491.52,"width":84.72,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":506,"blockId":47,"value":"w2 a e~ >2oa","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":211.44,"y":490.56,"width":42.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":507,"blockId":47,"value":"5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":258.96,"y":490.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":508,"blockId":47,"value":"o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":492.96,"width":107.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":509,"blockId":47,"value":"o=o g=Qo<o[¢]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":431.52,"y":491.52,"width":45.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":510,"blockId":47,"value":"o= oo[oN&-o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":482.16,"y":492.96,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"<=(=\" Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo w2 a e~ >2oa 5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ» o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a» o=o g=Qo<o[¢] o= oo[oN&-o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":511,"blockId":47,"value":"s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":496.8,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":312.96,"MarginRight":314.64,"Value":"s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":512,"blockId":47,"value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.68,"width":162.48,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":513,"blockId":47,"value":"=B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":268.56,"y":505.68,"width":89.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":358.32,"Value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w =B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},"52":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":514,"columnEnd":514,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.44","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.44","paragraphLabel":"1.44","rectangle":"72, 528, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":514,"blockId":48,"value":"1.44","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":528.24,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.44"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},"53":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":515,"columnEnd":515,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.45","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.45","paragraphLabel":"1.45","rectangle":"72, 553, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":515,"blockId":49,"value":"1.45","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":553.68,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.45"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}},"54":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":516,"columnEnd":535,"text":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46","paragraphId":"pa1.46","paragraphLabel":"1.46","rectangle":"72, 692, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","averageFontSize":8.202090592334494,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":516,"blockId":50,"value":"1.46","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":692.64,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":517,"blockId":50,"value":"As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":692.88,"width":426.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.46 As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":518,"blockId":50,"value":"informed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":705.36,"width":39.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":519,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":520,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.96,"y":705.36,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":521,"blockId":50,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":705.36,"width":32.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":522,"blockId":50,"value":"numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":222.0,"y":708.0,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":523,"blockId":50,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":271.92,"y":705.36,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":524,"blockId":50,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":331.44,"y":708.0,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":525,"blockId":50,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.24,"y":705.36,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":526,"blockId":50,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":370.32,"y":705.36,"width":21.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":527,"blockId":50,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":398.16,"y":706.56,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":528,"blockId":50,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.04,"y":705.36,"width":20.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":529,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":440.16,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":530,"blockId":50,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":705.36,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":531,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":532,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":495.12,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":533,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":705.36,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":534,"blockId":50,"value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":718.08,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":535,"blockId":50,"value":"the present Order.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":730.8,"width":78.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":177.84,"Value":"the present Order."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},"55":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":540,"columnEnd":540,"text":" Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h2","paragraphIdAuto":"hThe","paragraphId":"h2","paragraphLabel":"2.","rectangle":"99, 115, 176, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":540,"blockId":51,"value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.92,"width":176.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48}},"56":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":543,"columnEnd":563,"text":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><span class=\"supertext\">1</span></a>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.2","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.To","paragraphId":"pa2.2","paragraphLabel":"2.2","rectangle":"99, 254, 425, 108","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><sup>1</sup></a>","averageFontSize":7.9171597633136095,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":543,"blockId":54,"value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":544,"blockId":54,"value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":269.04,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":545,"blockId":54,"value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.12,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":546,"blockId":54,"value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":291.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":547,"blockId":54,"value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":304.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":548,"blockId":54,"value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.04,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility."},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":549,"blockId":54,"value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":550,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":551,"blockId":54,"value":"remained","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":342.48,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":552,"blockId":54,"value":"outstanding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.0,"y":342.48,"width":51.12,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":553,"blockId":54,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":342.48,"width":19.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":554,"blockId":54,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":342.48,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":555,"blockId":54,"value":"Interim Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":342.48,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":556,"blockId":54,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":339.36,"y":342.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":557,"blockId":54,"value":"found","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.96,"y":342.48,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":558,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":559,"blockId":54,"value":"“it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.0,"y":342.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":560,"blockId":54,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":430.32,"y":342.48,"width":14.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":561,"blockId":54,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":342.48,"width":50.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":562,"blockId":54,"value":"over","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":506.16,"y":345.12,"width":19.2,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that “it has jurisdiction over"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":563,"blockId":54,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":354.96,"width":380.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":480.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},"57":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":541,"columnEnd":542,"text":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.i","paragraphIdAuto":"hi","paragraphId":"h2.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"96, 227, 319, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","averageFontSize":8.19047619047619,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":541,"blockId":55,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":227.52,"width":12.0,"height":12.0,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":542,"blockId":55,"value":"The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":228.48,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997,"Value":"(i) The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997}},"58":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":564,"columnEnd":573,"text":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.3","paragraphLabel":"2.3","rectangle":"99, 380, 425, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.03,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":564,"blockId":58,"value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":565,"blockId":58,"value":"from which the Tribunal derives","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":393.12,"width":145.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":566,"blockId":58,"value":"its jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":393.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":567,"blockId":58,"value":"the “arbitral award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":393.12,"width":84.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":568,"blockId":58,"value":"shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":393.12,"width":115.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the “arbitral award shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":569,"blockId":58,"value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":408.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":570,"blockId":58,"value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":571,"blockId":58,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":433.92,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":572,"blockId":58,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.44,"y":431.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":573,"blockId":58,"value":"parties.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":431.04,"width":36.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":169.92,"Value":"on the parties.”"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},"59":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":574,"columnEnd":580,"text":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.4","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.It","paragraphId":"pa2.4","paragraphLabel":"2.4","rectangle":"99, 481, 426, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","averageFontSize":7.6716417910447765,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":574,"blockId":59,"value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":481.92,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":575,"blockId":59,"value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":494.16,"width":426.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":576,"blockId":59,"value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.88,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":577,"blockId":59,"value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":521.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":578,"blockId":59,"value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":532.08,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":579,"blockId":59,"value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":544.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":580,"blockId":59,"value":"the Tribunal in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.52,"width":117.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":216.95999999999998,"Value":"the Tribunal in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}},"60":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":581,"columnEnd":583,"text":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.6","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.6","paragraphLabel":"2.6","rectangle":"99, 680, 425, 22","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","averageFontSize":8.870466321243523,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":581,"blockId":61,"value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":680.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":582,"blockId":61,"value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":693.36,"width":382.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":583,"blockId":61,"value":"evidence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.72,"y":693.36,"width":38.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’ evidence"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}},"61":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":584,"columnEnd":586,"text":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn1","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"fn1","paragraphLabel":"1","rectangle":"72, 737, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":584,"blockId":63,"value":"! Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":72.0,"y":737.76,"width":62.64,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"! Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":585,"blockId":63,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":740.88,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":586,"blockId":63,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":738.48,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":205.2}},"62":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":591,"columnEnd":597,"text":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.889855072463767,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":591,"blockId":66,"value":"and argument over the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":102.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":592,"blockId":66,"value":"last two phases of the proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":115.44,"width":159.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":593,"blockId":66,"value":"in particular by putting numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":115.44,"width":152.64,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":594,"blockId":66,"value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":174.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":595,"blockId":66,"value":"1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.88,"y":127.92,"width":246.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":596,"blockId":66,"value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":142.08,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":597,"blockId":66,"value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":286.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":386.64,"Value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},"63":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":598,"columnEnd":681,"text":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><span class=\"supertext\">4</span></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.7","paragraphId":"pa2.7","paragraphLabel":"2.7","rectangle":"71, 178, 455, 276","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><sup>4</sup></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","averageFontSize":8.661600810536981,"rowsOfText":22,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":598,"blockId":67,"value":"2.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":178.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":599,"blockId":67,"value":"Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.8,"width":425.52,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.7 Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":600,"blockId":67,"value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":601,"blockId":67,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":602,"blockId":67,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":206.64,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":603,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.24,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":604,"blockId":67,"value":"of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":204.0,"width":84.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":605,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":294.48,"y":204.0,"width":56.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":606,"blockId":67,"value":"(as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":204.0,"width":12.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":607,"blockId":67,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":373.2,"y":204.0,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":608,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":206.64,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":609,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":610,"blockId":67,"value":"of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":611,"blockId":67,"value":"Thus,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":612,"blockId":67,"value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":613,"blockId":67,"value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":614,"blockId":67,"value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":244.56,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":615,"blockId":67,"value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":254.64,"width":350.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":616,"blockId":67,"value":"(ii1) granted the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":254.4,"width":70.08,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":617,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":618,"blockId":67,"value":"issues,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.84,"width":28.32,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":619,"blockId":67,"value":"including with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":279.84,"width":64.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":620,"blockId":67,"value":"respect to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":281.04,"width":43.44,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":621,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":279.84,"width":114.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":622,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":370.56,"y":279.84,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":623,"blockId":67,"value":"(as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":280.08,"width":35.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":624,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":282.48,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":625,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.0,"y":279.84,"width":40.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":626,"blockId":67,"value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":627,"blockId":67,"value":"pleadings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":41.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":628,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":146.88,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":629,"blockId":67,"value":"other communications","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.76,"y":305.04,"width":99.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":630,"blockId":67,"value":"from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":305.04,"width":39.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":631,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":317.28,"y":305.04,"width":42.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":632,"blockId":67,"value":"including","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":305.04,"width":41.04,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":633,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":411.36,"y":305.04,"width":19.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":634,"blockId":67,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":435.84,"y":306.48,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":635,"blockId":67,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":471.84,"y":306.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":636,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.52,"y":305.04,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":637,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":516.48,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":638,"blockId":67,"value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":317.76,"width":426.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":639,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.24,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":640,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant, to comment on the proposed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":117.84,"y":330.24,"width":180.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":641,"blockId":67,"value":"candidacy,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":302.88,"y":330.24,"width":46.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":642,"blockId":67,"value":"terms","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":331.44,"width":23.76,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":643,"blockId":67,"value":"of reference and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":383.52,"y":330.24,"width":74.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":644,"blockId":67,"value":"reports of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":463.2,"y":331.68,"width":61.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":645,"blockId":67,"value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":646,"blockId":67,"value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":647,"blockId":67,"value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":368.16,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":648,"blockId":67,"value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":380.88,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":649,"blockId":67,"value":"timely","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":27.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":650,"blockId":67,"value":"manner,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":396.24,"width":35.04,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":651,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":393.6,"width":19.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":652,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":653,"blockId":67,"value":"transcripts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":216.24,"y":393.6,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":654,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":267.36,"y":393.6,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":655,"blockId":67,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":288.24,"y":393.6,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":656,"blockId":67,"value":"other documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":304.08,"y":393.6,"width":74.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":657,"blockId":67,"value":"submitted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":393.6,"width":42.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":658,"blockId":67,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":432.72,"y":393.6,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":659,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":445.92,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":660,"blockId":67,"value":"course","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":464.4,"y":396.24,"width":28.32,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":661,"blockId":67,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":393.6,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":662,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":406.08,"width":39.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":663,"blockId":67,"value":"and (vii) provided an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":406.08,"width":97.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":664,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunity","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":247.2,"y":406.08,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":665,"blockId":67,"value":"for, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.12,"y":406.08,"width":35.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":666,"blockId":75,"value":"invited, the Respondent to comment on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":406.08,"width":181.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":667,"blockId":67,"value":"anything","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":418.8,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":668,"blockId":67,"value":"said","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":418.8,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":669,"blockId":67,"value":"during","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.48,"y":418.8,"width":28.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":670,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":418.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":671,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings.*","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":418.08,"width":43.44,"height":11.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":672,"blockId":67,"value":"The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.88,"y":419.04,"width":16.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":673,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":296.16,"y":419.04,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":674,"blockId":67,"value":"did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.24,"y":419.04,"width":13.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":675,"blockId":67,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":420.48,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":676,"blockId":67,"value":"avail","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.8,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":677,"blockId":67,"value":"itself of any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":422.4,"y":419.04,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":678,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":419.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":679,"blockId":67,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.8,"y":419.04,"width":22.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"anything said during the hearings.* The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":680,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":681,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility (or issues of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":444.24,"width":155.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":255.6,"Value":"admissibility (or issues of liability)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}},"64":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":682,"columnEnd":687,"text":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.8","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.28","paragraphId":"pa2.8","paragraphLabel":"2.8","rectangle":"71, 469, 453, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.450777202072539,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":682,"blockId":68,"value":"2.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":469.68,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":683,"blockId":68,"value":"Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.8 Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":684,"blockId":68,"value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":685,"blockId":68,"value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":686,"blockId":68,"value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":687,"blockId":68,"value":"|||><g&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":48.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":520.56,"width":34.08,"height":47.76,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":133.2,"Value":"|||><g&"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},"65":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":688,"columnEnd":707,"text":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.9","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.9","paragraphLabel":"2.9","rectangle":"71, 583, 454, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","averageFontSize":8.710526315789474,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":688,"blockId":69,"value":"29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":689,"blockId":69,"value":"The Tribunal is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":70.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":690,"blockId":69,"value":"also mindful of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.96,"y":583.2,"width":86.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":691,"blockId":69,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.88,"y":583.2,"width":47.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":692,"blockId":69,"value":"interest","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":583.2,"width":31.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":693,"blockId":69,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":583.2,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":694,"blockId":69,"value":"the finality of the Awards and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":368.64,"y":583.2,"width":156.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"29 The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant’s interest in the finality of the Awards and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":695,"blockId":69,"value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":696,"blockId":69,"value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":697,"blockId":69,"value":"jurisdiction were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":621.12,"width":77.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":698,"blockId":69,"value":"granted. Moreover, now","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":621.36,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":699,"blockId":69,"value":"that the Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":621.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":700,"blockId":69,"value":"courts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":367.2,"y":622.56,"width":26.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":701,"blockId":69,"value":"are","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":624.0,"width":12.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":702,"blockId":69,"value":"seised of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.12,"y":621.12,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":703,"blockId":69,"value":"Set Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":481.44,"y":621.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":704,"blockId":69,"value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":634.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":705,"blockId":69,"value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":706,"blockId":69,"value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":707,"blockId":69,"value":"supervisory jurisdiction.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":672.0,"width":105.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":205.68,"Value":"supervisory jurisdiction."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"66":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":712,"columnEnd":715,"text":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"fn4","paragraphId":"fn4","paragraphLabel":"4","rectangle":"71, 760, 228, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","averageFontSize":6.722222222222222,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":712,"blockId":72,"value":"4 See Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":760.56,"width":83.28,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":154.32,"Value":"4 See Interim Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":713,"blockId":72,"value":"para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":763.92,"width":19.2,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":714,"blockId":72,"value":"154; Partial Award, para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":180.96,"y":761.52,"width":99.12,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":715,"blockId":72,"value":"176.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":284.64,"y":761.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":157.44,"MarginRight":300.0,"Value":"para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176."}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":300.0}},"67":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":708,"columnEnd":711,"text":" In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10","paragraphId":"pa2.10","paragraphLabel":"2.10","rectangle":"71, 697, 454, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":7.674496644295302,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":708,"blockId":73,"value":"2.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":697.44,"width":18.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":6,"id":709,"blockId":73,"value":"In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":697.68,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.10 In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":710,"blockId":73,"value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":711,"blockId":73,"value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal"}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":525.12}},"68":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":720,"columnEnd":724,"text":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa","paragraphIdAuto":"pai.in","paragraphId":"pa","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 147, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.84,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":720,"blockId":74,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.44,"width":8.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":721,"blockId":74,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.68,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":722,"blockId":74,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":115.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":723,"blockId":74,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.92,"y":115.44,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":724,"blockId":74,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":115.44,"width":55.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96,"Value":"in the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96}},"69":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":725,"columnEnd":733,"text":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.211","paragraphId":"pa2.11","paragraphLabel":"2.11","rectangle":"71, 166, 453, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","averageFontSize":9.064615384615385,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":725,"blockId":76,"value":"2.11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":88.8,"Value":"2.11"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":726,"blockId":76,"value":"he Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":474.72,"y":178.56,"width":50.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":474.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"he Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":727,"blockId":76,"value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":728,"blockId":76,"value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":729,"blockId":76,"value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.48,"width":189.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":730,"blockId":76,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":216.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":731,"blockId":76,"value":"other applicable jurisdictional and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":308.88,"y":216.48,"width":155.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":732,"blockId":76,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":468.72,"y":216.48,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":733,"blockId":76,"value":"requirements under the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":134.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":234.48,"Value":"requirements under the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},"70":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":734,"columnEnd":765,"text":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.12","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.212","paragraphId":"pa2.12","paragraphLabel":"2.12","rectangle":"71, 254, 454, 172","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","averageFontSize":9.06353591160221,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":734,"blockId":79,"value":"2.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":254.64,"width":18.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.12"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":735,"blockId":79,"value":"IAlthough the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":330.48,"width":102.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":736,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":207.12,"y":330.48,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":737,"blockId":79,"value":"could","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":264.24,"y":330.48,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":738,"blockId":79,"value":"have","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":330.48,"width":20.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":739,"blockId":79,"value":"raised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":330.48,"width":25.92,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":740,"blockId":79,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":330.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":741,"blockId":79,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":330.48,"width":21.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":742,"blockId":79,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":399.36,"y":331.92,"width":7.44,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":743,"blockId":79,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":412.32,"y":333.12,"width":9.84,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":744,"blockId":79,"value":"earlier","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":427.92,"y":330.48,"width":27.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":745,"blockId":79,"value":"stage","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":461.28,"y":331.92,"width":21.84,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":746,"blockId":79,"value":"of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":330.48,"width":36.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"IAlthough the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":747,"blockId":79,"value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.96,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":748,"blockId":79,"value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":749,"blockId":79,"value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":368.4,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":750,"blockId":79,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":382.56,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":751,"blockId":79,"value":"minimize","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.48,"y":381.12,"width":40.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":752,"blockId":79,"value":"any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":161.76,"y":383.76,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":753,"blockId":79,"value":"delay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":183.6,"y":381.12,"width":23.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":754,"blockId":79,"value":"resulting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":213.6,"y":381.12,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":755,"blockId":79,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":258.24,"y":381.12,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":756,"blockId":79,"value":"such","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.6,"y":381.12,"width":19.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":757,"blockId":79,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":311.76,"y":381.12,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":758,"blockId":79,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":381.12,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":759,"blockId":79,"value":"given","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":393.36,"y":381.12,"width":23.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":760,"blockId":79,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":423.6,"y":381.12,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":761,"blockId":79,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":381.12,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":762,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":465.6,"y":381.12,"width":59.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":763,"blockId":79,"value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":395.04,"width":425.28,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":764,"blockId":79,"value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.32,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":765,"blockId":79,"value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":419.04,"width":424.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"71":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":766,"columnEnd":781,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:13","paragraphId":"pa2.13","paragraphLabel":"2:13","rectangle":"71, 444, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","averageFontSize":8.380434782608695,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":766,"blockId":80,"value":"2:13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":444.48,"width":18.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":767,"blockId":80,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:13 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":768,"blockId":80,"value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":769,"blockId":80,"value":"paragraph","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":43.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":770,"blockId":80,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.76,"y":469.68,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":771,"blockId":80,"value":"below)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.72,"y":469.44,"width":30.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":772,"blockId":80,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":211.2,"y":469.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":773,"blockId":80,"value":"Respondent may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":230.88,"y":469.44,"width":76.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":774,"blockId":80,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":313.44,"y":469.44,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":775,"blockId":80,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.44,"y":469.44,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":776,"blockId":80,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.2,"y":469.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":777,"blockId":80,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":417.36,"y":470.88,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":778,"blockId":80,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.56,"y":469.44,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":779,"blockId":80,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":469.92,"y":469.44,"width":9.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":780,"blockId":80,"value":"Illegality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":486.24,"y":469.44,"width":39.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":781,"blockId":80,"value":"Objection.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":144.95999999999998,"Value":"Objection."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"72":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":782,"columnEnd":783,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.ii","paragraphIdAuto":"hii","paragraphId":"h2.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"96, 506, 269, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","averageFontSize":8.307692307692308,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":782,"blockId":81,"value":"(ii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":506.64,"width":15.12,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":783,"blockId":81,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":507.36,"width":229.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24,"Value":"(ii) The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24}},"73":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":784,"columnEnd":799,"text":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.214","paragraphId":"pa2.14","paragraphLabel":"2.14","rectangle":"71, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.7631578947368425,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":784,"blockId":82,"value":"2.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":532.8,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":785,"blockId":82,"value":"In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":533.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.14 In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":786,"blockId":82,"value":"requests","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":546.72,"width":35.52,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":787,"blockId":82,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":141.84,"y":545.28,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":788,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.4,"y":545.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":789,"blockId":82,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":184.08,"y":545.28,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":790,"blockId":82,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":228.24,"y":546.72,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":791,"blockId":82,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":545.28,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":792,"blockId":82,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":280.32,"y":545.28,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":793,"blockId":82,"value":"pending","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":545.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":794,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":381.36,"y":545.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":795,"blockId":82,"value":"outcome","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":401.04,"y":546.72,"width":37.2,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":796,"blockId":82,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":444.96,"y":545.28,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":797,"blockId":82,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":480.0,"y":545.76,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":798,"blockId":82,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":545.28,"width":24.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":799,"blockId":82,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":55.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":155.28,"Value":"Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"74":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":800,"columnEnd":806,"text":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.15","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.215","paragraphId":"pa2.15","paragraphLabel":"2.15","rectangle":"71, 583, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":8.451965065502183,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":800,"blockId":83,"value":"2.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":801,"blockId":83,"value":"The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.44,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.15 The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":802,"blockId":83,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":596.4,"width":351.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":803,"blockId":83,"value":"law, that would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":596.16,"width":69.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":804,"blockId":83,"value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":805,"blockId":83,"value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":806,"blockId":83,"value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":635.28,"width":313.44,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":413.28,"Value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},"75":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":807,"columnEnd":817,"text":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:16","paragraphId":"pa2.16","paragraphLabel":"2.16","rectangle":"71, 659, 453, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","averageFontSize":8.691358024691358,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":807,"blockId":84,"value":"2:16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":659.52,"width":18.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":808,"blockId":84,"value":"The Tribunal considers that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":124.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":809,"blockId":84,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":659.52,"width":5.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":810,"blockId":84,"value":"is for the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.8,"y":659.52,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":811,"blockId":84,"value":"establish that a stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.56,"y":659.52,"width":89.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":812,"blockId":84,"value":"is justified by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":659.52,"width":78.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:16 The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":813,"blockId":84,"value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":672.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":814,"blockId":84,"value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":815,"blockId":84,"value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":816,"blockId":84,"value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":817,"blockId":84,"value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":375.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":475.20000000000005,"Value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},"76":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":818,"columnEnd":819,"text":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn5","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.10.5","paragraphId":"fn5","paragraphLabel":"5","rectangle":"71, 760, 104, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","averageFontSize":5.038461538461538,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":818,"blockId":85,"value":"5 Set Aside Writ,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":66.96,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":138.24,"Value":"5 Set Aside Writ,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":819,"blockId":85,"value":"para. 83.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":141.36,"y":763.92,"width":34.08,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":141.36,"MarginRight":175.44,"Value":"para. 83."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":175.44}},"77":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":824,"columnEnd":824,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.17","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.17","paragraphLabel":"2.17","rectangle":"71, 127, 18, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":824,"blockId":86,"value":"2.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":127.92,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.17"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76}},"78":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":825,"columnEnd":853,"text":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.18","paragraphId":"pa2.18","paragraphLabel":"2.18","rectangle":"71, 166, 455, 95","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","averageFontSize":8.048780487804878,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":825,"blockId":87,"value":"2.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":826,"blockId":87,"value":"The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":166.08,"width":215.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":827,"blockId":87,"value":"success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.92,"y":166.08,"width":205.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.18 The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":828,"blockId":87,"value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":179.76,"width":425.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":829,"blockId":87,"value":"deciding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":37.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":830,"blockId":87,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.32,"y":191.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":831,"blockId":87,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":160.8,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":832,"blockId":87,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":225.84,"y":192.48,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":833,"blockId":87,"value":"aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":242.64,"y":191.28,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":834,"blockId":87,"value":"application under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":270.24,"y":191.28,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":835,"blockId":87,"value":"law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":385.68,"y":191.28,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":836,"blockId":87,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":837,"blockId":87,"value":"accordingly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":191.28,"width":51.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"deciding the Respondent’s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":838,"blockId":87,"value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":839,"blockId":87,"value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":840,"blockId":87,"value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":229.2,"width":426.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":841,"blockId":87,"value":"Appeal,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":33.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":842,"blockId":87,"value":"ought","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":139.68,"y":241.92,"width":24.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":843,"blockId":87,"value":"nevertheless","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":169.92,"y":241.92,"width":53.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":844,"blockId":87,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":243.12,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":845,"blockId":87,"value":"consider","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.36,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":846,"blockId":87,"value":"whether","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.84,"y":241.92,"width":35.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":847,"blockId":87,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":326.64,"y":244.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":848,"blockId":87,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":337.2,"y":243.12,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":849,"blockId":87,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.0,"y":241.92,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":850,"blockId":87,"value":"proceedings may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":389.76,"y":241.92,"width":77.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":851,"blockId":87,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":852,"blockId":87,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.04,"y":241.92,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":853,"blockId":87,"value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.4,"width":250.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":350.4,"Value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},"79":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":854,"columnEnd":897,"text":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.219","paragraphId":"pa2.19","paragraphLabel":"2.19","rectangle":"71, 279, 455, 86","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","averageFontSize":9.113138686131387,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":854,"blockId":88,"value":"2.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":280.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":855,"blockId":88,"value":"Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.19 Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":856,"blockId":88,"value":"jurisdictional","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":292.56,"width":58.56,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":857,"blockId":88,"value":"objections","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":292.56,"width":44.64,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":858,"blockId":88,"value":"summarized","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":292.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":859,"blockId":88,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":277.44,"y":292.56,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":860,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":292.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":861,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":292.56,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":862,"blockId":88,"value":"recent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.68,"y":294.0,"width":26.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":863,"blockId":88,"value":"correspondence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.52,"y":292.56,"width":68.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":864,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":292.56,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":865,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":292.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent’s recent correspondence and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":866,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":867,"blockId":88,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":166.08,"y":305.28,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":868,"blockId":88,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":185.76,"y":305.04,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":869,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":217.68,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":870,"blockId":88,"value":"Revocation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":305.04,"width":49.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":871,"blockId":88,"value":"Writs,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":305.04,"width":26.64,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":872,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.04,"y":305.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":873,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":305.04,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":874,"blockId":88,"value":"concludes","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":305.04,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":875,"blockId":88,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.56,"y":305.04,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":876,"blockId":88,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":465.36,"y":307.68,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":877,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":476.4,"y":306.48,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":878,"blockId":88,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":879,"blockId":88,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.52,"y":305.04,"width":9.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":880,"blockId":88,"value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":881,"blockId":88,"value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":882,"blockId":88,"value":"failure","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":883,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":344.4,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":884,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":147.6,"y":344.4,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":885,"blockId":88,"value":"impede","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.4,"y":342.96,"width":31.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":886,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.84,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":887,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":226.56,"y":342.96,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":888,"blockId":88,"value":"ability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":277.92,"y":342.96,"width":27.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":889,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":311.04,"y":344.16,"width":7.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":890,"blockId":88,"value":"fully","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":324.96,"y":342.96,"width":20.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":891,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.64,"y":342.96,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":892,"blockId":88,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":342.96,"width":37.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":893,"blockId":88,"value":"examine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.48,"y":342.96,"width":36.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":894,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":456.96,"y":342.96,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":895,"blockId":88,"value":"decide","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":478.08,"y":342.96,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":896,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"failure to stay impede the Tribunal’s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":897,"blockId":88,"value":"remaining issues before it.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":115.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":214.8,"Value":"remaining issues before it."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},"80":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":898,"columnEnd":900,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.220","paragraphId":"pa2.20","paragraphLabel":"2.20","rectangle":"71, 380, 453, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.451851851851852,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":898,"blockId":89,"value":"2.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":381.12,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":899,"blockId":89,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.20 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":900,"blockId":89,"value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":395.04,"width":169.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":269.52,"Value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88}},"81":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":901,"columnEnd":903,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.iii","paragraphIdAuto":"h2.220.iii","paragraphId":"h2.iii","paragraphLabel":"(iii)","rectangle":"96, 417, 427, 21","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","averageFontSize":8.176991150442477,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":901,"blockId":90,"value":"(iii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":417.84,"width":16.56,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":902,"blockId":90,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.56,"y":418.8,"width":388.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"(iii) The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":903,"blockId":90,"value":"the Merits and Quantum","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":135.84,"y":431.52,"width":107.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":135.84,"MarginRight":243.12,"Value":"the Merits and Quantum"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64}},"82":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":904,"columnEnd":908,"text":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.2220","paragraphId":"pa2.21","paragraphLabel":"2.21","rectangle":"71, 456, 453, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","averageFontSize":8.532212885154062,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":904,"blockId":91,"value":"2220","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":456.96,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":905,"blockId":91,"value":"Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2220 Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":906,"blockId":91,"value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":907,"blockId":91,"value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":908,"blockId":91,"value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.64,"width":300.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":400.32000000000005,"Value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},"83":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":909,"columnEnd":949,"text":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><span class=\"supertext\">7</span></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.222","paragraphId":"pa2.22","paragraphLabel":"2.22","rectangle":"71, 520, 455, 149","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><sup>7</sup></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","averageFontSize":8.214634146341464,"rowsOfText":12,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":909,"blockId":92,"value":"2.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":520.32,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":910,"blockId":92,"value":"In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":520.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.22 In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":911,"blockId":92,"value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":912,"blockId":92,"value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.52,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":913,"blockId":92,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":558.0,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":914,"blockId":92,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":158.88,"y":558.0,"width":6.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":915,"blockId":92,"value":"unwarranted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":171.6,"y":558.0,"width":54.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":916,"blockId":92,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":232.8,"y":558.0,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":917,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":246.72,"y":558.0,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":918,"blockId":92,"value":"present","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":559.2,"width":31.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":919,"blockId":92,"value":"circumstances","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":303.6,"y":558.0,"width":61.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":920,"blockId":92,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.0,"y":558.0,"width":12.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":921,"blockId":92,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":390.24,"y":558.0,"width":10.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":922,"blockId":92,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":407.04,"y":558.0,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":923,"blockId":92,"value":"reasons","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":441.12,"y":560.88,"width":32.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":924,"blockId":92,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":559.44,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":925,"blockId":92,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":559.44,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":926,"blockId":92,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.68,"y":559.44,"width":7.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.3599999999999,"Value":"proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":927,"blockId":92,"value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":928,"blockId":92,"value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":583.44,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":929,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":595.92,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":930,"blockId":92,"value":"regarding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":159.12,"y":595.92,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":931,"blockId":92,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":595.92,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":932,"blockId":92,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":595.92,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":933,"blockId":92,"value":"liability.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":595.92,"width":35.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":934,"blockId":92,"value":"As","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":296.88,"y":596.4,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":935,"blockId":92,"value":"with jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":314.88,"y":595.92,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":936,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":937,"blockId":92,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":418.32,"y":596.16,"width":51.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":938,"blockId":92,"value":"missed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.92,"y":595.92,"width":30.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":939,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":940,"blockId":92,"value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":611.52,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":941,"blockId":92,"value":"any compelling reason why it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.36,"width":137.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":942,"blockId":92,"value":"should now be allowed to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.36,"width":147.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":943,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":395.04,"y":621.36,"width":53.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":944,"blockId":92,"value":"long","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":453.6,"y":621.6,"width":18.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":945,"blockId":92,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":477.36,"y":621.36,"width":20.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":946,"blockId":92,"value":"those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":621.6,"width":22.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":947,"blockId":92,"value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":633.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":948,"blockId":92,"value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":949,"blockId":92,"value":"granted.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":34.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":134.39999999999998,"Value":"granted."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.56}},"84":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":955,"columnEnd":957,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn7","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.7","paragraphId":"fn7","paragraphLabel":"7","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":955,"blockId":93,"value":"7 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":63.36,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"7 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":956,"blockId":93,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":957,"blockId":93,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}},"85":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":950,"columnEnd":953,"text":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.223","paragraphId":"pa2.23","paragraphLabel":"2.23","rectangle":"71, 684, 454, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","averageFontSize":7.683848797250859,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":950,"blockId":95,"value":"2.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":684.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":951,"blockId":95,"value":"The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.23 The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":952,"blockId":95,"value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":953,"blockId":95,"value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}},"86":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":962,"columnEnd":970,"text":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><span class=\"supertext\">8</span></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 426, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><sup>8</sup></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","averageFontSize":8.88030888030888,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":962,"blockId":96,"value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":963,"blockId":96,"value":"event that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":44.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":964,"blockId":96,"value":"liability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":127.92,"width":34.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":965,"blockId":96,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":186.72,"y":127.92,"width":6.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":966,"blockId":96,"value":"established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":127.92,"width":328.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":967,"blockId":96,"value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":968,"blockId":96,"value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":969,"blockId":96,"value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":166.08,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":970,"blockId":96,"value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.56,"width":175.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":275.03999999999996,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}},"87":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":971,"columnEnd":988,"text":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.224","paragraphId":"pa2.24","paragraphLabel":"2.24","rectangle":"71, 204, 454, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","averageFontSize":9.137142857142857,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":971,"blockId":97,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":204.0,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":972,"blockId":97,"value":"In","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":8.64,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":973,"blockId":97,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.72,"y":204.0,"width":22.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":974,"blockId":97,"value":"circumstances,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":143.52,"y":204.0,"width":64.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":975,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":976,"blockId":97,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":234.24,"y":204.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":977,"blockId":97,"value":"considers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":204.0,"width":40.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":978,"blockId":97,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":325.68,"y":204.0,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":979,"blockId":97,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":204.0,"width":5.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":980,"blockId":97,"value":"would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.48,"y":204.0,"width":27.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":981,"blockId":97,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.08,"y":204.0,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":982,"blockId":97,"value":"appropriate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":410.64,"y":204.0,"width":49.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":983,"blockId":97,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":466.56,"y":205.2,"width":8.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":984,"blockId":97,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.68,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":985,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.24 In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":986,"blockId":97,"value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":987,"blockId":97,"value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":988,"blockId":97,"value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":376.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":476.15999999999997,"Value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"88":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":989,"columnEnd":1018,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.25","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.225","paragraphId":"pa2.25","paragraphLabel":"2.25","rectangle":"71, 267, 454, 136","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","averageFontSize":7.852441613588111,"rowsOfText":11,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":989,"blockId":98,"value":"225","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":267.12,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":990,"blockId":98,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"225 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":991,"blockId":98,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":47.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":992,"blockId":98,"value":"claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":153.12,"y":279.84,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":993,"blockId":98,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.24,"y":279.84,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":994,"blockId":98,"value":"merits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":279.84,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":995,"blockId":98,"value":"and quantum insofar","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":249.36,"y":279.84,"width":94.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":996,"blockId":98,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":349.2,"y":282.48,"width":8.64,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":997,"blockId":98,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.36,"y":279.84,"width":5.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":998,"blockId":98,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":279.84,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":999,"blockId":98,"value":"seeks","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":386.88,"y":279.84,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1000,"blockId":98,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":282.48,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1001,"blockId":98,"value":"reconsideration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":425.04,"y":279.84,"width":67.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1002,"blockId":98,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":279.84,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1003,"blockId":98,"value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":292.56,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1004,"blockId":98,"value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1005,"blockId":98,"value":"the issues of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":140.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1006,"blockId":98,"value":"in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":317.76,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1007,"blockId":98,"value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.48,"width":308.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1008,"blockId":98,"value":"legal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":330.48,"width":20.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1009,"blockId":98,"value":"authorities,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":438.96,"y":330.48,"width":48.48,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1010,"blockId":98,"value":"witness","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":492.48,"y":330.48,"width":32.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1011,"blockId":98,"value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":344.4,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1012,"blockId":98,"value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":198.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1013,"blockId":98,"value":"above, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.84,"y":355.68,"width":45.6,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1014,"blockId":98,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":355.68,"width":32.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1015,"blockId":98,"value":"submissions on compensation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":355.68,"width":133.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1016,"blockId":98,"value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":370.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1017,"blockId":98,"value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1018,"blockId":98,"value":"witnesses, if any.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":74.88,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":174.48,"Value":"witnesses, if any."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},"89":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1019,"columnEnd":1033,"text":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.26","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.226","paragraphId":"pa2.26","paragraphLabel":"2.26","rectangle":"71, 419, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","averageFontSize":9.5423197492163,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1019,"blockId":99,"value":"2.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":419.28,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1020,"blockId":99,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":419.04,"width":59.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1021,"blockId":99,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":419.04,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1022,"blockId":99,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.48,"y":419.04,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1023,"blockId":99,"value":"Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":419.04,"width":29.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1024,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":251.52,"y":420.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1025,"blockId":99,"value":"revert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":264.96,"y":420.48,"width":25.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1026,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":420.48,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1027,"blockId":99,"value":"it by Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":309.12,"y":419.04,"width":68.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1028,"blockId":99,"value":"23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.8,"y":419.28,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1029,"blockId":99,"value":"September 2019 with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":419.04,"width":101.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1030,"blockId":99,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":505.2,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"2.26 The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by Monday, 23 September 2019 with their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1031,"blockId":99,"value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1032,"blockId":99,"value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1033,"blockId":99,"value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.96,"width":196.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":296.4,"Value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}},"90":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1034,"columnEnd":1084,"text":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.27","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.227","paragraphId":"pa2.27","paragraphLabel":"2.27","rectangle":"71, 482, 455, 109","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","averageFontSize":8.516083916083916,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1034,"blockId":100,"value":"227","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":482.4,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1035,"blockId":100,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":59.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1036,"blockId":100,"value":"further reminds","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":482.16,"width":69.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1037,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.56,"y":482.16,"width":90.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1038,"blockId":100,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":334.56,"y":482.16,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1039,"blockId":100,"value":"share","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":349.44,"y":482.16,"width":22.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1040,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":377.28,"y":482.16,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1041,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":482.16,"width":35.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1042,"blockId":100,"value":"requested by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.52,"y":482.16,"width":75.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"227 The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1043,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal in these proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":135.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1044,"blockId":100,"value":"in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":494.88,"width":284.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1045,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":51.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1046,"blockId":100,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":507.6,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1047,"blockId":100,"value":"requested","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.16,"y":507.6,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1048,"blockId":100,"value":"to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":218.16,"y":509.04,"width":37.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1049,"blockId":100,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":261.84,"y":507.6,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1050,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":290.4,"y":507.6,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1051,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.16,"y":507.6,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1052,"blockId":100,"value":"fulfilment","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.32,"y":507.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1053,"blockId":100,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.0,"y":507.6,"width":24.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1054,"blockId":100,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":426.72,"y":507.6,"width":48.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1055,"blockId":100,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.2,"y":507.6,"width":25.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1056,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":507.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1057,"blockId":100,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":520.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1058,"blockId":100,"value":"necessary","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":535.68,"width":42.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1059,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":532.8,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1060,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1061,"blockId":100,"value":"light","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":532.8,"width":19.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1062,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":532.8,"width":27.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1063,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.96,"y":532.8,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1064,"blockId":100,"value":"above","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":532.8,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1065,"blockId":100,"value":"decision","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":324.48,"y":532.8,"width":36.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1066,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":366.48,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1067,"blockId":100,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":380.88,"y":532.8,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1068,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1069,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":430.08,"y":532.8,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1070,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1071,"blockId":100,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.84,"y":532.8,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"necessary in the light of the Tribunal’s above decision to allow the Respondent to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1072,"blockId":100,"value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":545.52,"width":426.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1073,"blockId":100,"value":"the damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":56.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1074,"blockId":100,"value":"phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":161.04,"y":558.0,"width":24.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1075,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":558.0,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1076,"blockId":100,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":558.0,"width":55.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1077,"blockId":100,"value":"Accordingly,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":283.92,"y":558.0,"width":57.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1078,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.56,"y":558.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1079,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":558.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1080,"blockId":100,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.0,"y":558.0,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1081,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":558.0,"width":70.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1082,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":559.44,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1083,"blockId":100,"value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1084,"blockId":100,"value":"23 September 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.68,"width":91.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":190.8,"Value":"23 September 2019."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},"91":{"pageNum":13,"columnStart":1092,"columnEnd":1093,"text":"<div><br></div><div>&nbsp;<strong></strong></div><div><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </div><div><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa99","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.Date:12","paragraphId":"pa99","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"71, 115, 223, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p><br></p><p>&nbsp;<strong></strong></p><p><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </p><p><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</p>","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1092,"blockId":101,"value":"Date: 12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":115.68,"width":113.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":184.8,"Value":"Date: 12 September 2019"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1093,"blockId":101,"value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":142.56,"width":223.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004,"Value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004}},"92":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1085,"columnEnd":1087,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn8","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.8","paragraphId":"fn8","paragraphLabel":"8","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":6.4375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1085,"blockId":2,"value":"8 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.56,"width":63.36,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"8 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1086,"blockId":2,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.96,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1087,"blockId":2,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}}},"RectanglesPdf":{"1":"139, 83, 206, 13","2":"360, 83, 126, 12","3":"689, 83, 354, 12","4":"168, 231, 849, 15","5":"480, 256, 226, 15","6":"156, 307, 876, 14","7":"156, 333, 874, 15","8":"220, 358, 747, 15","9":"564, 408, 60, 15","10":"212, 459, 766, 14","11":"404, 484, 383, 15","12":"480, 560, 229, 15","13":"545, 645, 102, 2","14":"487, 712, 228, 15","15":"531, 762, 129, 15","16":"565, 838, 60, 15","17":"451, 914, 300, 15","18":"520, 965, 152, 15","19":"446, 1091, 300, 15","20":"491, 1193, 209, 15","21":"364, 1217, 462, 15","22":"483, 1242, 225, 15","23":"508, 1268, 176, 14","24":"556, 1319, 79, 20","25":"457, 1344, 277, 14","26":"513, 1394, 167, 15","27":"842, 76, 204, 14","28":"844, 101, 205, 15","29":"882, 126, 167, 15","30":"940, 152, 108, 19","31":"199, 231, 225, 15","32":"144, 280, 22, 14","33":"199, 280, 851, 14","34":"199, 305, 113, 15","35":"324, 305, 92, 20","36":"428, 305, 35, 18","37":"474, 305, 120, 20","38":"605, 305, 102, 18","39":"719, 305, 330, 15","40":"199, 330, 269, 15","41":"198, 359, 851, 17","42":"199, 381, 70, 15","43":"281, 381, 68, 15","44":"360, 381, 109, 20","45":"482, 381, 98, 20","46":"592, 386, 20, 10","47":"625, 381, 396, 15","48":"1033, 381, 20, 20","49":"198, 407, 290, 15","50":"500, 406, 550, 15","51":"198, 432, 850, 15","52":"144, 482, 23, 14","53":"145, 685, 22, 15","54":"199, 684, 397, 15","55":"145, 735, 23, 15","56":"199, 735, 853, 15","57":"199, 760, 154, 15","58":"363, 760, 285, 15","59":"658, 760, 114, 15","60":"782, 760, 25, 15","61":"817, 763, 144, 12","62":"971, 760, 52, 15","63":"1033, 763, 15, 12","64":"199, 785, 84, 15","65":"297, 791, 19, 10","66":"330, 785, 80, 20","67":"423, 785, 21, 20","68":"457, 785, 26, 15","69":"497, 785, 103, 20","70":"612, 788, 16, 12","71":"642, 785, 25, 15","72":"679, 785, 101, 20","73":"793, 785, 19, 15","74":"824, 785, 25, 15","75":"863, 785, 73, 15","76":"951, 785, 30, 15","77":"995, 788, 15, 12","78":"1024, 785, 25, 15","79":"199, 811, 717, 20","80":"145, 862, 22, 15","81":"199, 862, 851, 15","82":"199, 887, 41, 15","83":"252, 887, 25, 15","84":"289, 887, 107, 20","85":"408, 887, 25, 15","86":"445, 887, 74, 15","87":"531, 887, 54, 15","88":"596, 887, 93, 15","89":"701, 887, 91, 15","90":"807, 887, 4, 15","91":"826, 887, 30, 15","92":"868, 887, 48, 15","93":"927, 887, 121, 15","94":"199, 912, 851, 20","95":"199, 937, 851, 15","96":"199, 968, 41, 10","97":"251, 965, 15, 12","98":"278, 962, 27, 15","99":"316, 968, 8, 10","100":"336, 963, 394, 14","101":"742, 962, 66, 15","102":"819, 962, 145, 20","103":"976, 965, 16, 12","104":"1003, 962, 27, 15","105":"1042, 968, 8, 10","106":"200, 989, 279, 14","107":"490, 988, 85, 20","108":"586, 991, 16, 12","109":"612, 988, 102, 15","110":"726, 988, 55, 15","111":"791, 988, 123, 20","112":"927, 988, 123, 20","113":"199, 1013, 440, 20","114":"144, 1064, 24, 15","115":"144, 1115, 23, 15","116":"199, 1114, 183, 15","117":"392, 1117, 27, 12","118":"430, 1114, 27, 15","119":"468, 1120, 9, 10","120":"487, 1115, 195, 14","121":"693, 1117, 179, 12","122":"882, 1114, 168, 15","123":"199, 1140, 850, 20","124":"199, 1165, 850, 15","125":"199, 1190, 79, 15","126":"144, 1241, 23, 15","127":"144, 1343, 23, 15","128":"199, 1343, 850, 14","129":"199, 1368, 787, 20","130":"996, 1368, 54, 15","131":"199, 1393, 193, 15","132":"403, 1393, 14, 18","133":"428, 1393, 98, 15","134":"536, 1393, 19, 20","135":"565, 1392, 484, 19","136":"199, 1418, 850, 18","137":"199, 1449, 851, 10","138":"199, 1469, 850, 15","139":"199, 1494, 850, 15","140":"199, 1522, 850, 12","141":"842, 76, 204, 14","142":"844, 101, 205, 15","143":"882, 126, 167, 15","144":"940, 152, 108, 19","145":"199, 230, 25, 15","146":"234, 230, 352, 15","147":"597, 230, 95, 18","148":"703, 230, 346, 15","149":"199, 255, 742, 15","150":"144, 306, 35, 15","151":"199, 408, 853, 14","152":"199, 432, 850, 18","153":"199, 463, 851, 10","154":"199, 486, 675, 12","155":"144, 534, 34, 14","156":"199, 534, 851, 14","157":"199, 559, 851, 15","158":"199, 585, 850, 15","159":"199, 610, 102, 15","160":"830, 610, 219, 15","161":"199, 635, 196, 15","162":"145, 686, 33, 15","163":"199, 686, 94, 15","164":"303, 686, 746, 15","165":"199, 711, 426, 15","166":"198, 736, 628, 20","167":"145, 787, 34, 15","168":"199, 787, 290, 20","169":"499, 787, 155, 20","170":"665, 787, 191, 15","171":"869, 787, 17, 15","172":"898, 790, 16, 12","173":"927, 787, 18, 15","174":"955, 787, 36, 20","175":"1001, 787, 47, 15","176":"199, 812, 851, 20","177":"199, 837, 851, 15","178":"199, 863, 851, 20","179":"199, 888, 124, 15","180":"333, 891, 16, 12","181":"359, 888, 25, 15","182":"395, 888, 203, 18","183":"608, 888, 65, 20","184":"684, 888, 44, 15","185":"738, 891, 15, 12","186":"765, 888, 64, 15","187":"840, 888, 81, 20","188":"931, 888, 83, 15","189":"1024, 888, 25, 15","190":"199, 913, 74, 15","191":"285, 913, 15, 15","192":"311, 913, 25, 15","193":"348, 913, 69, 20","194":"429, 919, 16, 10","195":"456, 913, 36, 15","196":"504, 919, 16, 10","197":"532, 913, 44, 15","198":"587, 915, 63, 13","199":"661, 913, 58, 20","200":"731, 916, 27, 12","201":"768, 913, 53, 15","202":"833, 913, 69, 20","203":"914, 913, 15, 15","204":"940, 913, 109, 20","205":"199, 938, 386, 15","206":"144, 989, 34, 15","207":"758, 988, 291, 21","208":"199, 1014, 298, 15","209":"144, 1065, 35, 15","210":"199, 1066, 851, 14","211":"199, 1090, 853, 15","212":"196, 1116, 748, 20","213":"144, 1166, 34, 15","214":"199, 1166, 504, 15","215":"255, 1217, 396, 13","216":"294, 1263, 11, 13","217":"327, 1263, 23, 13","218":"361, 1263, 62, 13","219":"433, 1263, 84, 13","220":"527, 1263, 25, 13","221":"563, 1263, 67, 13","222":"641, 1263, 87, 18","223":"738, 1263, 45, 13","224":"793, 1263, 23, 13","225":"826, 1263, 51, 17","226":"887, 1263, 14, 13","227":"911, 1265, 56, 15","228":"977, 1263, 18, 13","229":"327, 1286, 79, 13","230":"421, 1286, 71, 13","231":"506, 1286, 27, 13","232":"549, 1286, 36, 13","233":"599, 1286, 94, 13","234":"708, 1286, 14, 13","235":"736, 1286, 23, 13","236":"774, 1286, 68, 13","237":"856, 1286, 77, 13","238":"947, 1291, 15, 9","239":"977, 1286, 18, 13","240":"328, 1309, 126, 13","241":"291, 1355, 13, 13","242":"327, 1355, 665, 13","243":"328, 1378, 445, 18","244":"292, 1424, 12, 14","245":"327, 1424, 664, 13","246":"327, 1447, 106, 13","247":"842, 76, 204, 14","248":"844, 101, 205, 15","249":"882, 126, 167, 15","250":"940, 152, 108, 19","251":"255, 230, 737, 13","252":"255, 253, 737, 13","253":"255, 276, 137, 13","254":"144, 324, 34, 15","255":"199, 324, 218, 15","256":"427, 324, 74, 15","257":"512, 324, 78, 15","258":"600, 324, 173, 15","259":"785, 324, 88, 20","260":"884, 324, 165, 15","261":"199, 355, 55, 10","262":"144, 400, 34, 15","263":"199, 401, 52, 14","264":"261, 400, 788, 20","265":"199, 426, 850, 20","266":"198, 451, 852, 20","267":"199, 476, 851, 15","268":"198, 502, 851, 20","269":"199, 527, 851, 15","270":"199, 552, 654, 15","271":"144, 603, 35, 15","272":"199, 603, 150, 14","273":"359, 603, 691, 15","274":"198, 629, 30, 15","275":"240, 629, 14, 18","276":"265, 628, 25, 15","277":"301, 628, 74, 15","278":"386, 628, 85, 15","279":"483, 629, 17, 15","280":"512, 628, 81, 20","281":"604, 631, 153, 12","282":"768, 628, 81, 20","283":"859, 631, 190, 12","284":"201, 654, 848, 15","285":"199, 679, 133, 20","286":"198, 704, 464, 20","287":"144, 755, 32, 15","288":"199, 755, 850, 15","289":"199, 780, 850, 15","290":"199, 805, 851, 15","291":"199, 830, 851, 15","292":"199, 858, 851, 12","293":"199, 881, 380, 20","294":"144, 932, 34, 15","295":"199, 932, 851, 20","296":"199, 957, 851, 15","297":"199, 982, 851, 15","298":"199, 1008, 663, 15","299":"872, 1008, 177, 15","300":"199, 1032, 851, 15","301":"199, 1058, 65, 20","302":"274, 1058, 125, 20","303":"409, 1058, 81, 15","304":"500, 1061, 16, 12","305":"526, 1058, 26, 15","306":"562, 1058, 105, 19","307":"677, 1058, 25, 15","308":"713, 1058, 110, 15","309":"835, 1058, 133, 15","310":"979, 1058, 44, 15","311":"1033, 1061, 16, 12","312":"199, 1083, 851, 15","313":"199, 1109, 326, 20","314":"144, 1160, 34, 15","315":"734, 1159, 315, 21","316":"199, 1185, 366, 15","317":"144, 1236, 35, 15","318":"199, 1236, 850, 19","319":"199, 1260, 716, 15","320":"144, 1311, 34, 15","321":"199, 1311, 48, 15","322":"260, 1311, 79, 20","323":"351, 1311, 48, 18","324":"412, 1311, 59, 20","325":"484, 1311, 102, 19","326":"599, 1311, 26, 15","327":"637, 1311, 74, 15","328":"725, 1311, 54, 15","329":"792, 1317, 9, 10","330":"813, 1311, 95, 15","331":"922, 1311, 56, 15","332":"991, 1311, 59, 15","333":"199, 1337, 850, 20","334":"199, 1368, 851, 10","335":"198, 1387, 311, 15","336":"842, 76, 204, 14","337":"844, 101, 205, 15","338":"882, 126, 167, 15","339":"940, 152, 108, 19","340":"144, 230, 35, 15","341":"199, 230, 497, 15","342":"255, 281, 396, 13","343":"294, 327, 11, 13","344":"327, 326, 575, 13","345":"291, 373, 13, 13","346":"327, 372, 320, 13","347":"292, 419, 12, 13","348":"327, 419, 23, 13","349":"364, 419, 62, 13","350":"440, 419, 84, 13","351":"537, 419, 25, 13","352":"576, 419, 72, 13","353":"661, 419, 54, 13","354":"729, 419, 7, 13","355":"751, 419, 17, 13","356":"780, 419, 23, 13","357":"816, 419, 51, 17","358":"881, 419, 14, 13","359":"908, 421, 56, 15","360":"977, 419, 18, 13","361":"328, 442, 200, 13","362":"255, 490, 736, 13","363":"255, 516, 534, 11","364":"145, 560, 34, 15","365":"145, 710, 34, 15","366":"199, 710, 850, 15","367":"199, 735, 851, 15","368":"199, 760, 109, 20","369":"145, 810, 34, 15","370":"199, 810, 24, 20","371":"238, 810, 44, 15","372":"296, 810, 19, 15","373":"326, 810, 26, 15","374":"367, 815, 43, 10","375":"424, 810, 40, 18","376":"480, 810, 20, 15","377":"515, 810, 56, 15","378":"585, 810, 48, 18","379":"647, 810, 25, 15","380":"687, 810, 73, 15","381":"776, 810, 68, 15","382":"858, 810, 25, 15","383":"898, 810, 62, 20","384":"974, 810, 46, 15","385":"1034, 813, 14, 12","386":"199, 835, 851, 20","387":"199, 860, 851, 15","388":"199, 886, 780, 18","389":"989, 886, 4, 15","390":"1004, 886, 45, 20","391":"199, 911, 641, 18","392":"144, 960, 35, 15","393":"199, 961, 850, 14","394":"199, 988, 89, 12","395":"301, 985, 41, 15","396":"354, 985, 25, 15","397":"393, 985, 108, 20","398":"513, 985, 26, 15","399":"552, 985, 74, 15","400":"639, 985, 53, 15","401":"705, 985, 93, 15","402":"812, 985, 92, 15","403":"918, 986, 14, 17","404":"946, 985, 15, 15","405":"973, 985, 53, 15","406":"1039, 985, 10, 15","407":"199, 1010, 145, 18","408":"355, 1010, 183, 15","409":"548, 1010, 128, 20","410":"686, 1010, 62, 15","411":"758, 1013, 16, 12","412":"785, 1010, 74, 15","413":"870, 1013, 15, 12","414":"895, 1010, 92, 20","415":"998, 1010, 15, 15","416":"1024, 1010, 25, 15","417":"199, 1036, 851, 20","418":"199, 1061, 851, 15","419":"199, 1086, 72, 15","420":"144, 1136, 32, 15","421":"199, 1137, 851, 19","422":"199, 1161, 52, 15","423":"263, 1161, 25, 15","424":"298, 1161, 25, 15","425":"334, 1161, 163, 15","426":"508, 1161, 293, 15","427":"813, 1161, 32, 15","428":"856, 1161, 35, 15","429":"902, 1161, 32, 15","430":"946, 1164, 67, 12","431":"1024, 1161, 25, 15","432":"199, 1186, 90, 15","433":"303, 1186, 70, 20","434":"387, 1186, 16, 15","435":"417, 1186, 19, 15","436":"449, 1186, 56, 15","437":"519, 1186, 59, 15","438":"591, 1187, 31, 15","439":"636, 1186, 60, 15","440":"708, 1186, 25, 15","441":"748, 1186, 79, 15","442":"840, 1189, 15, 12","443":"870, 1187, 46, 15","444":"929, 1187, 44, 15","445":"986, 1186, 63, 15","446":"199, 1212, 136, 15","447":"346, 1212, 658, 19","448":"1014, 1212, 36, 20","449":"199, 1237, 819, 18","450":"144, 1286, 34, 15","451":"144, 1361, 34, 15","452":"199, 1362, 851, 19","453":"199, 1386, 307, 15","454":"144, 1436, 35, 15","455":"842, 76, 204, 14","456":"844, 101, 205, 15","457":"882, 126, 167, 15","458":"940, 152, 108, 19","459":"144, 408, 34, 15","460":"144, 990, 34, 15","461":"256, 1470, 21, 17","462":"842, 76, 204, 14","463":"844, 101, 205, 15","464":"882, 126, 167, 15","465":"940, 152, 108, 19","466":"256, 230, 28, 17","467":"254, 253, 744, 18","468":"255, 276, 743, 18","469":"555, 299, 17, 18","470":"144, 348, 34, 15","471":"199, 348, 851, 19","472":"199, 373, 850, 15","473":"199, 398, 850, 15","474":"199, 423, 555, 20","475":"145, 475, 34, 15","476":"199, 475, 252, 19","477":"460, 477, 588, 12","478":"199, 499, 600, 15","479":"144, 551, 34, 15","480":"144, 702, 35, 15","481":"144, 828, 32, 15","482":"144, 879, 34, 15","483":"199, 879, 24, 14","484":"236, 884, 38, 10","485":"281, 878, 73, 15","486":"361, 879, 18, 26","487":"387, 884, 59, 14","488":"458, 881, 58, 12","489":"529, 884, 75, 10","490":"642, 878, 10, 15","491":"665, 878, 287, 15","492":"1023, 881, 25, 12","493":"448, 892, 2, 5","494":"656, 894, 11, 3","495":"527, 905, 3, 5","496":"199, 910, 325, 10","497":"533, 910, 119, 10","498":"659, 904, 18, 15","499":"706, 904, 180, 15","500":"144, 955, 34, 15","501":"199, 955, 279, 14","502":"492, 957, 558, 12","503":"480, 968, 2, 5","504":"198, 985, 35, 9","505":"243, 983, 169, 12","506":"422, 981, 85, 14","507":"517, 981, 106, 14","508":"638, 985, 215, 10","509":"863, 983, 91, 12","510":"964, 985, 85, 10","511":"625, 993, 3, 5","512":"199, 1011, 324, 10","513":"537, 1011, 179, 10","514":"144, 1056, 35, 15","515":"144, 1107, 34, 15","516":"144, 1385, 35, 15","517":"198, 1385, 852, 14","518":"199, 1410, 79, 15","519":"291, 1410, 21, 20","520":"325, 1410, 25, 15","521":"364, 1410, 64, 15","522":"444, 1416, 85, 10","523":"543, 1410, 106, 15","524":"662, 1416, 21, 10","525":"696, 1410, 30, 15","526":"740, 1410, 42, 15","527":"796, 1413, 16, 12","528":"826, 1410, 40, 18","529":"880, 1416, 16, 10","530":"910, 1410, 36, 15","531":"960, 1416, 16, 10","532":"990, 1410, 21, 20","533":"1023, 1410, 26, 15","534":"199, 1436, 850, 20","535":"198, 1461, 156, 15","536":"842, 76, 204, 14","537":"844, 101, 205, 15","538":"882, 126, 167, 15","539":"940, 152, 108, 19","540":"199, 231, 353, 15","541":"193, 455, 24, 24","542":"272, 456, 559, 15","543":"199, 508, 851, 14","544":"199, 538, 851, 10","545":"199, 558, 850, 18","546":"199, 583, 851, 15","547":"199, 609, 851, 20","548":"199, 634, 850, 15","549":"199, 660, 850, 15","550":"199, 684, 32, 15","551":"243, 684, 81, 15","552":"336, 684, 102, 20","553":"449, 684, 39, 15","554":"501, 684, 19, 15","555":"533, 684, 133, 15","556":"678, 684, 31, 15","557":"721, 684, 50, 15","558":"783, 684, 32, 15","559":"828, 684, 20, 15","560":"860, 684, 28, 15","561":"898, 684, 101, 20","562":"1012, 690, 38, 10","563":"199, 709, 760, 15","564":"199, 760, 850, 15","565":"199, 786, 291, 15","566":"501, 786, 132, 15","567":"642, 786, 168, 15","568":"819, 786, 230, 15","569":"199, 816, 851, 15","570":"199, 836, 851, 15","571":"199, 867, 21, 10","572":"230, 862, 25, 15","573":"266, 862, 72, 20","574":"199, 963, 850, 14","575":"199, 988, 853, 15","576":"199, 1013, 851, 15","577":"199, 1042, 850, 12","578":"199, 1064, 850, 18","579":"199, 1089, 851, 15","580":"199, 1115, 234, 15","581":"199, 1361, 851, 15","582":"199, 1386, 764, 20","583":"973, 1386, 76, 15","584":"144, 1475, 125, 8","585":"275, 1481, 13, 13","586":"298, 1476, 112, 16","587":"842, 76, 204, 14","588":"844, 101, 205, 15","589":"882, 126, 167, 15","590":"940, 152, 108, 19","591":"199, 230, 205, 15","592":"414, 230, 319, 15","593":"744, 230, 305, 15","594":"199, 255, 348, 20","595":"557, 255, 492, 15","596":"199, 284, 851, 17","597":"199, 306, 573, 20","598":"142, 357, 26, 15","599":"199, 357, 851, 18","600":"199, 382, 850, 15","601":"199, 408, 106, 15","602":"316, 413, 21, 10","603":"348, 408, 50, 15","604":"409, 408, 168, 15","605":"588, 408, 112, 20","606":"711, 408, 24, 20","607":"746, 408, 36, 15","608":"793, 413, 16, 10","609":"821, 408, 50, 15","610":"883, 408, 106, 20","611":"1001, 408, 48, 18","612":"199, 432, 851, 15","613":"199, 463, 851, 10","614":"199, 489, 851, 10","615":"200, 509, 700, 14","616":"910, 508, 140, 19","617":"199, 534, 851, 20","618":"199, 559, 56, 18","619":"266, 559, 129, 20","620":"406, 562, 86, 18","621":"503, 559, 228, 15","622":"741, 559, 112, 20","623":"863, 560, 71, 19","624":"944, 564, 16, 10","625":"972, 559, 81, 15","626":"199, 585, 851, 20","627":"199, 610, 83, 20","628":"293, 610, 31, 15","629":"335, 610, 198, 15","630":"545, 610, 78, 15","631":"634, 610, 84, 18","632":"730, 610, 82, 20","633":"822, 610, 38, 15","634":"871, 612, 61, 17","635":"943, 612, 16, 12","636":"971, 610, 50, 15","637":"1032, 610, 20, 15","638":"197, 635, 852, 20","639":"199, 660, 26, 15","640":"235, 660, 360, 18","641":"605, 660, 92, 20","642":"708, 662, 47, 13","643":"767, 660, 149, 15","644":"926, 663, 123, 17","645":"199, 685, 850, 20","646":"199, 711, 851, 20","647":"199, 736, 850, 15","648":"199, 761, 851, 20","649":"199, 787, 55, 20","650":"265, 792, 70, 13","651":"346, 787, 38, 15","652":"396, 787, 25, 15","653":"432, 787, 90, 20","654":"534, 787, 30, 15","655":"576, 787, 20, 15","656":"608, 787, 148, 15","657":"768, 787, 85, 15","658":"865, 787, 15, 15","659":"891, 787, 25, 15","660":"928, 792, 56, 10","661":"996, 787, 53, 15","662":"199, 812, 78, 20","663":"289, 812, 194, 20","664":"494, 812, 101, 20","665":"606, 812, 71, 18","666":"687, 812, 362, 18","667":"199, 837, 76, 20","668":"289, 837, 34, 15","669":"336, 837, 56, 20","670":"406, 837, 25, 15","671":"445, 836, 86, 22","672":"545, 838, 33, 15","673":"592, 838, 103, 20","674":"708, 838, 27, 15","675":"748, 840, 27, 12","676":"789, 838, 40, 15","677":"844, 838, 117, 15","678":"974, 838, 20, 15","679":"1005, 838, 44, 15","680":"199, 863, 851, 20","681":"199, 888, 311, 20","682":"142, 939, 25, 15","683":"199, 938, 850, 20","684":"199, 964, 851, 15","685":"199, 989, 850, 18","686":"199, 1015, 850, 15","687":"198, 1041, 68, 95","688":"142, 1166, 26, 15","689":"199, 1166, 140, 15","690":"349, 1166, 173, 15","691":"533, 1166, 95, 15","692":"638, 1166, 63, 15","693":"711, 1166, 16, 15","694":"737, 1166, 312, 15","695":"199, 1191, 851, 15","696":"199, 1217, 851, 20","697":"196, 1242, 154, 20","698":"361, 1242, 220, 20","699":"591, 1242, 132, 15","700":"734, 1245, 52, 12","701":"797, 1248, 25, 10","702":"834, 1242, 117, 15","703":"962, 1243, 86, 14","704":"199, 1268, 851, 20","705":"199, 1293, 851, 15","706":"199, 1319, 851, 15","707":"199, 1344, 211, 20","708":"142, 1394, 37, 15","709":"199, 1395, 850, 14","710":"199, 1419, 851, 15","711":"199, 1445, 850, 15","712":"142, 1521, 166, 9","713":"314, 1527, 38, 13","714":"361, 1523, 198, 16","715":"569, 1523, 30, 14","716":"842, 76, 204, 14","717":"844, 101, 205, 15","718":"882, 126, 167, 15","719":"929, 152, 120, 19","720":"199, 230, 16, 15","721":"231, 230, 25, 15","722":"274, 231, 26, 14","723":"315, 230, 50, 15","724":"382, 230, 111, 20","725":"142, 332, 35, 15","726":"949, 357, 100, 15","727":"199, 382, 851, 15","728":"199, 408, 850, 19","729":"198, 432, 378, 20","730":"587, 432, 20, 15","731":"617, 432, 310, 15","732":"937, 432, 112, 20","733":"199, 458, 269, 20","734":"142, 509, 36, 14","735":"198, 660, 204, 20","736":"414, 660, 103, 20","737":"528, 660, 48, 15","738":"587, 660, 40, 15","739":"639, 660, 51, 15","740":"701, 660, 31, 15","741":"744, 660, 42, 15","742":"798, 663, 14, 12","743":"824, 666, 19, 10","744":"855, 660, 55, 15","745":"922, 663, 43, 17","746":"977, 660, 72, 15","747":"199, 685, 851, 20","748":"199, 711, 851, 20","749":"199, 736, 851, 15","750":"199, 765, 15, 12","751":"228, 762, 81, 15","752":"323, 767, 31, 15","753":"367, 762, 47, 20","754":"427, 762, 76, 20","755":"516, 762, 41, 15","756":"571, 762, 39, 15","757":"623, 762, 106, 15","758":"743, 762, 30, 15","759":"786, 762, 47, 20","760":"847, 762, 32, 15","761":"892, 762, 25, 15","762":"931, 762, 118, 20","763":"199, 790, 850, 17","764":"199, 812, 851, 20","765":"199, 838, 849, 15","766":"142, 888, 36, 15","767":"199, 888, 851, 15","768":"199, 913, 850, 15","769":"199, 938, 87, 20","770":"299, 939, 36, 15","771":"349, 938, 60, 20","772":"422, 938, 25, 15","773":"461, 938, 152, 20","774":"626, 938, 46, 15","775":"686, 938, 106, 15","776":"806, 938, 15, 15","777":"834, 941, 61, 17","778":"909, 938, 20, 15","779":"939, 938, 18, 15","780":"972, 938, 78, 20","781":"199, 964, 90, 20","782":"193, 1013, 30, 24","783":"272, 1014, 459, 15","784":"142, 1065, 37, 15","785":"199, 1066, 851, 14","786":"199, 1093, 71, 17","787":"283, 1090, 32, 15","788":"328, 1091, 25, 15","789":"368, 1090, 74, 15","790":"456, 1093, 34, 17","791":"503, 1090, 44, 15","792":"560, 1090, 105, 20","793":"679, 1090, 70, 20","794":"762, 1090, 25, 15","795":"802, 1093, 74, 12","796":"889, 1090, 56, 15","797":"960, 1091, 26, 14","798":"999, 1090, 49, 15","799":"199, 1116, 111, 20","800":"142, 1166, 36, 15","801":"199, 1166, 851, 15","802":"199, 1192, 702, 14","803":"911, 1192, 138, 18","804":"199, 1217, 851, 20","805":"199, 1242, 850, 15","806":"199, 1270, 626, 17","807":"142, 1319, 37, 15","808":"199, 1319, 249, 15","809":"457, 1319, 11, 15","810":"477, 1319, 218, 15","811":"705, 1319, 178, 15","812":"892, 1319, 157, 15","813":"199, 1344, 850, 15","814":"199, 1369, 851, 20","815":"198, 1394, 851, 20","816":"199, 1419, 851, 15","817":"199, 1445, 751, 15","818":"142, 1521, 133, 8","819":"282, 1527, 68, 13","820":"842, 76, 204, 14","821":"844, 101, 205, 15","822":"882, 126, 167, 15","823":"929, 152, 120, 19","824":"142, 255, 36, 15","825":"142, 332, 36, 15","826":"199, 332, 431, 15","827":"639, 332, 410, 15","828":"199, 359, 851, 12","829":"199, 382, 75, 20","830":"284, 382, 25, 15","831":"321, 382, 118, 20","832":"451, 384, 23, 12","833":"485, 382, 44, 15","834":"540, 382, 220, 20","835":"771, 382, 34, 15","836":"817, 382, 118, 15","837":"947, 382, 103, 20","838":"199, 408, 850, 15","839":"199, 432, 851, 20","840":"199, 458, 852, 15","841":"199, 483, 67, 20","842":"279, 483, 48, 20","843":"339, 483, 107, 15","844":"458, 486, 16, 12","845":"486, 483, 74, 15","846":"571, 483, 70, 15","847":"653, 489, 9, 10","848":"674, 486, 34, 17","849":"720, 483, 48, 15","850":"779, 483, 154, 20","851":"944, 483, 74, 20","852":"1030, 483, 20, 15","853":"199, 508, 501, 15","854":"142, 560, 36, 15","855":"199, 559, 851, 20","856":"197, 585, 117, 20","857":"329, 585, 89, 20","858":"433, 585, 106, 15","859":"554, 585, 16, 15","860":"585, 585, 26, 15","861":"625, 585, 119, 20","862":"759, 588, 53, 12","863":"827, 585, 137, 20","864":"979, 585, 30, 15","865":"1023, 585, 25, 15","866":"199, 610, 119, 20","867":"332, 610, 26, 14","868":"371, 610, 50, 15","869":"435, 610, 31, 15","870":"479, 610, 99, 15","871":"591, 610, 53, 18","872":"658, 610, 25, 15","873":"696, 610, 74, 15","874":"785, 610, 86, 15","875":"885, 610, 32, 15","876":"930, 615, 8, 10","877":"952, 612, 34, 17","878":"999, 610, 20, 15","879":"1031, 610, 19, 15","880":"199, 635, 853, 20","881":"199, 660, 851, 15","882":"199, 685, 56, 15","883":"266, 688, 16, 12","884":"295, 688, 34, 17","885":"340, 685, 63, 20","886":"415, 685, 25, 15","887":"453, 685, 90, 15","888":"555, 685, 55, 20","889":"622, 688, 15, 13","890":"649, 685, 40, 20","891":"701, 685, 31, 15","892":"743, 685, 74, 20","893":"828, 685, 73, 15","894":"913, 685, 30, 15","895":"956, 685, 56, 15","896":"1023, 685, 25, 15","897":"199, 711, 230, 20","898":"142, 762, 37, 15","899":"199, 761, 850, 15","900":"199, 790, 339, 12","901":"193, 835, 33, 24","902":"273, 837, 776, 15","903":"271, 863, 214, 15","904":"142, 913, 35, 15","905":"199, 913, 850, 20","906":"199, 938, 850, 15","907":"199, 964, 851, 15","908":"199, 989, 601, 15","909":"142, 1040, 36, 15","910":"199, 1041, 850, 14","911":"199, 1066, 851, 19","912":"199, 1091, 853, 15","913":"198, 1116, 105, 20","914":"317, 1116, 12, 15","915":"343, 1116, 109, 15","916":"465, 1116, 15, 15","917":"493, 1116, 25, 15","918":"531, 1118, 63, 18","919":"607, 1116, 123, 15","920":"744, 1116, 24, 15","921":"780, 1116, 21, 15","922":"814, 1116, 55, 15","923":"882, 1121, 64, 10","924":"960, 1118, 23, 12","925":"996, 1118, 27, 12","926":"1035, 1118, 15, 12","927":"198, 1141, 852, 20","928":"196, 1166, 853, 20","929":"199, 1191, 106, 15","930":"318, 1191, 84, 20","931":"414, 1191, 51, 15","932":"479, 1191, 19, 15","933":"508, 1191, 71, 20","934":"593, 1192, 23, 14","935":"629, 1191, 155, 20","936":"797, 1191, 25, 15","937":"836, 1192, 102, 20","938":"951, 1191, 60, 15","939":"1024, 1191, 25, 15","940":"199, 1223, 851, 10","941":"199, 1242, 274, 20","942":"483, 1242, 295, 15","943":"790, 1242, 106, 15","944":"907, 1243, 37, 20","945":"954, 1242, 40, 15","946":"1004, 1243, 45, 15","947":"199, 1267, 851, 15","948":"199, 1293, 851, 15","949":"199, 1319, 69, 20","950":"142, 1369, 36, 15","951":"199, 1369, 851, 15","952":"199, 1394, 851, 15","953":"198, 1419, 851, 18","954":"142, 1498, 27, 9","955":"142, 1521, 126, 8","956":"275, 1527, 13, 13","957":"298, 1523, 112, 16","958":"842, 76, 204, 14","959":"844, 101, 205, 15","960":"881, 126, 168, 15","961":"929, 152, 120, 19","962":"199, 230, 851, 20","963":"199, 255, 88, 15","964":"296, 255, 68, 20","965":"373, 255, 13, 15","966":"396, 255, 657, 18","967":"199, 281, 851, 20","968":"199, 306, 850, 15","969":"199, 332, 850, 15","970":"199, 357, 350, 15","971":"142, 408, 37, 15","972":"199, 408, 17, 14","973":"229, 408, 44, 15","974":"287, 408, 129, 18","975":"429, 408, 26, 15","976":"468, 408, 74, 15","977":"556, 408, 81, 15","978":"651, 408, 32, 15","979":"696, 408, 11, 15","980":"720, 408, 54, 15","981":"788, 408, 20, 15","982":"821, 408, 99, 20","983":"933, 410, 16, 12","984":"963, 408, 48, 15","985":"1023, 408, 26, 15","986":"199, 432, 851, 20","987":"199, 458, 851, 20","988":"199, 483, 753, 15","989":"142, 534, 36, 15","990":"199, 534, 851, 15","991":"199, 559, 95, 15","992":"306, 559, 79, 15","993":"396, 559, 26, 15","994":"433, 559, 53, 15","995":"498, 559, 189, 15","996":"698, 564, 17, 10","997":"726, 559, 11, 15","998":"748, 559, 13, 15","999":"773, 559, 46, 15","1000":"830, 564, 9, 10","1001":"850, 559, 135, 15","1002":"996, 559, 54, 15","1003":"199, 585, 850, 15","1004":"199, 610, 851, 15","1005":"199, 635, 281, 15","1006":"490, 635, 559, 15","1007":"199, 660, 616, 18","1008":"826, 660, 41, 20","1009":"877, 660, 96, 18","1010":"984, 660, 65, 15","1011":"199, 688, 850, 12","1012":"199, 711, 397, 15","1013":"607, 711, 91, 18","1014":"708, 711, 64, 15","1015":"783, 711, 266, 15","1016":"199, 741, 851, 15","1017":"199, 761, 851, 15","1018":"199, 787, 149, 19","1019":"142, 838, 37, 15","1020":"199, 838, 118, 15","1021":"329, 838, 57, 15","1022":"396, 838, 26, 15","1023":"433, 838, 59, 15","1024":"503, 840, 16, 12","1025":"529, 840, 50, 12","1026":"591, 840, 15, 12","1027":"618, 838, 136, 15","1028":"765, 838, 20, 15","1029":"797, 838, 202, 20","1030":"1010, 838, 40, 15","1031":"199, 863, 850, 20","1032":"199, 888, 851, 20","1033":"199, 913, 393, 20","1034":"142, 964, 36, 15","1035":"199, 964, 118, 15","1036":"328, 964, 138, 15","1037":"477, 964, 181, 15","1038":"669, 964, 19, 15","1039":"698, 964, 45, 15","1040":"754, 964, 53, 15","1041":"817, 964, 71, 20","1042":"899, 964, 150, 20","1043":"199, 989, 271, 15","1044":"480, 989, 569, 15","1045":"199, 1015, 103, 20","1046":"314, 1015, 13, 15","1047":"340, 1015, 84, 20","1048":"436, 1018, 74, 12","1049":"523, 1015, 44, 15","1050":"580, 1015, 70, 20","1051":"664, 1015, 16, 15","1052":"692, 1015, 86, 15","1053":"792, 1015, 49, 15","1054":"853, 1015, 96, 20","1055":"962, 1015, 50, 15","1056":"1024, 1015, 25, 15","1057":"199, 1040, 851, 15","1058":"199, 1071, 84, 14","1059":"296, 1065, 15, 15","1060":"324, 1065, 25, 15","1061":"363, 1065, 38, 20","1062":"414, 1065, 55, 15","1063":"481, 1065, 90, 15","1064":"585, 1065, 51, 15","1065":"648, 1065, 72, 15","1066":"732, 1068, 16, 12","1067":"761, 1065, 48, 15","1068":"821, 1065, 25, 15","1069":"860, 1065, 103, 20","1070":"974, 1068, 16, 12","1071":"1003, 1065, 46, 15","1072":"199, 1091, 852, 15","1073":"199, 1116, 112, 15","1074":"322, 1116, 49, 20","1075":"382, 1116, 53, 15","1076":"446, 1116, 110, 20","1077":"567, 1116, 114, 20","1078":"693, 1116, 26, 15","1079":"730, 1116, 74, 15","1080":"816, 1116, 57, 15","1081":"883, 1116, 140, 15","1082":"1033, 1118, 15, 12","1083":"198, 1141, 852, 20","1084":"199, 1167, 182, 15","1085":"142, 1521, 126, 9","1086":"275, 1527, 13, 13","1087":"298, 1523, 112, 16","1088":"842, 76, 204, 14","1089":"844, 101, 205, 15","1090":"881, 126, 168, 15","1091":"929, 151, 120, 20","1092":"142, 231, 227, 15","1093":"142, 285, 447, 15","1094":"484, 552, 224, 15","1095":"463, 576, 265, 15","1096":"501, 602, 190, 20"},"OrderedListOfDocumentBlocks":[{"pageNum":1,"columnStart":4,"columnEnd":26,"text":"<div> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </div><div><br></div><div>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </div><div><br></div><div>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </div><div><br></div><div>- between - </div><div><br></div><div>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </div><div>The Claimant </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </div><div>The Respondent </div><div><br></div><div>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </div><div><br></div><div><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></div><div>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </div><div>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </div><div>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</div><div><br></div><div><strong>Registry</strong> </div><div>Permanent Court of Arbitration </div><div><br></div><div>12 September 2019</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa0","paragraphIdAuto":"paIN","paragraphId":"pa0","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"78, 115, 438, 589","alignment":1,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </p><p><br></p><p>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </p><p><br></p><p>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </p><p><br></p><p>- between - </p><p><br></p><p>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </p><p>The Claimant </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </p><p>The Respondent </p><p><br></p><p>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </p><p><br></p><p><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></p><p>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </p><p>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </p><p>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</p><p><br></p><p><strong>Registry</strong> </p><p>Permanent Court of Arbitration </p><p><br></p><p>12 September 2019</p>","averageFontSize":7.644859813084112,"rowsOfText":23,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":4,"blockId":7,"value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":84.48,"y":115.92,"width":424.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":84.48,"MarginRight":509.28000000000003,"Value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":5,"blockId":7,"value":"ACCORDANCE WITH","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":128.16,"width":113.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.24,"MarginRight":353.52,"Value":"ACCORDANCE WITH"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":6,"blockId":7,"value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":78.0,"y":153.84,"width":438.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0,"Value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":7,"blockId":7,"value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":78.24,"y":166.56,"width":437.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.24,"MarginRight":515.28,"Value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":8,"blockId":7,"value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":110.16,"y":179.04,"width":373.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":110.16,"MarginRight":483.84000000000003,"Value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":9,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.0,"y":204.48,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.0,"MarginRight":312.48,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":10,"blockId":7,"value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":106.32,"y":229.68,"width":383.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":106.32,"MarginRight":489.59999999999997,"Value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":11,"blockId":7,"value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":202.32,"y":242.16,"width":191.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":202.32,"MarginRight":393.84000000000003,"Value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":12,"blockId":7,"value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":280.08,"width":114.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":355.44,"Value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":13,"blockId":7,"value":"- between -","fontName":"Times","fontSize":1.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":322.8,"width":51.12,"height":1.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":272.64,"MarginRight":323.76,"Value":"- between -"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":14,"blockId":7,"value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.6,"y":356.16,"width":114.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":243.6,"MarginRight":357.84,"Value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":15,"blockId":7,"value":"The Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":381.36,"width":64.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":265.92,"MarginRight":330.72,"Value":"The Claimant"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":16,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.96,"y":419.28,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.96,"MarginRight":313.44,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":17,"blockId":7,"value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":225.6,"y":457.2,"width":150.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":225.6,"MarginRight":375.84000000000003,"Value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":18,"blockId":7,"value":"The Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":260.16,"y":482.64,"width":76.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":260.16,"MarginRight":336.48,"Value":"The Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":19,"blockId":7,"value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":545.76,"width":150.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":223.2,"MarginRight":373.2,"Value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":20,"blockId":7,"value":"The Arbitral Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.76,"y":596.64,"width":104.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":245.76,"MarginRight":350.64,"Value":"The Arbitral Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":21,"blockId":7,"value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":608.64,"width":231.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":182.4,"MarginRight":413.76,"Value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":22,"blockId":7,"value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.12,"width":112.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":241.92,"MarginRight":354.48,"Value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":23,"blockId":7,"value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":254.16,"y":634.32,"width":88.08,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":254.16,"MarginRight":342.24,"Value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":24,"blockId":7,"value":"Registry","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":659.76,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":278.4,"MarginRight":318.0,"Value":"Registry"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":25,"blockId":7,"value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":228.96,"y":672.24,"width":138.72,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":228.96,"MarginRight":367.68,"Value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":26,"blockId":7,"value":"12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":697.44,"width":83.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":256.8,"MarginRight":340.56,"Value":"12 September 2019"}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":31,"columnEnd":31,"text":" Procedural Background","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h1","paragraphIdAuto":"hProcedural","paragraphId":"h1","paragraphLabel":"1.","rectangle":"99, 115, 112, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Procedural Background","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":31,"blockId":8,"value":"Procedural Background","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.92,"width":112.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64,"Value":"Procedural Background"}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":32,"columnEnd":51,"text":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.1","paragraphId":"pa1.1","paragraphLabel":"1.1","rectangle":"72, 140, 454, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","averageFontSize":8.188065099457505,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":32,"blockId":9,"value":"1.1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":140.16,"width":11.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":33,"blockId":9,"value":"On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.1 On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":34,"blockId":9,"value":"Finilon LLC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":152.64,"width":56.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":35,"blockId":9,"value":"(“Finilon”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":152.64,"width":46.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":36,"blockId":9,"value":"and,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":214.08,"y":152.64,"width":17.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":37,"blockId":9,"value":"together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":237.36,"y":152.64,"width":60.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":38,"blockId":9,"value":"PrivatBank,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":302.64,"y":152.64,"width":51.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":39,"blockId":9,"value":"the “Claimants”) commenced these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":359.52,"y":152.64,"width":165.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Finilon LLC (“Finilon” and, together with PrivatBank, the “Claimants”) commenced these"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":40,"blockId":9,"value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":165.36,"width":134.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":234.72,"Value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":41,"blockId":9,"value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":179.52,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":42,"blockId":9,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":190.56,"width":35.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":43,"blockId":9,"value":"Cabinet","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":190.56,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":44,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ministers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.48,"y":190.56,"width":54.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":45,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ukraine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":241.2,"y":190.56,"width":49.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":46,"blockId":9,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":296.4,"y":193.2,"width":10.08,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":47,"blockId":9,"value":"the Encouragement and Mutual Protection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":312.72,"y":190.56,"width":198.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":48,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":190.56,"width":10.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001,"Value":"and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":49,"blockId":9,"value":"Investments dated 27 November","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":203.52,"width":145.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":50,"blockId":9,"value":"1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.08,"y":203.28,"width":275.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":51,"blockId":9,"value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.4,"Value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":52,"columnEnd":52,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.2","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.2","paragraphLabel":"1.2","rectangle":"72, 241, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":52,"blockId":10,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":241.44,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"12"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":53,"columnEnd":54,"text":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa13","paragraphId":"pa1.3","paragraphLabel":"1.3","rectangle":"72, 342, 225, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":53,"blockId":11,"value":"13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":342.72,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":54,"blockId":11,"value":"The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":198.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32,"Value":"13 The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":55,"columnEnd":79,"text":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.4","paragraphId":"pa1.4","paragraphLabel":"1.4","rectangle":"72, 367, 453, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","averageFontSize":8.510385756676557,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":55,"blockId":12,"value":"1.4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":367.92,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":56,"blockId":12,"value":"On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.92,"width":426.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"1.4 On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":57,"blockId":12,"value":"the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.16,"width":77.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":58,"blockId":12,"value":"Letters from the PCA, and that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":380.16,"width":142.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":59,"blockId":12,"value":"it considered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.28,"y":380.16,"width":57.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":60,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.2,"y":380.16,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":61,"blockId":12,"value":"content of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":381.6,"width":72.0,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":62,"blockId":12,"value":"letters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.76,"y":380.16,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":63,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":381.6,"width":7.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":64,"blockId":12,"value":"constitute","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":392.88,"width":42.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":65,"blockId":12,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":148.56,"y":395.52,"width":9.84,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":66,"blockId":12,"value":"objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":165.12,"y":392.88,"width":40.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":67,"blockId":12,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":211.92,"y":392.88,"width":10.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":68,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":392.88,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":69,"blockId":12,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":248.64,"y":392.88,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":70,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":394.32,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":71,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":72,"blockId":12,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":392.88,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":73,"blockId":12,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":392.88,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":74,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":412.08,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":75,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":392.88,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":76,"blockId":12,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.68,"y":392.88,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":77,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":497.52,"y":394.32,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":78,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":392.88,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":79,"blockId":12,"value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.6,"width":358.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.64,"Value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":80,"columnEnd":113,"text":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.5","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.125","paragraphId":"pa1.5","paragraphLabel":"1.5","rectangle":"72, 431, 452, 85","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.546712802768166,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":80,"blockId":13,"value":"125","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":431.04,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":81,"blockId":13,"value":"On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"125 On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":82,"blockId":13,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":443.52,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":83,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":126.0,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":84,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":443.52,"width":53.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":85,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.24,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":86,"blockId":13,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":443.52,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":87,"blockId":13,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.68,"y":443.52,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":88,"blockId":13,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":298.08,"y":443.52,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":89,"blockId":13,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":443.52,"width":45.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":90,"blockId":13,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.92,"y":443.76,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":91,"blockId":13,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":443.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":92,"blockId":13,"value":"Rules","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.16,"y":443.52,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":93,"blockId":13,"value":"of Procedure,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.92,"y":443.52,"width":60.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":94,"blockId":13,"value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.24,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":95,"blockId":13,"value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":468.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":96,"blockId":13,"value":"were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":484.32,"width":20.88,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":97,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":125.76,"y":482.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":98,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":139.2,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":99,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":100,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":168.24,"y":481.92,"width":197.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":101,"blockId":13,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.28,"y":481.44,"width":33.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":102,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":481.44,"width":72.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":103,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":488.16,"y":482.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":104,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.6,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":105,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":521.04,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":106,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Defence and any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":494.64,"width":139.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":107,"blockId":13,"value":"Objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":494.16,"width":42.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":108,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":293.28,"y":495.6,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":109,"blockId":13,"value":"Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":494.16,"width":51.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":110,"blockId":13,"value":"and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.12,"y":494.16,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":111,"blockId":13,"value":"Admissibility,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":395.76,"y":494.16,"width":61.92,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":112,"blockId":13,"value":"including any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":494.16,"width":61.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":113,"blockId":13,"value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.64,"width":220.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":319.68,"Value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":114,"columnEnd":114,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.6","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.6","paragraphLabel":"1.6","rectangle":"72, 532, 12, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":114,"blockId":14,"value":"1.6","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.32,"width":12.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48,"Value":"1.6"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":115,"columnEnd":125,"text":" The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure. The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the Tribunal. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.7","paragraphId":"pa1.7","paragraphLabel":"1.7","rectangle":"72, 557, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.364912280701754,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":115,"blockId":15,"value":"1.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":557.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":116,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.28,"width":91.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":117,"blockId":15,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":196.32,"y":558.72,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":118,"blockId":15,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":215.04,"y":557.28,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":119,"blockId":15,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":234.0,"y":560.16,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":120,"blockId":15,"value":"Statement of Defence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":243.84,"y":557.76,"width":97.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":121,"blockId":15,"value":"or any Objection to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":346.8,"y":558.72,"width":89.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":122,"blockId":15,"value":"Jurisdiction and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.36,"y":557.28,"width":84.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.7 The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":123,"blockId":15,"value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":570.0,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":124,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":582.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":125,"blockId":15,"value":"Tribunal.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.2,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":139.44,"Value":"Tribunal."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":126,"columnEnd":126,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.8","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.8","paragraphLabel":"1.8","rectangle":"72, 620, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":126,"blockId":1,"value":"1.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":620.88,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"1.8"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}},{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":127,"columnEnd":140,"text":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.9","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19","paragraphId":"pa1.9","paragraphLabel":"1.9","rectangle":"72, 671, 452, 96","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","averageFontSize":7.4953271028037385,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":127,"blockId":2,"value":"19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":671.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":128,"blockId":2,"value":"On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":671.76,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"19 On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":129,"blockId":2,"value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":393.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":130,"blockId":2,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":684.0,"width":27.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":131,"blockId":2,"value":"Procedural Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":696.72,"width":96.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":132,"blockId":2,"value":"2,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":201.6,"y":696.72,"width":7.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":133,"blockId":2,"value":"in which it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.32,"y":696.72,"width":49.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":134,"blockId":2,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":268.08,"y":696.72,"width":9.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":135,"blockId":2,"value":"ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":282.72,"y":696.48,"width":242.4,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":136,"blockId":2,"value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.44,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":137,"blockId":2,"value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":724.56,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":138,"blockId":2,"value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":734.64,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":139,"blockId":2,"value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":747.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":140,"blockId":2,"value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":761.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":145,"columnEnd":149,"text":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.063953488372093,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":145,"blockId":3,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":146,"blockId":3,"value":"Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":117.36,"y":115.44,"width":176.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":147,"blockId":3,"value":"Thereafter,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":298.8,"y":115.44,"width":47.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":148,"blockId":3,"value":"each Party had until 29 April 2016 to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":351.84,"y":115.44,"width":173.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":149,"blockId":3,"value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":127.92,"width":371.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":471.12,"Value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":150,"columnEnd":150,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.10","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.10","paragraphLabel":"1.10","rectangle":"72, 153, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":150,"blockId":1,"value":"1.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":153.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.10"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":151,"columnEnd":154,"text":" May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19.On24","paragraphId":"pa1.11","paragraphLabel":"1.11","rectangle":"99, 204, 426, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":6.793296089385475,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":151,"blockId":4,"value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":426.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":152,"blockId":4,"value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":153,"blockId":4,"value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":154,"blockId":4,"value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":243.36,"width":337.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":437.52,"Value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":155,"columnEnd":161,"text":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12","paragraphId":"pa1.12","paragraphLabel":"1.12","rectangle":"72, 267, 452, 58","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":7.7176470588235295,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":155,"blockId":2,"value":"1.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":267.36,"width":17.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":156,"blockId":2,"value":"On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.36,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.12 On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":157,"blockId":2,"value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":158,"blockId":2,"value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":159,"blockId":2,"value":"thereon.I","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":51.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":160,"blockId":2,"value":"The Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":305.04,"width":109.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"thereon.I The Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":161,"blockId":2,"value":"submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":317.76,"width":98.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":198.0,"Value":"submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":162,"columnEnd":166,"text":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.113","paragraphId":"pa1.13","paragraphLabel":"1.13","rectangle":"72, 343, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.445652173913043,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":162,"blockId":3,"value":"1.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":343.2,"width":16.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":163,"blockId":3,"value":"On 10 and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":343.2,"width":47.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":164,"blockId":3,"value":"14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":343.2,"width":373.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.13 On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":165,"blockId":3,"value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":213.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":312.96000000000004,"Value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":166,"blockId":3,"value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":368.16,"width":314.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":413.28000000000003,"Value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":167,"columnEnd":205,"text":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.114","paragraphId":"pa1.14","paragraphLabel":"1.14","rectangle":"72, 393, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.49737302977233,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":167,"blockId":6,"value":"1.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":393.84,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":168,"blockId":6,"value":"The hearing on jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":145.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":169,"blockId":6,"value":"admissibility was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":249.84,"y":393.6,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":170,"blockId":6,"value":"held in Geneva from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.88,"y":393.6,"width":95.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":171,"blockId":6,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.88,"y":393.84,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":172,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":395.04,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":173,"blockId":6,"value":"14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":393.84,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":174,"blockId":6,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":477.84,"y":393.6,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":175,"blockId":6,"value":"2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":393.84,"width":23.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"1.14 The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":176,"blockId":6,"value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":177,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":178,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":179,"blockId":6,"value":"was delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":62.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":180,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":166.56,"y":445.68,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":181,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":444.24,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":182,"blockId":6,"value":"Parties, and they were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":197.76,"y":444.24,"width":101.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":183,"blockId":6,"value":"granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":304.32,"y":444.24,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":184,"blockId":6,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":342.0,"y":444.24,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":185,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":445.68,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":186,"blockId":6,"value":"address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.56,"y":444.24,"width":32.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":187,"blockId":6,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":420.0,"y":444.24,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":188,"blockId":6,"value":"raised by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":465.84,"y":444.24,"width":41.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":189,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":444.24,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":190,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":191,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.56,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":192,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":155.76,"y":456.72,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":193,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.0,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":194,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":459.6,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":195,"blockId":6,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.48,"y":456.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":196,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":252.48,"y":459.6,"width":8.16,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":197,"blockId":6,"value":"other","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.16,"y":456.72,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":198,"blockId":6,"value":"matters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":293.52,"y":457.92,"width":31.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":199,"blockId":6,"value":"arising","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":330.96,"y":456.72,"width":29.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":200,"blockId":6,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":365.52,"y":458.16,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":201,"blockId":6,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":456.72,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":202,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":416.64,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":203,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":457.2,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":204,"blockId":6,"value":"post-hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":470.4,"y":456.72,"width":54.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":205,"blockId":6,"value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":193.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":293.28,"Value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":206,"columnEnd":208,"text":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.15","paragraphId":"pa1.15","paragraphLabel":"1.15","rectangle":"72, 494, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.131147540983607,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":206,"blockId":7,"value":"1.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":494.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":207,"blockId":7,"value":"NThe Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":494.4,"width":145.68,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.15 NThe Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":208,"blockId":7,"value":"file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":507.36,"width":149.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":249.12,"Value":"file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":209,"columnEnd":212,"text":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.116","paragraphId":"pa1.16","paragraphLabel":"1.16","rectangle":"72, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":8.283154121863799,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":209,"blockId":8,"value":"1.16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.8,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":210,"blockId":8,"value":"On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.16 On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":211,"blockId":8,"value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.28,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":212,"blockId":8,"value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":558.0,"width":374.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":472.56000000000006,"Value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":526.56}},{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":213,"columnEnd":246,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </div><div><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </div><div><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.17","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.117","paragraphId":"pa1.17","paragraphLabel":"1.17","rectangle":"72, 583, 425, 147","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </p><p><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </p><p><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.421686746987952,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":213,"blockId":9,"value":"1.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":583.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":214,"blockId":9,"value":"The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":252.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":352.08,"Value":"1.17 The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":215,"blockId":9,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":608.88,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":216,"blockId":9,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":631.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":217,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":631.68,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":218,"blockId":9,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":631.68,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":219,"blockId":9,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":631.68,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":220,"blockId":9,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":263.76,"y":631.68,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":221,"blockId":9,"value":"assumed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":281.76,"y":631.68,"width":33.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":222,"blockId":9,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":320.64,"y":631.68,"width":43.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":223,"blockId":9,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":631.68,"width":22.56,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":224,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":396.72,"y":631.68,"width":11.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":225,"blockId":9,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":631.92,"width":25.68,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":226,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":443.76,"y":631.68,"width":7.44,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":227,"blockId":9,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":632.88,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":228,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":631.68,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":229,"blockId":9,"value":"Ukrainian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":643.2,"width":39.6,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":230,"blockId":9,"value":"investors","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":210.72,"y":643.2,"width":35.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":231,"blockId":9,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":253.44,"y":643.2,"width":13.92,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":232,"blockId":9,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":274.56,"y":643.2,"width":18.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":233,"blockId":9,"value":"investments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":643.2,"width":47.04,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":234,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":643.2,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":235,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":368.16,"y":643.2,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":236,"blockId":9,"value":"Crimean","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":387.12,"y":643.2,"width":34.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":237,"blockId":9,"value":"Peninsula","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":643.2,"width":38.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":238,"blockId":9,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":645.6,"width":7.92,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":239,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":643.2,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":240,"blockId":9,"value":"21 March 2014;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":654.72,"width":63.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":227.28,"Value":"21 March 2014;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":241,"blockId":9,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":677.76,"width":6.72,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":242,"blockId":9,"value":"there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":677.76,"width":332.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":496.55999999999995,"Value":"2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":243,"blockId":9,"value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":689.28,"width":222.72,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":386.88,"Value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":244,"blockId":9,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":712.08,"width":6.48,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":245,"blockId":9,"value":"the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":712.08,"width":332.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":496.31999999999994,"Value":"3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":246,"blockId":9,"value":"of the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":723.6,"width":53.28,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":217.2,"Value":"of the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":497.76}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":251,"columnEnd":253,"text":"<div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"127, 115, 368, 30","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":251,"blockId":10,"value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":115.2,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":252,"blockId":10,"value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":126.72,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":253,"blockId":10,"value":"of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":138.24,"width":68.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":196.8,"Value":"of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":254,"columnEnd":261,"text":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.18","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.118","paragraphId":"pa1.18","paragraphLabel":"1.18","rectangle":"72, 162, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","averageFontSize":7.768421052631579,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":254,"blockId":12,"value":"1.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":162.48,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":255,"blockId":12,"value":"On 27 March 2017, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":162.48,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":256,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":213.84,"y":162.48,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":257,"blockId":12,"value":"re-issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":162.48,"width":39.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":258,"blockId":12,"value":"the Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":300.48,"y":162.48,"width":86.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":259,"blockId":12,"value":"correcting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":392.88,"y":162.48,"width":44.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":260,"blockId":12,"value":"four typographical","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.32,"y":162.48,"width":82.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.18 On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":261,"blockId":12,"value":"errors.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":177.84,"width":27.6,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":127.19999999999999,"Value":"errors."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":262,"columnEnd":270,"text":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.119","paragraphId":"pa1.19","paragraphLabel":"1.19","rectangle":"72, 200, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","averageFontSize":9.124809741248097,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":262,"blockId":13,"value":"1.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":200.4,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":263,"blockId":13,"value":"On 11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":200.64,"width":26.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":264,"blockId":13,"value":"July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.56,"y":200.4,"width":394.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.19 On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":265,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":213.12,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":266,"blockId":13,"value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":225.84,"width":426.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":267,"blockId":13,"value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":238.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":268,"blockId":13,"value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":251.04,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":269,"blockId":13,"value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":263.76,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":270,"blockId":13,"value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":276.48,"width":327.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":426.96000000000004,"Value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":271,"columnEnd":286,"text":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.120","paragraphId":"pa1.20","paragraphLabel":"1.20","rectangle":"72, 301, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","averageFontSize":8.218289085545722,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":271,"blockId":14,"value":"1.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":301.92,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":272,"blockId":14,"value":"On the same day,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":301.92,"width":75.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":273,"blockId":14,"value":"11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":301.92,"width":345.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999,"Value":"1.20 On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":274,"blockId":14,"value":"No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":314.64,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":275,"blockId":14,"value":"3,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":120.48,"y":314.64,"width":7.2,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":276,"blockId":14,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":314.4,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":277,"blockId":14,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":314.4,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":278,"blockId":14,"value":"addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.2,"y":314.4,"width":42.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":279,"blockId":14,"value":"15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":314.64,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":280,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":281,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Parties—4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":302.16,"y":315.84,"width":76.8,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":282,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":384.0,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":283,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Claimants and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":429.84,"y":315.84,"width":95.28,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties—4 questions to the Claimants and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":284,"blockId":14,"value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":100.8,"y":327.12,"width":424.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.8,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":285,"blockId":14,"value":"admissibility.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":339.6,"width":66.96,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":166.56,"Value":"admissibility.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":286,"blockId":14,"value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":352.32,"width":232.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":331.44,"Value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":287,"columnEnd":293,"text":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.121","paragraphId":"pa1.21","paragraphLabel":"1.21","rectangle":"72, 377, 452, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.021645021645021,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":287,"blockId":15,"value":"1.21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":377.76,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":288,"blockId":15,"value":"On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":377.76,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.21 On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":289,"blockId":15,"value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":390.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":290,"blockId":15,"value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":402.72,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":291,"blockId":15,"value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":415.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":292,"blockId":15,"value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":429.36,"width":425.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":293,"blockId":15,"value":"Respondent did not provide any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":440.64,"width":190.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":290.15999999999997,"Value":"Respondent did not provide any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":294,"columnEnd":313,"text":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.122","paragraphId":"pa1.22","paragraphLabel":"1.22","rectangle":"72, 466, 452, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":8.05043227665706,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":294,"blockId":16,"value":"1.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":466.32,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":295,"blockId":16,"value":"A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":466.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.22 A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":296,"blockId":16,"value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":478.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":297,"blockId":16,"value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":491.28,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":298,"blockId":16,"value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":504.0,"width":331.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":299,"blockId":16,"value":"all presented by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":436.32,"y":504.0,"width":88.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":300,"blockId":16,"value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":516.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":301,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":529.2,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":302,"blockId":16,"value":"transcript was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":529.2,"width":62.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":303,"blockId":16,"value":"delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":529.2,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":304,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":250.32,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":305,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":263.28,"y":529.2,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":306,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":281.28,"y":529.2,"width":52.8,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":307,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":338.88,"y":529.2,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":308,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":356.88,"y":529.2,"width":55.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":309,"blockId":16,"value":"further granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.6,"y":529.2,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":310,"blockId":16,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":529.2,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":311,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":312,"blockId":16,"value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":541.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":313,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":554.64,"width":163.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":263.03999999999996,"Value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":314,"columnEnd":316,"text":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.123","paragraphId":"pa1.23","paragraphLabel":"1.23","rectangle":"72, 579, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":314,"blockId":17,"value":"1.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":580.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":315,"blockId":17,"value":"NThe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":367.44,"y":579.6,"width":157.92,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.23 NThe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":316,"blockId":17,"value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":592.56,"width":183.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":282.96000000000004,"Value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":317,"columnEnd":319,"text":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.124","paragraphId":"pa1.24","paragraphLabel":"1.24","rectangle":"72, 618, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.61344537815126,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":317,"blockId":18,"value":"1.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":618.0,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":318,"blockId":18,"value":"By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.24 By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":319,"blockId":18,"value":"from the Parties,|G","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":630.48,"width":358.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.15999999999997,"Value":"from the Parties,|G"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}},{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":320,"columnEnd":335,"text":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.25","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.25","paragraphLabel":"1.25","rectangle":"72, 655, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":7.85064935064935,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":320,"blockId":19,"value":"1.25","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":655.92,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":321,"blockId":19,"value":"On 4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":322,"blockId":19,"value":"February","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.08,"y":655.92,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":323,"blockId":19,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":175.68,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":324,"blockId":19,"value":"having","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":206.4,"y":655.92,"width":29.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":325,"blockId":19,"value":"deliberated,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":242.16,"y":655.68,"width":51.12,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":326,"blockId":19,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":655.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":327,"blockId":19,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.96,"y":655.68,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":328,"blockId":19,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":362.88,"y":655.68,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":329,"blockId":19,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.24,"y":658.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":330,"blockId":19,"value":"unanimous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":655.92,"width":47.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":331,"blockId":19,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":461.04,"y":655.68,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":332,"blockId":19,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":495.6,"y":655.92,"width":29.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":333,"blockId":19,"value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":668.64,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":334,"blockId":19,"value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":335,"blockId":19,"value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":693.84,"width":155.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":254.88,"Value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":340,"columnEnd":363,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </div><div><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </div><div><br></div><div>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</div><div>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.26","paragraphId":"pa1.26","paragraphLabel":"1.26","rectangle":"72, 115, 425, 148","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </p><p><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </p><p><br></p><p>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</p><p>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.01875,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":340,"blockId":22,"value":"1.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":115.44,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":341,"blockId":22,"value":"The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":248.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":348.48,"Value":"1.26 The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":342,"blockId":22,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":140.64,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":343,"blockId":22,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":163.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":344,"blockId":22,"value":"the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":163.44,"width":287.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":451.43999999999994,"Value":"1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":345,"blockId":22,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":186.72,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":346,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":186.48,"width":160.32,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":324.24,"Value":"2. PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":347,"blockId":22,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":209.76,"width":6.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":348,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":349,"blockId":22,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":209.52,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":350,"blockId":22,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":220.08,"y":209.52,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":351,"blockId":22,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":268.8,"y":209.52,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":352,"blockId":22,"value":"breached","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":288.48,"y":209.52,"width":36.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":353,"blockId":22,"value":"Article","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":330.72,"y":209.52,"width":27.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":354,"blockId":22,"value":"5","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":364.8,"y":209.76,"width":3.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":355,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":375.84,"y":209.52,"width":8.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":356,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":390.0,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":357,"blockId":22,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":408.24,"y":209.76,"width":25.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":358,"blockId":22,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":440.64,"y":209.52,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":359,"blockId":22,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.32,"y":210.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":360,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":209.52,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":498.0,"Value":"3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":361,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s investment.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":221.04,"width":100.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":264.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s investment."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":362,"blockId":22,"value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":245.04,"width":368.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.32,"Value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":363,"blockId":22,"value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":258.0,"width":267.12,"height":5.52,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":395.04,"Value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":498.0}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":364,"columnEnd":364,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.27","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.27","paragraphLabel":"1.27","rectangle":"72, 280, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":364,"blockId":23,"value":"11279","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":280.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999,"Value":"11279"}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":365,"columnEnd":368,"text":" On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.28","paragraphId":"pa1.28","paragraphLabel":"1.28","rectangle":"72, 355, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.117647058823529,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":365,"blockId":24,"value":"1.28","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":355.2,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":366,"blockId":24,"value":"On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.2,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.28 On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":367,"blockId":24,"value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.68,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":368,"blockId":24,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":54.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":154.56,"Value":"proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":369,"columnEnd":391,"text":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.29","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.129","paragraphId":"pa1.29","paragraphLabel":"1.29","rectangle":"72, 405, 452, 59","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","averageFontSize":8.882488479262673,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":369,"blockId":25,"value":"1.29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":405.36,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":370,"blockId":25,"value":"By","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.36,"width":12.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":371,"blockId":25,"value":"letter","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":119.04,"y":405.12,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":372,"blockId":25,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.08,"y":405.12,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":373,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":163.44,"y":405.12,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":374,"blockId":25,"value":"same","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":183.84,"y":407.76,"width":21.6,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":375,"blockId":25,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":212.4,"y":405.12,"width":20.4,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":376,"blockId":25,"value":"22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.0,"y":405.36,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":377,"blockId":25,"value":"March","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":257.52,"y":405.12,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":378,"blockId":25,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":405.36,"width":24.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":379,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":323.76,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":380,"blockId":25,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":405.12,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":381,"blockId":25,"value":"recalled","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":388.08,"y":405.12,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":382,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":429.12,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":383,"blockId":25,"value":"finding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":405.12,"width":31.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":384,"blockId":25,"value":"made","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.2,"y":405.12,"width":23.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":385,"blockId":25,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.44,"y":406.56,"width":7.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.8800000000001,"Value":"1.29 By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":386,"blockId":25,"value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":417.6,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":387,"blockId":25,"value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":430.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":388,"blockId":25,"value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":443.04,"width":390.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":389,"blockId":25,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":494.88,"y":443.28,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":390,"blockId":25,"value":"April","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":443.04,"width":22.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":391,"blockId":25,"value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.76,"width":320.64,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":420.24,"Value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":392,"columnEnd":419,"text":" On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going forward. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.30","paragraphId":"pa1.30","paragraphLabel":"1.30","rectangle":"72, 480, 452, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.335540838852097,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":392,"blockId":27,"value":"1.30","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":480.48,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":393,"blockId":27,"value":"On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":480.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.30 On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":394,"blockId":27,"value":"comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.4,"width":44.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":395,"blockId":27,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":492.96,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":396,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.36,"y":492.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":397,"blockId":27,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":196.56,"y":492.96,"width":54.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":398,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":492.96,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":399,"blockId":27,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":276.0,"y":492.96,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":400,"blockId":27,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":492.96,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":401,"blockId":27,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.8,"y":492.96,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":402,"blockId":27,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.08,"y":492.96,"width":46.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":403,"blockId":27,"value":"5,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":459.12,"y":493.44,"width":7.2,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":404,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":473.04,"y":492.96,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":405,"blockId":27,"value":"which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.96,"y":492.96,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":406,"blockId":27,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":519.84,"y":492.96,"width":5.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":407,"blockId":27,"value":"determined that,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.44,"width":72.72,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":408,"blockId":27,"value":"absent any reasoned","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.6,"y":505.44,"width":91.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":409,"blockId":27,"value":"application by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":274.32,"y":505.44,"width":64.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":410,"blockId":27,"value":"Finilon","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.2,"y":505.44,"width":31.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":411,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":506.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":412,"blockId":27,"value":"continue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":505.44,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":413,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":506.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":414,"blockId":27,"value":"participate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":447.84,"y":505.44,"width":46.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":415,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.2,"y":505.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":416,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":505.44,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":417,"blockId":27,"value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":518.16,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":418,"blockId":27,"value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":530.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":419,"blockId":27,"value":"forward.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":543.36,"width":36.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":136.32,"Value":"forward."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":420,"columnEnd":449,"text":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.31","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.131","paragraphId":"pa1.31","paragraphLabel":"1.31","rectangle":"72, 568, 452, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","averageFontSize":8.667431192660551,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":420,"blockId":28,"value":"1.31","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":568.32,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":421,"blockId":28,"value":"By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":568.56,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.31 By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":422,"blockId":28,"value":"useful","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":580.56,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":423,"blockId":28,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":131.52,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":424,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":425,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.28,"y":580.56,"width":81.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":426,"blockId":28,"value":"further submissions on damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":580.56,"width":146.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":427,"blockId":28,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":580.8,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":428,"blockId":28,"value":"take","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":580.56,"width":17.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":429,"blockId":28,"value":"into","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":451.44,"y":580.56,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":430,"blockId":28,"value":"account","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":473.28,"y":582.0,"width":33.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":431,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":580.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":432,"blockId":28,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":593.28,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":433,"blockId":28,"value":"findings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":593.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":434,"blockId":28,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.92,"y":593.28,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":435,"blockId":28,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":208.8,"y":593.28,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":436,"blockId":28,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":593.28,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":437,"blockId":28,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":259.68,"y":593.28,"width":29.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":438,"blockId":28,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":593.52,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":439,"blockId":28,"value":"invited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.0,"y":593.28,"width":30.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":440,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":593.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":441,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.16,"y":593.28,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":442,"blockId":28,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":420.48,"y":594.72,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":443,"blockId":28,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":593.52,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":444,"blockId":28,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":464.88,"y":593.52,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":445,"blockId":28,"value":"revised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":493.44,"y":593.28,"width":31.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":446,"blockId":28,"value":"submissions by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":606.24,"width":68.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":447,"blockId":28,"value":"19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":606.0,"width":329.04,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":448,"blockId":28,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":507.12,"y":606.0,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":449,"blockId":28,"value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.96,"width":409.68,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":509.28,"Value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":450,"columnEnd":450,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.32","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.32","paragraphLabel":"1.32","rectangle":"72, 643, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":450,"blockId":29,"value":"1.32","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":643.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.32"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":451,"columnEnd":453,"text":" By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s extension request by 21 May 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.33","paragraphId":"pa1.33","paragraphLabel":"1.33","rectangle":"72, 680, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":9.430769230769231,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":451,"blockId":30,"value":"1.33","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":680.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":452,"blockId":30,"value":"By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":681.12,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.33 By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":453,"blockId":30,"value":"extension request by 21 May 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":693.36,"width":153.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":253.44,"Value":"extension request by 21 May 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":454,"columnEnd":454,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.34","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.34","paragraphLabel":"1.34","rectangle":"72, 718, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":454,"blockId":31,"value":"1.34","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":718.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.34"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":459,"columnEnd":459,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.35","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.35","paragraphLabel":"1.35","rectangle":"72, 204, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":459,"blockId":32,"value":"1.35","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":204.24,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.35"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}},{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":460,"columnEnd":460,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36","paragraphLabel":"1.36","rectangle":"72, 495, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":460,"blockId":33,"value":"1.36","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":495.12,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.36"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":461,"columnEnd":461,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.i","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"128, 735, 10, 8","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":461,"blockId":36,"value":"~ —--~","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":735.12,"width":10.8,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96,"Value":"~ —--~"}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":466,"columnEnd":468,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"127, 115, 372, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":466,"blockId":37,"value":"<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":115.2,"width":14.16,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":142.32,"Value":"<"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":467,"blockId":37,"value":"e","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.44,"y":126.72,"width":372.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"e"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":468,"blockId":37,"value":".","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.68,"y":138.24,"width":371.76,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.68,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"."}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":470,"columnEnd":474,"text":" By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37","paragraphId":"pa1.37","paragraphLabel":"1.37","rectangle":"72, 174, 452, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.886426592797784,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":470,"blockId":41,"value":"1.37","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":174.0,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":471,"blockId":41,"value":"By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":174.24,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.37 By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":472,"blockId":41,"value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":186.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":473,"blockId":41,"value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":199.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":474,"blockId":41,"value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":211.92,"width":277.92,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":377.52,"Value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":475,"columnEnd":478,"text":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.38","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37.138","paragraphId":"pa1.38","paragraphLabel":"1.38","rectangle":"72, 237, 452, 19","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","averageFontSize":7.559523809523809,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":475,"blockId":42,"value":"1.38","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":237.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":476,"blockId":42,"value":"By letter dated 4 July 2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":237.6,"width":126.0,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":477,"blockId":42,"value":"at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":230.4,"y":238.8,"width":294.48,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.38 By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":478,"blockId":42,"value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":249.84,"width":300.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":399.84000000000003,"Value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":479,"columnEnd":479,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.39","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.39","paragraphLabel":"1.39","rectangle":"72, 275, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":479,"blockId":43,"value":"1.39","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":275.52,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.39"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":480,"columnEnd":480,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.40","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.40","paragraphLabel":"1.40","rectangle":"72, 351, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":480,"blockId":44,"value":"1.40","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":351.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.40"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":481,"columnEnd":481,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.41","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.41","paragraphLabel":"1.41","rectangle":"72, 414, 16, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":481,"blockId":45,"value":"1.41","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":414.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56,"Value":"1.41"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":482,"columnEnd":499,"text":"<div>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.42","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.42o","paragraphId":"pa1.42","paragraphLabel":"1.42","rectangle":"72, 439, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</p>","averageFontSize":6.321782178217822,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":482,"blockId":46,"value":"1.42","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":439.68,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":483,"blockId":46,"value":"o<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":439.92,"width":12.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":484,"blockId":46,"value":"a.!—fi[~ (¢}=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":118.32,"y":442.32,"width":19.44,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":485,"blockId":46,"value":"Q.©-[¢}o, oN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":439.44,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":486,"blockId":46,"value":"A=t[=]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":13.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":439.92,"width":9.36,"height":13.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":487,"blockId":46,"value":"=< o) P— \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":193.68,"y":442.32,"width":29.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":488,"blockId":46,"value":"-Bo H o=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":440.88,"width":29.04,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":489,"blockId":46,"value":"c=© B o©-Q&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":264.72,"y":442.08,"width":37.68,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":490,"blockId":46,"value":"o,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.36,"y":439.44,"width":5.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":491,"blockId":46,"value":"=©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.64,"y":439.44,"width":143.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":492,"blockId":46,"value":"-=o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":440.88,"width":12.96,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.42 o< a.!—fi[~ (¢}= Q.©-[¢}o, oN A=t[=] =< o) P— \\O -Bo H o= c=© B o©-Q& o, =©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO: -=o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":493,"blockId":46,"value":">","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":224.4,"y":446.16,"width":1.44,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":494,"blockId":46,"value":"[","fontName":"Times","fontSize":2.0,"color":null,"x":328.32,"y":447.36,"width":5.76,"height":1.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":224.4,"MarginRight":334.08,"Value":"> ["},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":495,"blockId":46,"value":"’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":263.52,"y":452.64,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":263.52,"MarginRight":265.2,"Value":"’"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":496,"blockId":46,"value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.04,"width":162.72,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":497,"blockId":46,"value":"w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":455.04,"width":59.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":498,"blockId":46,"value":"2o P","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.76,"y":452.4,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":499,"blockId":46,"value":"&< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":353.28,"y":452.4,"width":90.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":443.28,"Value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8= w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@& 2o P &< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":500,"columnEnd":513,"text":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.43","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.143","paragraphId":"pa1.43","paragraphLabel":"1.43","rectangle":"72, 477, 452, 33","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","averageFontSize":5.817204301075269,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":500,"blockId":47,"value":"1.43","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":477.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":501,"blockId":47,"value":"low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":477.84,"width":139.68,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":502,"blockId":47,"value":"—=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":246.0,"y":478.8,"width":279.12,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.43 low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O —=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":503,"blockId":47,"value":"2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":484.08,"width":1.44,"height":2.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":241.92,"Value":"2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":504,"blockId":47,"value":"<=(=\"","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":492.96,"width":17.76,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":505,"blockId":47,"value":"Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":491.52,"width":84.72,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":506,"blockId":47,"value":"w2 a e~ >2oa","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":211.44,"y":490.56,"width":42.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":507,"blockId":47,"value":"5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":258.96,"y":490.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":508,"blockId":47,"value":"o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":492.96,"width":107.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":509,"blockId":47,"value":"o=o g=Qo<o[¢]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":431.52,"y":491.52,"width":45.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":510,"blockId":47,"value":"o= oo[oN&-o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":482.16,"y":492.96,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"<=(=\" Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo w2 a e~ >2oa 5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ» o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a» o=o g=Qo<o[¢] o= oo[oN&-o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":511,"blockId":47,"value":"s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":496.8,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":312.96,"MarginRight":314.64,"Value":"s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":512,"blockId":47,"value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.68,"width":162.48,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":513,"blockId":47,"value":"=B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":268.56,"y":505.68,"width":89.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":358.32,"Value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w =B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":514,"columnEnd":514,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.44","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.44","paragraphLabel":"1.44","rectangle":"72, 528, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":514,"blockId":48,"value":"1.44","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":528.24,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.44"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":515,"columnEnd":515,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.45","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.45","paragraphLabel":"1.45","rectangle":"72, 553, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":515,"blockId":49,"value":"1.45","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":553.68,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.45"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}},{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":516,"columnEnd":535,"text":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46","paragraphId":"pa1.46","paragraphLabel":"1.46","rectangle":"72, 692, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","averageFontSize":8.202090592334494,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":516,"blockId":50,"value":"1.46","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":692.64,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":517,"blockId":50,"value":"As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":692.88,"width":426.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.46 As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":518,"blockId":50,"value":"informed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":705.36,"width":39.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":519,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":520,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.96,"y":705.36,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":521,"blockId":50,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":705.36,"width":32.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":522,"blockId":50,"value":"numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":222.0,"y":708.0,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":523,"blockId":50,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":271.92,"y":705.36,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":524,"blockId":50,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":331.44,"y":708.0,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":525,"blockId":50,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.24,"y":705.36,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":526,"blockId":50,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":370.32,"y":705.36,"width":21.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":527,"blockId":50,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":398.16,"y":706.56,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":528,"blockId":50,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.04,"y":705.36,"width":20.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":529,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":440.16,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":530,"blockId":50,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":705.36,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":531,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":532,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":495.12,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":533,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":705.36,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":534,"blockId":50,"value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":718.08,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":535,"blockId":50,"value":"the present Order.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":730.8,"width":78.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":177.84,"Value":"the present Order."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":540,"columnEnd":540,"text":" Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h2","paragraphIdAuto":"hThe","paragraphId":"h2","paragraphLabel":"2.","rectangle":"99, 115, 176, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":540,"blockId":51,"value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.92,"width":176.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":541,"columnEnd":542,"text":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.i","paragraphIdAuto":"hi","paragraphId":"h2.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"96, 227, 319, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","averageFontSize":8.19047619047619,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":541,"blockId":55,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":227.52,"width":12.0,"height":12.0,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":542,"blockId":55,"value":"The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":228.48,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997,"Value":"(i) The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":543,"columnEnd":563,"text":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><span class=\"supertext\">1</span></a>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.2","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.To","paragraphId":"pa2.2","paragraphLabel":"2.2","rectangle":"99, 254, 425, 108","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><sup>1</sup></a>","averageFontSize":7.9171597633136095,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":543,"blockId":54,"value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":544,"blockId":54,"value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":269.04,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":545,"blockId":54,"value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.12,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":546,"blockId":54,"value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":291.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":547,"blockId":54,"value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":304.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":548,"blockId":54,"value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.04,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility."},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":549,"blockId":54,"value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":550,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":551,"blockId":54,"value":"remained","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":342.48,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":552,"blockId":54,"value":"outstanding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.0,"y":342.48,"width":51.12,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":553,"blockId":54,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":342.48,"width":19.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":554,"blockId":54,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":342.48,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":555,"blockId":54,"value":"Interim Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":342.48,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":556,"blockId":54,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":339.36,"y":342.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":557,"blockId":54,"value":"found","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.96,"y":342.48,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":558,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":559,"blockId":54,"value":"“it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.0,"y":342.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":560,"blockId":54,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":430.32,"y":342.48,"width":14.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":561,"blockId":54,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":342.48,"width":50.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":562,"blockId":54,"value":"over","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":506.16,"y":345.12,"width":19.2,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that “it has jurisdiction over"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":563,"blockId":54,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":354.96,"width":380.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":480.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":564,"columnEnd":573,"text":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.3","paragraphLabel":"2.3","rectangle":"99, 380, 425, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.03,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":564,"blockId":58,"value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":565,"blockId":58,"value":"from which the Tribunal derives","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":393.12,"width":145.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":566,"blockId":58,"value":"its jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":393.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":567,"blockId":58,"value":"the “arbitral award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":393.12,"width":84.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":568,"blockId":58,"value":"shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":393.12,"width":115.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the “arbitral award shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":569,"blockId":58,"value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":408.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":570,"blockId":58,"value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":571,"blockId":58,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":433.92,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":572,"blockId":58,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.44,"y":431.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":573,"blockId":58,"value":"parties.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":431.04,"width":36.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":169.92,"Value":"on the parties.”"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":574,"columnEnd":580,"text":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.4","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.It","paragraphId":"pa2.4","paragraphLabel":"2.4","rectangle":"99, 481, 426, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","averageFontSize":7.6716417910447765,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":574,"blockId":59,"value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":481.92,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":575,"blockId":59,"value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":494.16,"width":426.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":576,"blockId":59,"value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.88,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":577,"blockId":59,"value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":521.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":578,"blockId":59,"value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":532.08,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":579,"blockId":59,"value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":544.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":580,"blockId":59,"value":"the Tribunal in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.52,"width":117.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":216.95999999999998,"Value":"the Tribunal in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":581,"columnEnd":583,"text":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.6","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.6","paragraphLabel":"2.6","rectangle":"99, 680, 425, 22","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","averageFontSize":8.870466321243523,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":581,"blockId":61,"value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":680.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":582,"blockId":61,"value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":693.36,"width":382.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":583,"blockId":61,"value":"evidence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.72,"y":693.36,"width":38.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’ evidence"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":584,"columnEnd":586,"text":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn1","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"fn1","paragraphLabel":"1","rectangle":"72, 737, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":584,"blockId":63,"value":"! Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":72.0,"y":737.76,"width":62.64,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"! Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":585,"blockId":63,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":740.88,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":586,"blockId":63,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":738.48,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":205.2}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":591,"columnEnd":597,"text":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.889855072463767,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":591,"blockId":66,"value":"and argument over the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":102.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":592,"blockId":66,"value":"last two phases of the proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":115.44,"width":159.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":593,"blockId":66,"value":"in particular by putting numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":115.44,"width":152.64,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":594,"blockId":66,"value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":174.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":595,"blockId":66,"value":"1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.88,"y":127.92,"width":246.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":596,"blockId":66,"value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":142.08,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":597,"blockId":66,"value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":286.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":386.64,"Value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":598,"columnEnd":681,"text":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><span class=\"supertext\">4</span></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.7","paragraphId":"pa2.7","paragraphLabel":"2.7","rectangle":"71, 178, 455, 276","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><sup>4</sup></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","averageFontSize":8.661600810536981,"rowsOfText":22,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":598,"blockId":67,"value":"2.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":178.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":599,"blockId":67,"value":"Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.8,"width":425.52,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.7 Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":600,"blockId":67,"value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":601,"blockId":67,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":602,"blockId":67,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":206.64,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":603,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.24,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":604,"blockId":67,"value":"of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":204.0,"width":84.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":605,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":294.48,"y":204.0,"width":56.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":606,"blockId":67,"value":"(as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":204.0,"width":12.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":607,"blockId":67,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":373.2,"y":204.0,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":608,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":206.64,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":609,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":610,"blockId":67,"value":"of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":611,"blockId":67,"value":"Thus,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":612,"blockId":67,"value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":613,"blockId":67,"value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":614,"blockId":67,"value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":244.56,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":615,"blockId":67,"value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":254.64,"width":350.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":616,"blockId":67,"value":"(ii1) granted the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":254.4,"width":70.08,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":617,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":618,"blockId":67,"value":"issues,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.84,"width":28.32,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":619,"blockId":67,"value":"including with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":279.84,"width":64.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":620,"blockId":67,"value":"respect to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":281.04,"width":43.44,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":621,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":279.84,"width":114.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":622,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":370.56,"y":279.84,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":623,"blockId":67,"value":"(as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":280.08,"width":35.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":624,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":282.48,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":625,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.0,"y":279.84,"width":40.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":626,"blockId":67,"value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":627,"blockId":67,"value":"pleadings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":41.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":628,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":146.88,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":629,"blockId":67,"value":"other communications","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.76,"y":305.04,"width":99.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":630,"blockId":67,"value":"from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":305.04,"width":39.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":631,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":317.28,"y":305.04,"width":42.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":632,"blockId":67,"value":"including","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":305.04,"width":41.04,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":633,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":411.36,"y":305.04,"width":19.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":634,"blockId":67,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":435.84,"y":306.48,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":635,"blockId":67,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":471.84,"y":306.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":636,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.52,"y":305.04,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":637,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":516.48,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":638,"blockId":67,"value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":317.76,"width":426.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":639,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.24,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":640,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant, to comment on the proposed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":117.84,"y":330.24,"width":180.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":641,"blockId":67,"value":"candidacy,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":302.88,"y":330.24,"width":46.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":642,"blockId":67,"value":"terms","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":331.44,"width":23.76,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":643,"blockId":67,"value":"of reference and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":383.52,"y":330.24,"width":74.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":644,"blockId":67,"value":"reports of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":463.2,"y":331.68,"width":61.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":645,"blockId":67,"value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":646,"blockId":67,"value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":647,"blockId":67,"value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":368.16,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":648,"blockId":67,"value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":380.88,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":649,"blockId":67,"value":"timely","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":27.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":650,"blockId":67,"value":"manner,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":396.24,"width":35.04,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":651,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":393.6,"width":19.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":652,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":653,"blockId":67,"value":"transcripts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":216.24,"y":393.6,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":654,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":267.36,"y":393.6,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":655,"blockId":67,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":288.24,"y":393.6,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":656,"blockId":67,"value":"other documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":304.08,"y":393.6,"width":74.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":657,"blockId":67,"value":"submitted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":393.6,"width":42.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":658,"blockId":67,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":432.72,"y":393.6,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":659,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":445.92,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":660,"blockId":67,"value":"course","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":464.4,"y":396.24,"width":28.32,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":661,"blockId":67,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":393.6,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":662,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":406.08,"width":39.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":663,"blockId":67,"value":"and (vii) provided an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":406.08,"width":97.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":664,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunity","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":247.2,"y":406.08,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":665,"blockId":67,"value":"for, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.12,"y":406.08,"width":35.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":666,"blockId":75,"value":"invited, the Respondent to comment on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":406.08,"width":181.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":667,"blockId":67,"value":"anything","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":418.8,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":668,"blockId":67,"value":"said","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":418.8,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":669,"blockId":67,"value":"during","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.48,"y":418.8,"width":28.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":670,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":418.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":671,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings.*","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":418.08,"width":43.44,"height":11.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":672,"blockId":67,"value":"The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.88,"y":419.04,"width":16.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":673,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":296.16,"y":419.04,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":674,"blockId":67,"value":"did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.24,"y":419.04,"width":13.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":675,"blockId":67,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":420.48,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":676,"blockId":67,"value":"avail","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.8,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":677,"blockId":67,"value":"itself of any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":422.4,"y":419.04,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":678,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":419.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":679,"blockId":67,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.8,"y":419.04,"width":22.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"anything said during the hearings.* The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":680,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":681,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility (or issues of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":444.24,"width":155.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":255.6,"Value":"admissibility (or issues of liability)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":682,"columnEnd":687,"text":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.8","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.28","paragraphId":"pa2.8","paragraphLabel":"2.8","rectangle":"71, 469, 453, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.450777202072539,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":682,"blockId":68,"value":"2.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":469.68,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":683,"blockId":68,"value":"Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.8 Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":684,"blockId":68,"value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":685,"blockId":68,"value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":686,"blockId":68,"value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":687,"blockId":68,"value":"|||><g&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":48.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":520.56,"width":34.08,"height":47.76,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":133.2,"Value":"|||><g&"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":688,"columnEnd":707,"text":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.9","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.9","paragraphLabel":"2.9","rectangle":"71, 583, 454, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","averageFontSize":8.710526315789474,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":688,"blockId":69,"value":"29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":689,"blockId":69,"value":"The Tribunal is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":70.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":690,"blockId":69,"value":"also mindful of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.96,"y":583.2,"width":86.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":691,"blockId":69,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.88,"y":583.2,"width":47.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":692,"blockId":69,"value":"interest","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":583.2,"width":31.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":693,"blockId":69,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":583.2,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":694,"blockId":69,"value":"the finality of the Awards and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":368.64,"y":583.2,"width":156.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"29 The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant’s interest in the finality of the Awards and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":695,"blockId":69,"value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":696,"blockId":69,"value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":697,"blockId":69,"value":"jurisdiction were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":621.12,"width":77.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":698,"blockId":69,"value":"granted. Moreover, now","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":621.36,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":699,"blockId":69,"value":"that the Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":621.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":700,"blockId":69,"value":"courts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":367.2,"y":622.56,"width":26.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":701,"blockId":69,"value":"are","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":624.0,"width":12.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":702,"blockId":69,"value":"seised of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.12,"y":621.12,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":703,"blockId":69,"value":"Set Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":481.44,"y":621.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":704,"blockId":69,"value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":634.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":705,"blockId":69,"value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":706,"blockId":69,"value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":707,"blockId":69,"value":"supervisory jurisdiction.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":672.0,"width":105.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":205.68,"Value":"supervisory jurisdiction."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":708,"columnEnd":711,"text":" In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10","paragraphId":"pa2.10","paragraphLabel":"2.10","rectangle":"71, 697, 454, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":7.674496644295302,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":708,"blockId":73,"value":"2.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":697.44,"width":18.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":6,"id":709,"blockId":73,"value":"In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":697.68,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.10 In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":710,"blockId":73,"value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":711,"blockId":73,"value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal"}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":712,"columnEnd":715,"text":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"fn4","paragraphId":"fn4","paragraphLabel":"4","rectangle":"71, 760, 228, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","averageFontSize":6.722222222222222,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":712,"blockId":72,"value":"4 See Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":760.56,"width":83.28,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":154.32,"Value":"4 See Interim Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":713,"blockId":72,"value":"para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":763.92,"width":19.2,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":714,"blockId":72,"value":"154; Partial Award, para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":180.96,"y":761.52,"width":99.12,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":715,"blockId":72,"value":"176.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":284.64,"y":761.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":157.44,"MarginRight":300.0,"Value":"para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176."}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":300.0}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":720,"columnEnd":724,"text":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa","paragraphIdAuto":"pai.in","paragraphId":"pa","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 147, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.84,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":720,"blockId":74,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.44,"width":8.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":721,"blockId":74,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.68,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":722,"blockId":74,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":115.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":723,"blockId":74,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.92,"y":115.44,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":724,"blockId":74,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":115.44,"width":55.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96,"Value":"in the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":725,"columnEnd":733,"text":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.211","paragraphId":"pa2.11","paragraphLabel":"2.11","rectangle":"71, 166, 453, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","averageFontSize":9.064615384615385,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":725,"blockId":76,"value":"2.11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":88.8,"Value":"2.11"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":726,"blockId":76,"value":"he Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":474.72,"y":178.56,"width":50.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":474.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"he Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":727,"blockId":76,"value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":728,"blockId":76,"value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":729,"blockId":76,"value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.48,"width":189.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":730,"blockId":76,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":216.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":731,"blockId":76,"value":"other applicable jurisdictional and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":308.88,"y":216.48,"width":155.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":732,"blockId":76,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":468.72,"y":216.48,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":733,"blockId":76,"value":"requirements under the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":134.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":234.48,"Value":"requirements under the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":734,"columnEnd":765,"text":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.12","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.212","paragraphId":"pa2.12","paragraphLabel":"2.12","rectangle":"71, 254, 454, 172","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","averageFontSize":9.06353591160221,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":734,"blockId":79,"value":"2.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":254.64,"width":18.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.12"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":735,"blockId":79,"value":"IAlthough the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":330.48,"width":102.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":736,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":207.12,"y":330.48,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":737,"blockId":79,"value":"could","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":264.24,"y":330.48,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":738,"blockId":79,"value":"have","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":330.48,"width":20.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":739,"blockId":79,"value":"raised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":330.48,"width":25.92,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":740,"blockId":79,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":330.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":741,"blockId":79,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":330.48,"width":21.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":742,"blockId":79,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":399.36,"y":331.92,"width":7.44,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":743,"blockId":79,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":412.32,"y":333.12,"width":9.84,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":744,"blockId":79,"value":"earlier","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":427.92,"y":330.48,"width":27.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":745,"blockId":79,"value":"stage","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":461.28,"y":331.92,"width":21.84,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":746,"blockId":79,"value":"of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":330.48,"width":36.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"IAlthough the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":747,"blockId":79,"value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.96,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":748,"blockId":79,"value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":749,"blockId":79,"value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":368.4,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":750,"blockId":79,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":382.56,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":751,"blockId":79,"value":"minimize","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.48,"y":381.12,"width":40.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":752,"blockId":79,"value":"any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":161.76,"y":383.76,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":753,"blockId":79,"value":"delay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":183.6,"y":381.12,"width":23.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":754,"blockId":79,"value":"resulting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":213.6,"y":381.12,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":755,"blockId":79,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":258.24,"y":381.12,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":756,"blockId":79,"value":"such","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.6,"y":381.12,"width":19.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":757,"blockId":79,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":311.76,"y":381.12,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":758,"blockId":79,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":381.12,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":759,"blockId":79,"value":"given","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":393.36,"y":381.12,"width":23.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":760,"blockId":79,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":423.6,"y":381.12,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":761,"blockId":79,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":381.12,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":762,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":465.6,"y":381.12,"width":59.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":763,"blockId":79,"value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":395.04,"width":425.28,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":764,"blockId":79,"value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.32,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":765,"blockId":79,"value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":419.04,"width":424.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":766,"columnEnd":781,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:13","paragraphId":"pa2.13","paragraphLabel":"2:13","rectangle":"71, 444, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","averageFontSize":8.380434782608695,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":766,"blockId":80,"value":"2:13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":444.48,"width":18.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":767,"blockId":80,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:13 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":768,"blockId":80,"value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":769,"blockId":80,"value":"paragraph","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":43.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":770,"blockId":80,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.76,"y":469.68,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":771,"blockId":80,"value":"below)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.72,"y":469.44,"width":30.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":772,"blockId":80,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":211.2,"y":469.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":773,"blockId":80,"value":"Respondent may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":230.88,"y":469.44,"width":76.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":774,"blockId":80,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":313.44,"y":469.44,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":775,"blockId":80,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.44,"y":469.44,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":776,"blockId":80,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.2,"y":469.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":777,"blockId":80,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":417.36,"y":470.88,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":778,"blockId":80,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.56,"y":469.44,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":779,"blockId":80,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":469.92,"y":469.44,"width":9.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":780,"blockId":80,"value":"Illegality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":486.24,"y":469.44,"width":39.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":781,"blockId":80,"value":"Objection.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":144.95999999999998,"Value":"Objection."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":782,"columnEnd":783,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.ii","paragraphIdAuto":"hii","paragraphId":"h2.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"96, 506, 269, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","averageFontSize":8.307692307692308,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":782,"blockId":81,"value":"(ii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":506.64,"width":15.12,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":783,"blockId":81,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":507.36,"width":229.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24,"Value":"(ii) The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":784,"columnEnd":799,"text":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.214","paragraphId":"pa2.14","paragraphLabel":"2.14","rectangle":"71, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.7631578947368425,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":784,"blockId":82,"value":"2.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":532.8,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":785,"blockId":82,"value":"In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":533.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.14 In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":786,"blockId":82,"value":"requests","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":546.72,"width":35.52,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":787,"blockId":82,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":141.84,"y":545.28,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":788,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.4,"y":545.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":789,"blockId":82,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":184.08,"y":545.28,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":790,"blockId":82,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":228.24,"y":546.72,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":791,"blockId":82,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":545.28,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":792,"blockId":82,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":280.32,"y":545.28,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":793,"blockId":82,"value":"pending","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":545.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":794,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":381.36,"y":545.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":795,"blockId":82,"value":"outcome","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":401.04,"y":546.72,"width":37.2,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":796,"blockId":82,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":444.96,"y":545.28,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":797,"blockId":82,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":480.0,"y":545.76,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":798,"blockId":82,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":545.28,"width":24.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":799,"blockId":82,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":55.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":155.28,"Value":"Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":800,"columnEnd":806,"text":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.15","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.215","paragraphId":"pa2.15","paragraphLabel":"2.15","rectangle":"71, 583, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":8.451965065502183,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":800,"blockId":83,"value":"2.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":801,"blockId":83,"value":"The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.44,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.15 The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":802,"blockId":83,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":596.4,"width":351.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":803,"blockId":83,"value":"law, that would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":596.16,"width":69.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":804,"blockId":83,"value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":805,"blockId":83,"value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":806,"blockId":83,"value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":635.28,"width":313.44,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":413.28,"Value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":807,"columnEnd":817,"text":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:16","paragraphId":"pa2.16","paragraphLabel":"2.16","rectangle":"71, 659, 453, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","averageFontSize":8.691358024691358,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":807,"blockId":84,"value":"2:16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":659.52,"width":18.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":808,"blockId":84,"value":"The Tribunal considers that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":124.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":809,"blockId":84,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":659.52,"width":5.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":810,"blockId":84,"value":"is for the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.8,"y":659.52,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":811,"blockId":84,"value":"establish that a stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.56,"y":659.52,"width":89.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":812,"blockId":84,"value":"is justified by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":659.52,"width":78.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:16 The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":813,"blockId":84,"value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":672.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":814,"blockId":84,"value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":815,"blockId":84,"value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":816,"blockId":84,"value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":817,"blockId":84,"value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":375.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":475.20000000000005,"Value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":818,"columnEnd":819,"text":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn5","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.10.5","paragraphId":"fn5","paragraphLabel":"5","rectangle":"71, 760, 104, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","averageFontSize":5.038461538461538,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":818,"blockId":85,"value":"5 Set Aside Writ,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":66.96,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":138.24,"Value":"5 Set Aside Writ,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":819,"blockId":85,"value":"para. 83.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":141.36,"y":763.92,"width":34.08,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":141.36,"MarginRight":175.44,"Value":"para. 83."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":175.44}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":824,"columnEnd":824,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.17","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.17","paragraphLabel":"2.17","rectangle":"71, 127, 18, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":824,"blockId":86,"value":"2.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":127.92,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.17"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":825,"columnEnd":853,"text":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.18","paragraphId":"pa2.18","paragraphLabel":"2.18","rectangle":"71, 166, 455, 95","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","averageFontSize":8.048780487804878,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":825,"blockId":87,"value":"2.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":826,"blockId":87,"value":"The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":166.08,"width":215.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":827,"blockId":87,"value":"success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.92,"y":166.08,"width":205.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.18 The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":828,"blockId":87,"value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":179.76,"width":425.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":829,"blockId":87,"value":"deciding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":37.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":830,"blockId":87,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.32,"y":191.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":831,"blockId":87,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":160.8,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":832,"blockId":87,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":225.84,"y":192.48,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":833,"blockId":87,"value":"aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":242.64,"y":191.28,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":834,"blockId":87,"value":"application under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":270.24,"y":191.28,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":835,"blockId":87,"value":"law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":385.68,"y":191.28,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":836,"blockId":87,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":837,"blockId":87,"value":"accordingly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":191.28,"width":51.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"deciding the Respondent’s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":838,"blockId":87,"value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":839,"blockId":87,"value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":840,"blockId":87,"value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":229.2,"width":426.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":841,"blockId":87,"value":"Appeal,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":33.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":842,"blockId":87,"value":"ought","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":139.68,"y":241.92,"width":24.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":843,"blockId":87,"value":"nevertheless","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":169.92,"y":241.92,"width":53.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":844,"blockId":87,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":243.12,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":845,"blockId":87,"value":"consider","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.36,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":846,"blockId":87,"value":"whether","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.84,"y":241.92,"width":35.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":847,"blockId":87,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":326.64,"y":244.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":848,"blockId":87,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":337.2,"y":243.12,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":849,"blockId":87,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.0,"y":241.92,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":850,"blockId":87,"value":"proceedings may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":389.76,"y":241.92,"width":77.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":851,"blockId":87,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":852,"blockId":87,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.04,"y":241.92,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":853,"blockId":87,"value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.4,"width":250.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":350.4,"Value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":854,"columnEnd":897,"text":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.219","paragraphId":"pa2.19","paragraphLabel":"2.19","rectangle":"71, 279, 455, 86","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","averageFontSize":9.113138686131387,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":854,"blockId":88,"value":"2.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":280.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":855,"blockId":88,"value":"Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.19 Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":856,"blockId":88,"value":"jurisdictional","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":292.56,"width":58.56,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":857,"blockId":88,"value":"objections","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":292.56,"width":44.64,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":858,"blockId":88,"value":"summarized","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":292.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":859,"blockId":88,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":277.44,"y":292.56,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":860,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":292.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":861,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":292.56,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":862,"blockId":88,"value":"recent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.68,"y":294.0,"width":26.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":863,"blockId":88,"value":"correspondence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.52,"y":292.56,"width":68.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":864,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":292.56,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":865,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":292.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent’s recent correspondence and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":866,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":867,"blockId":88,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":166.08,"y":305.28,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":868,"blockId":88,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":185.76,"y":305.04,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":869,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":217.68,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":870,"blockId":88,"value":"Revocation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":305.04,"width":49.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":871,"blockId":88,"value":"Writs,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":305.04,"width":26.64,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":872,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.04,"y":305.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":873,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":305.04,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":874,"blockId":88,"value":"concludes","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":305.04,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":875,"blockId":88,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.56,"y":305.04,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":876,"blockId":88,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":465.36,"y":307.68,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":877,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":476.4,"y":306.48,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":878,"blockId":88,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":879,"blockId":88,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.52,"y":305.04,"width":9.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":880,"blockId":88,"value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":881,"blockId":88,"value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":882,"blockId":88,"value":"failure","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":883,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":344.4,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":884,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":147.6,"y":344.4,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":885,"blockId":88,"value":"impede","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.4,"y":342.96,"width":31.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":886,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.84,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":887,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":226.56,"y":342.96,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":888,"blockId":88,"value":"ability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":277.92,"y":342.96,"width":27.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":889,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":311.04,"y":344.16,"width":7.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":890,"blockId":88,"value":"fully","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":324.96,"y":342.96,"width":20.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":891,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.64,"y":342.96,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":892,"blockId":88,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":342.96,"width":37.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":893,"blockId":88,"value":"examine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.48,"y":342.96,"width":36.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":894,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":456.96,"y":342.96,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":895,"blockId":88,"value":"decide","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":478.08,"y":342.96,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":896,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"failure to stay impede the Tribunal’s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":897,"blockId":88,"value":"remaining issues before it.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":115.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":214.8,"Value":"remaining issues before it."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":898,"columnEnd":900,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.220","paragraphId":"pa2.20","paragraphLabel":"2.20","rectangle":"71, 380, 453, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.451851851851852,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":898,"blockId":89,"value":"2.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":381.12,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":899,"blockId":89,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.20 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":900,"blockId":89,"value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":395.04,"width":169.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":269.52,"Value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":901,"columnEnd":903,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.iii","paragraphIdAuto":"h2.220.iii","paragraphId":"h2.iii","paragraphLabel":"(iii)","rectangle":"96, 417, 427, 21","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","averageFontSize":8.176991150442477,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":901,"blockId":90,"value":"(iii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":417.84,"width":16.56,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":902,"blockId":90,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.56,"y":418.8,"width":388.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"(iii) The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":903,"blockId":90,"value":"the Merits and Quantum","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":135.84,"y":431.52,"width":107.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":135.84,"MarginRight":243.12,"Value":"the Merits and Quantum"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":904,"columnEnd":908,"text":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.2220","paragraphId":"pa2.21","paragraphLabel":"2.21","rectangle":"71, 456, 453, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","averageFontSize":8.532212885154062,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":904,"blockId":91,"value":"2220","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":456.96,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":905,"blockId":91,"value":"Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2220 Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":906,"blockId":91,"value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":907,"blockId":91,"value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":908,"blockId":91,"value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.64,"width":300.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":400.32000000000005,"Value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":909,"columnEnd":949,"text":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><span class=\"supertext\">7</span></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.222","paragraphId":"pa2.22","paragraphLabel":"2.22","rectangle":"71, 520, 455, 149","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><sup>7</sup></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","averageFontSize":8.214634146341464,"rowsOfText":12,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":909,"blockId":92,"value":"2.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":520.32,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":910,"blockId":92,"value":"In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":520.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.22 In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":911,"blockId":92,"value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":912,"blockId":92,"value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.52,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":913,"blockId":92,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":558.0,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":914,"blockId":92,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":158.88,"y":558.0,"width":6.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":915,"blockId":92,"value":"unwarranted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":171.6,"y":558.0,"width":54.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":916,"blockId":92,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":232.8,"y":558.0,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":917,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":246.72,"y":558.0,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":918,"blockId":92,"value":"present","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":559.2,"width":31.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":919,"blockId":92,"value":"circumstances","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":303.6,"y":558.0,"width":61.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":920,"blockId":92,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.0,"y":558.0,"width":12.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":921,"blockId":92,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":390.24,"y":558.0,"width":10.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":922,"blockId":92,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":407.04,"y":558.0,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":923,"blockId":92,"value":"reasons","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":441.12,"y":560.88,"width":32.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":924,"blockId":92,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":559.44,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":925,"blockId":92,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":559.44,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":926,"blockId":92,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.68,"y":559.44,"width":7.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.3599999999999,"Value":"proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":927,"blockId":92,"value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":928,"blockId":92,"value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":583.44,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":929,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":595.92,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":930,"blockId":92,"value":"regarding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":159.12,"y":595.92,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":931,"blockId":92,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":595.92,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":932,"blockId":92,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":595.92,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":933,"blockId":92,"value":"liability.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":595.92,"width":35.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":934,"blockId":92,"value":"As","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":296.88,"y":596.4,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":935,"blockId":92,"value":"with jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":314.88,"y":595.92,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":936,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":937,"blockId":92,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":418.32,"y":596.16,"width":51.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":938,"blockId":92,"value":"missed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.92,"y":595.92,"width":30.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":939,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":940,"blockId":92,"value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":611.52,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":941,"blockId":92,"value":"any compelling reason why it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.36,"width":137.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":942,"blockId":92,"value":"should now be allowed to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.36,"width":147.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":943,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":395.04,"y":621.36,"width":53.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":944,"blockId":92,"value":"long","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":453.6,"y":621.6,"width":18.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":945,"blockId":92,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":477.36,"y":621.36,"width":20.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":946,"blockId":92,"value":"those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":621.6,"width":22.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":947,"blockId":92,"value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":633.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":948,"blockId":92,"value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":949,"blockId":92,"value":"granted.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":34.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":134.39999999999998,"Value":"granted."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.56}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":950,"columnEnd":953,"text":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.223","paragraphId":"pa2.23","paragraphLabel":"2.23","rectangle":"71, 684, 454, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","averageFontSize":7.683848797250859,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":950,"blockId":95,"value":"2.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":684.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":951,"blockId":95,"value":"The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.23 The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":952,"blockId":95,"value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":953,"blockId":95,"value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}},{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":955,"columnEnd":957,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn7","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.7","paragraphId":"fn7","paragraphLabel":"7","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":955,"blockId":93,"value":"7 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":63.36,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"7 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":956,"blockId":93,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":957,"blockId":93,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":962,"columnEnd":970,"text":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><span class=\"supertext\">8</span></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 426, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><sup>8</sup></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","averageFontSize":8.88030888030888,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":962,"blockId":96,"value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":963,"blockId":96,"value":"event that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":44.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":964,"blockId":96,"value":"liability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":127.92,"width":34.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":965,"blockId":96,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":186.72,"y":127.92,"width":6.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":966,"blockId":96,"value":"established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":127.92,"width":328.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":967,"blockId":96,"value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":968,"blockId":96,"value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":969,"blockId":96,"value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":166.08,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":970,"blockId":96,"value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.56,"width":175.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":275.03999999999996,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":971,"columnEnd":988,"text":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.224","paragraphId":"pa2.24","paragraphLabel":"2.24","rectangle":"71, 204, 454, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","averageFontSize":9.137142857142857,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":971,"blockId":97,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":204.0,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":972,"blockId":97,"value":"In","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":8.64,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":973,"blockId":97,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.72,"y":204.0,"width":22.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":974,"blockId":97,"value":"circumstances,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":143.52,"y":204.0,"width":64.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":975,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":976,"blockId":97,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":234.24,"y":204.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":977,"blockId":97,"value":"considers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":204.0,"width":40.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":978,"blockId":97,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":325.68,"y":204.0,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":979,"blockId":97,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":204.0,"width":5.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":980,"blockId":97,"value":"would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.48,"y":204.0,"width":27.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":981,"blockId":97,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.08,"y":204.0,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":982,"blockId":97,"value":"appropriate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":410.64,"y":204.0,"width":49.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":983,"blockId":97,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":466.56,"y":205.2,"width":8.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":984,"blockId":97,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.68,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":985,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.24 In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":986,"blockId":97,"value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":987,"blockId":97,"value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":988,"blockId":97,"value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":376.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":476.15999999999997,"Value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":989,"columnEnd":1018,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.25","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.225","paragraphId":"pa2.25","paragraphLabel":"2.25","rectangle":"71, 267, 454, 136","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","averageFontSize":7.852441613588111,"rowsOfText":11,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":989,"blockId":98,"value":"225","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":267.12,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":990,"blockId":98,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"225 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":991,"blockId":98,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":47.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":992,"blockId":98,"value":"claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":153.12,"y":279.84,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":993,"blockId":98,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.24,"y":279.84,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":994,"blockId":98,"value":"merits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":279.84,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":995,"blockId":98,"value":"and quantum insofar","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":249.36,"y":279.84,"width":94.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":996,"blockId":98,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":349.2,"y":282.48,"width":8.64,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":997,"blockId":98,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.36,"y":279.84,"width":5.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":998,"blockId":98,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":279.84,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":999,"blockId":98,"value":"seeks","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":386.88,"y":279.84,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1000,"blockId":98,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":282.48,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1001,"blockId":98,"value":"reconsideration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":425.04,"y":279.84,"width":67.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1002,"blockId":98,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":279.84,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1003,"blockId":98,"value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":292.56,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1004,"blockId":98,"value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1005,"blockId":98,"value":"the issues of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":140.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1006,"blockId":98,"value":"in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":317.76,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1007,"blockId":98,"value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.48,"width":308.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1008,"blockId":98,"value":"legal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":330.48,"width":20.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1009,"blockId":98,"value":"authorities,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":438.96,"y":330.48,"width":48.48,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1010,"blockId":98,"value":"witness","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":492.48,"y":330.48,"width":32.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1011,"blockId":98,"value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":344.4,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1012,"blockId":98,"value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":198.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1013,"blockId":98,"value":"above, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.84,"y":355.68,"width":45.6,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1014,"blockId":98,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":355.68,"width":32.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1015,"blockId":98,"value":"submissions on compensation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":355.68,"width":133.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1016,"blockId":98,"value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":370.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1017,"blockId":98,"value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1018,"blockId":98,"value":"witnesses, if any.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":74.88,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":174.48,"Value":"witnesses, if any."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1019,"columnEnd":1033,"text":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.26","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.226","paragraphId":"pa2.26","paragraphLabel":"2.26","rectangle":"71, 419, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","averageFontSize":9.5423197492163,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1019,"blockId":99,"value":"2.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":419.28,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1020,"blockId":99,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":419.04,"width":59.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1021,"blockId":99,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":419.04,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1022,"blockId":99,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.48,"y":419.04,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1023,"blockId":99,"value":"Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":419.04,"width":29.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1024,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":251.52,"y":420.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1025,"blockId":99,"value":"revert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":264.96,"y":420.48,"width":25.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1026,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":420.48,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1027,"blockId":99,"value":"it by Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":309.12,"y":419.04,"width":68.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1028,"blockId":99,"value":"23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.8,"y":419.28,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1029,"blockId":99,"value":"September 2019 with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":419.04,"width":101.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1030,"blockId":99,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":505.2,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"2.26 The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by Monday, 23 September 2019 with their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1031,"blockId":99,"value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1032,"blockId":99,"value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1033,"blockId":99,"value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.96,"width":196.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":296.4,"Value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1034,"columnEnd":1084,"text":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.27","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.227","paragraphId":"pa2.27","paragraphLabel":"2.27","rectangle":"71, 482, 455, 109","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","averageFontSize":8.516083916083916,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1034,"blockId":100,"value":"227","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":482.4,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1035,"blockId":100,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":59.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1036,"blockId":100,"value":"further reminds","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":482.16,"width":69.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1037,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.56,"y":482.16,"width":90.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1038,"blockId":100,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":334.56,"y":482.16,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1039,"blockId":100,"value":"share","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":349.44,"y":482.16,"width":22.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1040,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":377.28,"y":482.16,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1041,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":482.16,"width":35.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1042,"blockId":100,"value":"requested by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.52,"y":482.16,"width":75.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"227 The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1043,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal in these proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":135.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1044,"blockId":100,"value":"in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":494.88,"width":284.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1045,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":51.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1046,"blockId":100,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":507.6,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1047,"blockId":100,"value":"requested","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.16,"y":507.6,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1048,"blockId":100,"value":"to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":218.16,"y":509.04,"width":37.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1049,"blockId":100,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":261.84,"y":507.6,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1050,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":290.4,"y":507.6,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1051,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.16,"y":507.6,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1052,"blockId":100,"value":"fulfilment","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.32,"y":507.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1053,"blockId":100,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.0,"y":507.6,"width":24.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1054,"blockId":100,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":426.72,"y":507.6,"width":48.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1055,"blockId":100,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.2,"y":507.6,"width":25.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1056,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":507.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1057,"blockId":100,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":520.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1058,"blockId":100,"value":"necessary","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":535.68,"width":42.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1059,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":532.8,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1060,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1061,"blockId":100,"value":"light","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":532.8,"width":19.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1062,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":532.8,"width":27.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1063,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.96,"y":532.8,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1064,"blockId":100,"value":"above","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":532.8,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1065,"blockId":100,"value":"decision","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":324.48,"y":532.8,"width":36.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1066,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":366.48,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1067,"blockId":100,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":380.88,"y":532.8,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1068,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1069,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":430.08,"y":532.8,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1070,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1071,"blockId":100,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.84,"y":532.8,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"necessary in the light of the Tribunal’s above decision to allow the Respondent to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1072,"blockId":100,"value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":545.52,"width":426.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1073,"blockId":100,"value":"the damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":56.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1074,"blockId":100,"value":"phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":161.04,"y":558.0,"width":24.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1075,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":558.0,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1076,"blockId":100,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":558.0,"width":55.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1077,"blockId":100,"value":"Accordingly,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":283.92,"y":558.0,"width":57.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1078,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.56,"y":558.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1079,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":558.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1080,"blockId":100,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.0,"y":558.0,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1081,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":558.0,"width":70.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1082,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":559.44,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1083,"blockId":100,"value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1084,"blockId":100,"value":"23 September 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.68,"width":91.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":190.8,"Value":"23 September 2019."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}},{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1085,"columnEnd":1087,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn8","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.8","paragraphId":"fn8","paragraphLabel":"8","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":6.4375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1085,"blockId":2,"value":"8 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.56,"width":63.36,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"8 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1086,"blockId":2,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.96,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1087,"blockId":2,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}},{"pageNum":13,"columnStart":1092,"columnEnd":1093,"text":"<div><br></div><div>&nbsp;<strong></strong></div><div><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </div><div><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa99","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.Date:12","paragraphId":"pa99","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"71, 115, 223, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p><br></p><p>&nbsp;<strong></strong></p><p><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </p><p><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</p>","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1092,"blockId":101,"value":"Date: 12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":115.68,"width":113.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":184.8,"Value":"Date: 12 September 2019"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1093,"blockId":101,"value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":142.56,"width":223.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004,"Value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004}}],"OrderedListOfDocumentBlocksKV":[{"Key":3,"Value":{"pageNum":1,"columnStart":4,"columnEnd":26,"text":"<div> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </div><div><br></div><div>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </div><div><br></div><div>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </div><div><br></div><div>- between - </div><div><br></div><div>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </div><div>The Claimant </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </div><div>The Respondent </div><div><br></div><div>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </div><div><br></div><div><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></div><div>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </div><div>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </div><div>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</div><div><br></div><div><strong>Registry</strong> </div><div>Permanent Court of Arbitration </div><div><br></div><div>12 September 2019</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa0","paragraphIdAuto":"paIN","paragraphId":"pa0","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"78, 115, 438, 589","alignment":1,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </p><p><br></p><p>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </p><p><br></p><p>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </p><p><br></p><p>- between - </p><p><br></p><p>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </p><p>The Claimant </p><p><br></p><p>-and- </p><p><br></p><p>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </p><p>The Respondent </p><p><br></p><p>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </p><p><br></p><p><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></p><p>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </p><p>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </p><p>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</p><p><br></p><p><strong>Registry</strong> </p><p>Permanent Court of Arbitration </p><p><br></p><p>12 September 2019</p>","averageFontSize":7.644859813084112,"rowsOfText":23,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":4,"blockId":7,"value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":84.48,"y":115.92,"width":424.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":84.48,"MarginRight":509.28000000000003,"Value":"IN THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":5,"blockId":7,"value":"ACCORDANCE WITH","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":128.16,"width":113.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.24,"MarginRight":353.52,"Value":"ACCORDANCE WITH"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":6,"blockId":7,"value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":78.0,"y":153.84,"width":438.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0,"Value":"THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":7,"blockId":7,"value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":78.24,"y":166.56,"width":437.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":78.24,"MarginRight":515.28,"Value":"AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":8,"blockId":7,"value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":110.16,"y":179.04,"width":373.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":110.16,"MarginRight":483.84000000000003,"Value":"MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":9,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.0,"y":204.48,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.0,"MarginRight":312.48,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":10,"blockId":7,"value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":106.32,"y":229.68,"width":383.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":106.32,"MarginRight":489.59999999999997,"Value":"THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":11,"blockId":7,"value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":202.32,"y":242.16,"width":191.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":202.32,"MarginRight":393.84000000000003,"Value":"INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":12,"blockId":7,"value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":280.08,"width":114.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":355.44,"Value":"PCA CASE NO. 2015-21"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":13,"blockId":7,"value":"- between -","fontName":"Times","fontSize":1.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":322.8,"width":51.12,"height":1.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":272.64,"MarginRight":323.76,"Value":"- between -"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":14,"blockId":7,"value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.6,"y":356.16,"width":114.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":243.6,"MarginRight":357.84,"Value":"JSC CB PRIVATBANK"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":15,"blockId":7,"value":"The Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":381.36,"width":64.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":265.92,"MarginRight":330.72,"Value":"The Claimant"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":16,"blockId":7,"value":"-and-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":282.96,"y":419.28,"width":30.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":282.96,"MarginRight":313.44,"Value":"-and-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":17,"blockId":7,"value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":225.6,"y":457.2,"width":150.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":225.6,"MarginRight":375.84000000000003,"Value":"THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":18,"blockId":7,"value":"The Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":260.16,"y":482.64,"width":76.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":260.16,"MarginRight":336.48,"Value":"The Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":19,"blockId":7,"value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":545.76,"width":150.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":223.2,"MarginRight":373.2,"Value":"PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":20,"blockId":7,"value":"The Arbitral Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.76,"y":596.64,"width":104.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":245.76,"MarginRight":350.64,"Value":"The Arbitral Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":21,"blockId":7,"value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":608.64,"width":231.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":182.4,"MarginRight":413.76,"Value":"Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator)"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":22,"blockId":7,"value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.12,"width":112.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":241.92,"MarginRight":354.48,"Value":"Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":23,"blockId":7,"value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":254.16,"y":634.32,"width":88.08,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":254.16,"MarginRight":342.24,"Value":"Dr. Vaclav Mikulka"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":24,"blockId":7,"value":"Registry","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":659.76,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":278.4,"MarginRight":318.0,"Value":"Registry"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":25,"blockId":7,"value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":228.96,"y":672.24,"width":138.72,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":228.96,"MarginRight":367.68,"Value":"Permanent Court of Arbitration"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":26,"blockId":7,"value":"12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":697.44,"width":83.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":256.8,"MarginRight":340.56,"Value":"12 September 2019"}],"MarginLeft":78.0,"MarginRight":516.0}}},{"Key":4,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":31,"columnEnd":31,"text":" Procedural Background","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h1","paragraphIdAuto":"hProcedural","paragraphId":"h1","paragraphLabel":"1.","rectangle":"99, 115, 112, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Procedural Background","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":31,"blockId":8,"value":"Procedural Background","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.92,"width":112.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64,"Value":"Procedural Background"}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":212.64}}},{"Key":5,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":32,"columnEnd":51,"text":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.1","paragraphId":"pa1.1","paragraphLabel":"1.1","rectangle":"72, 140, 454, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;).","averageFontSize":8.188065099457505,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":32,"blockId":9,"value":"1.1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":140.16,"width":11.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":33,"blockId":9,"value":"On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.1 On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (“PrivatBank” or the “Claimant”) and Finance Company"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":34,"blockId":9,"value":"Finilon LLC","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":152.64,"width":56.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":35,"blockId":9,"value":"(“Finilon”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":152.64,"width":46.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":36,"blockId":9,"value":"and,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":214.08,"y":152.64,"width":17.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":37,"blockId":9,"value":"together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":237.36,"y":152.64,"width":60.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":38,"blockId":9,"value":"PrivatBank,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":302.64,"y":152.64,"width":51.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":39,"blockId":9,"value":"the “Claimants”) commenced these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":359.52,"y":152.64,"width":165.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Finilon LLC (“Finilon” and, together with PrivatBank, the “Claimants”) commenced these"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":40,"blockId":9,"value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":165.36,"width":134.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":234.72,"Value":"arbitral proceedings |IEEEEEE—_—_"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":41,"blockId":9,"value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":179.52,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government ofthe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":42,"blockId":9,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":190.56,"width":35.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":43,"blockId":9,"value":"Cabinet","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":190.56,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":44,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ministers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.48,"y":190.56,"width":54.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":45,"blockId":9,"value":"of Ukraine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":241.2,"y":190.56,"width":49.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":46,"blockId":9,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":296.4,"y":193.2,"width":10.08,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":47,"blockId":9,"value":"the Encouragement and Mutual Protection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":312.72,"y":190.56,"width":198.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":48,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":190.56,"width":10.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001,"Value":"and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":49,"blockId":9,"value":"Investments dated 27 November","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":203.52,"width":145.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":50,"blockId":9,"value":"1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.08,"y":203.28,"width":275.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the “Treaty”) and the Arbitration Rules of the United"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":51,"blockId":9,"value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.4,"Value":"Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the “UNCITRAL Rules”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":527.2800000000001}}},{"Key":6,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":52,"columnEnd":52,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.2","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.2","paragraphLabel":"1.2","rectangle":"72, 241, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":52,"blockId":10,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":241.44,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"12"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}}},{"Key":7,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":53,"columnEnd":54,"text":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa13","paragraphId":"pa1.3","paragraphLabel":"1.3","rectangle":"72, 342, 225, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":53,"blockId":11,"value":"13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":342.72,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":54,"blockId":11,"value":"The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":198.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32,"Value":"13 The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":298.32}}},{"Key":8,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":55,"columnEnd":79,"text":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.4","paragraphId":"pa1.4","paragraphLabel":"1.4","rectangle":"72, 367, 453, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. ","averageFontSize":8.510385756676557,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":55,"blockId":12,"value":"1.4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":367.92,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":56,"blockId":12,"value":"On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.92,"width":426.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"1.4 On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":57,"blockId":12,"value":"the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.16,"width":77.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":58,"blockId":12,"value":"Letters from the PCA, and that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":380.16,"width":142.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":59,"blockId":12,"value":"it considered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.28,"y":380.16,"width":57.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":60,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.2,"y":380.16,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":61,"blockId":12,"value":"content of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":381.6,"width":72.0,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":62,"blockId":12,"value":"letters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.76,"y":380.16,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":63,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":381.6,"width":7.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":64,"blockId":12,"value":"constitute","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":392.88,"width":42.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":65,"blockId":12,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":148.56,"y":395.52,"width":9.84,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":66,"blockId":12,"value":"objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":165.12,"y":392.88,"width":40.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":67,"blockId":12,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":211.92,"y":392.88,"width":10.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":68,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":392.88,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":69,"blockId":12,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":248.64,"y":392.88,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":70,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":394.32,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":71,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":72,"blockId":12,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":392.88,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":73,"blockId":12,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":392.88,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":74,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":412.08,"y":392.88,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":75,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":392.88,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":76,"blockId":12,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.68,"y":392.88,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":77,"blockId":12,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":497.52,"y":394.32,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":78,"blockId":12,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":392.88,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":79,"blockId":12,"value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.6,"width":358.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.64,"Value":"admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":526.32}}},{"Key":9,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":80,"columnEnd":113,"text":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.5","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.125","paragraphId":"pa1.5","paragraphLabel":"1.5","rectangle":"72, 431, 452, 85","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.546712802768166,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":80,"blockId":13,"value":"125","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":431.04,"width":11.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":81,"blockId":13,"value":"On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"125 On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":82,"blockId":13,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":443.52,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":83,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":126.0,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":84,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":443.52,"width":53.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":85,"blockId":13,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.24,"y":443.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":86,"blockId":13,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":443.52,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":87,"blockId":13,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":265.68,"y":443.52,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":88,"blockId":13,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":298.08,"y":443.52,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":89,"blockId":13,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":443.52,"width":45.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":90,"blockId":13,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.92,"y":443.76,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":91,"blockId":13,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":443.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":92,"blockId":13,"value":"Rules","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.16,"y":443.52,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":93,"blockId":13,"value":"of Procedure,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.92,"y":443.52,"width":60.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":94,"blockId":13,"value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.24,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":95,"blockId":13,"value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":468.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":96,"blockId":13,"value":"were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":484.32,"width":20.88,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":97,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":125.76,"y":482.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":98,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":139.2,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":99,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":100,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":168.24,"y":481.92,"width":197.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":101,"blockId":13,"value":"and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.28,"y":481.44,"width":33.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":102,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":481.44,"width":72.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":103,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":488.16,"y":482.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":104,"blockId":13,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.6,"y":481.44,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":105,"blockId":13,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":521.04,"y":484.32,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":106,"blockId":13,"value":"Statement of Defence and any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":494.64,"width":139.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":107,"blockId":13,"value":"Objection","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":494.16,"width":42.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":108,"blockId":13,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":293.28,"y":495.6,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":109,"blockId":13,"value":"Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":306.48,"y":494.16,"width":51.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":110,"blockId":13,"value":"and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.12,"y":494.16,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":111,"blockId":13,"value":"Admissibility,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":395.76,"y":494.16,"width":61.92,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":112,"blockId":13,"value":"including any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":494.16,"width":61.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":113,"blockId":13,"value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.64,"width":220.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":319.68,"Value":"Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":10,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":114,"columnEnd":114,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.6","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.6","paragraphLabel":"1.6","rectangle":"72, 532, 12, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":114,"blockId":14,"value":"1.6","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.32,"width":12.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48,"Value":"1.6"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.48}}},{"Key":11,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":115,"columnEnd":125,"text":" The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure. The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the Tribunal. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.7","paragraphId":"pa1.7","paragraphLabel":"1.7","rectangle":"72, 557, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.364912280701754,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":115,"blockId":15,"value":"1.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":557.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":116,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.28,"width":91.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":117,"blockId":15,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":196.32,"y":558.72,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":118,"blockId":15,"value":"file","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":215.04,"y":557.28,"width":13.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":119,"blockId":15,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":234.0,"y":560.16,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":120,"blockId":15,"value":"Statement of Defence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":243.84,"y":557.76,"width":97.92,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":121,"blockId":15,"value":"or any Objection to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":346.8,"y":558.72,"width":89.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":122,"blockId":15,"value":"Jurisdiction and/or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.36,"y":557.28,"width":84.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.7 The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":123,"blockId":15,"value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":570.0,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":124,"blockId":15,"value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":582.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":125,"blockId":15,"value":"Tribunal.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.2,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":139.44,"Value":"Tribunal."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":12,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":126,"columnEnd":126,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.8","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.8","paragraphLabel":"1.8","rectangle":"72, 620, 11, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":126,"blockId":1,"value":"1.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":620.88,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001,"Value":"1.8"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":84.24000000000001}}},{"Key":13,"Value":{"pageNum":2,"columnStart":127,"columnEnd":140,"text":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.9","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19","paragraphId":"pa1.9","paragraphLabel":"1.9","rectangle":"72, 671, 452, 96","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","averageFontSize":7.4953271028037385,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":127,"blockId":2,"value":"19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":671.52,"width":11.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":128,"blockId":2,"value":"On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":671.76,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"19 On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent’s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":129,"blockId":2,"value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":393.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":130,"blockId":2,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":684.0,"width":27.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and having sought the Respondent’s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":131,"blockId":2,"value":"Procedural Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":696.72,"width":96.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":132,"blockId":2,"value":"2,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":201.6,"y":696.72,"width":7.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":133,"blockId":2,"value":"in which it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.32,"y":696.72,"width":49.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":134,"blockId":2,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":268.08,"y":696.72,"width":9.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":135,"blockId":2,"value":"ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":282.72,"y":696.48,"width":242.4,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":136,"blockId":2,"value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.44,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent’s failure to communicate"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":137,"blockId":2,"value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":724.56,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues ofjurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":138,"blockId":2,"value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":734.64,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":139,"blockId":2,"value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":747.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties—one question to the Claimants and 24 questions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":140,"blockId":2,"value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":761.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to both Parties—regarding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":14,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":145,"columnEnd":149,"text":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.063953488372093,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":145,"blockId":3,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":146,"blockId":3,"value":"Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":117.36,"y":115.44,"width":176.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":147,"blockId":3,"value":"Thereafter,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":298.8,"y":115.44,"width":47.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":148,"blockId":3,"value":"each Party had until 29 April 2016 to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":351.84,"y":115.44,"width":173.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":149,"blockId":3,"value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":127.92,"width":371.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":471.12,"Value":"indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":16,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":150,"columnEnd":150,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.10","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.10","paragraphLabel":"1.10","rectangle":"72, 153, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":150,"blockId":1,"value":"1.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":153.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.10"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}}},{"Key":15,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":151,"columnEnd":154,"text":" May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa19.On24","paragraphId":"pa1.11","paragraphLabel":"1.11","rectangle":"99, 204, 426, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":6.793296089385475,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":151,"blockId":4,"value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":426.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"On 24 May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":152,"blockId":4,"value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":153,"blockId":4,"value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":154,"blockId":4,"value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":243.36,"width":337.92,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":437.52,"Value":"to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}}},{"Key":17,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":155,"columnEnd":161,"text":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12","paragraphId":"pa1.12","paragraphLabel":"1.12","rectangle":"72, 267, 452, 58","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":7.7176470588235295,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":155,"blockId":2,"value":"1.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":267.36,"width":17.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":156,"blockId":2,"value":"On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.36,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.12 On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":157,"blockId":2,"value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":158,"blockId":2,"value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues ofjurisdiction, and invited the Parties’ comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":159,"blockId":2,"value":"thereon.I","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":51.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":160,"blockId":2,"value":"The Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":305.04,"width":109.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"thereon.I The Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":161,"blockId":2,"value":"submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":317.76,"width":98.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":198.0,"Value":"submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":18,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":162,"columnEnd":166,"text":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.113","paragraphId":"pa1.13","paragraphLabel":"1.13","rectangle":"72, 343, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.445652173913043,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":162,"blockId":3,"value":"1.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":343.2,"width":16.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":163,"blockId":3,"value":"On 10 and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":343.2,"width":47.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":164,"blockId":3,"value":"14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":343.2,"width":373.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.13 On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":165,"blockId":3,"value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":213.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":312.96000000000004,"Value":"Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":166,"blockId":3,"value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":368.16,"width":314.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":413.28000000000003,"Value":"IeRespondent did not submit any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":19,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":167,"columnEnd":205,"text":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.12.114","paragraphId":"pa1.14","paragraphLabel":"1.14","rectangle":"72, 393, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. ","averageFontSize":8.49737302977233,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":167,"blockId":6,"value":"1.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":393.84,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":168,"blockId":6,"value":"The hearing on jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":145.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":169,"blockId":6,"value":"admissibility was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":249.84,"y":393.6,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":170,"blockId":6,"value":"held in Geneva from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.88,"y":393.6,"width":95.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":171,"blockId":6,"value":"12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":434.88,"y":393.84,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":172,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":395.04,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":173,"blockId":6,"value":"14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":463.68,"y":393.84,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":174,"blockId":6,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":477.84,"y":393.6,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":175,"blockId":6,"value":"2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":393.84,"width":23.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"1.14 The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":176,"blockId":6,"value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":177,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":178,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":179,"blockId":6,"value":"was delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":62.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":180,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":166.56,"y":445.68,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":181,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":444.24,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":182,"blockId":6,"value":"Parties, and they were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":197.76,"y":444.24,"width":101.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":183,"blockId":6,"value":"granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":304.32,"y":444.24,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":184,"blockId":6,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":342.0,"y":444.24,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":185,"blockId":6,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":445.68,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":186,"blockId":6,"value":"address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.56,"y":444.24,"width":32.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":187,"blockId":6,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":420.0,"y":444.24,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":188,"blockId":6,"value":"raised by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":465.84,"y":444.24,"width":41.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":189,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":444.24,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":190,"blockId":6,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":191,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.56,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":192,"blockId":6,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":155.76,"y":456.72,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":193,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.0,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":194,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":459.6,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":195,"blockId":6,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.48,"y":456.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":196,"blockId":6,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":252.48,"y":459.6,"width":8.16,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":197,"blockId":6,"value":"other","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.16,"y":456.72,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":198,"blockId":6,"value":"matters","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":293.52,"y":457.92,"width":31.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":199,"blockId":6,"value":"arising","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":330.96,"y":456.72,"width":29.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":200,"blockId":6,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":365.52,"y":458.16,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":201,"blockId":6,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":456.72,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":202,"blockId":6,"value":"hearing,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":416.64,"y":456.72,"width":34.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":203,"blockId":6,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":457.2,"y":456.72,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":204,"blockId":6,"value":"post-hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":470.4,"y":456.72,"width":54.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":205,"blockId":6,"value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":193.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":293.28,"Value":"submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":20,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":206,"columnEnd":208,"text":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.15","paragraphId":"pa1.15","paragraphLabel":"1.15","rectangle":"72, 494, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.131147540983607,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":206,"blockId":7,"value":"1.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":494.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":207,"blockId":7,"value":"NThe Respondent did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":494.4,"width":145.68,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.15 NThe Respondent did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":208,"blockId":7,"value":"file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":507.36,"width":149.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":249.12,"Value":"file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":21,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":209,"columnEnd":212,"text":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.116","paragraphId":"pa1.16","paragraphLabel":"1.16","rectangle":"72, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":8.283154121863799,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":209,"blockId":8,"value":"1.16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":532.8,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":210,"blockId":8,"value":"On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.16 On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":211,"blockId":8,"value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.28,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"certain issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":212,"blockId":8,"value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":558.0,"width":374.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":472.56000000000006,"Value":"jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the “Interim Award”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":526.56}}},{"Key":22,"Value":{"pageNum":3,"columnStart":213,"columnEnd":246,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </div><div><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </div><div><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.17","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.117","paragraphId":"pa1.17","paragraphLabel":"1.17","rectangle":"72, 583, 425, 147","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </p><p><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </p><p><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.421686746987952,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":213,"blockId":9,"value":"1.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":583.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":214,"blockId":9,"value":"The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":252.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":352.08,"Value":"1.17 The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":215,"blockId":9,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":608.88,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":216,"blockId":9,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":631.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":217,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":631.68,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":218,"blockId":9,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":631.68,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":219,"blockId":9,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":631.68,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":220,"blockId":9,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":263.76,"y":631.68,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":221,"blockId":9,"value":"assumed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":281.76,"y":631.68,"width":33.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":222,"blockId":9,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":320.64,"y":631.68,"width":43.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":223,"blockId":9,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":369.36,"y":631.68,"width":22.56,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":224,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":396.72,"y":631.68,"width":11.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":225,"blockId":9,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":631.92,"width":25.68,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":226,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":443.76,"y":631.68,"width":7.44,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":227,"blockId":9,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":632.88,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":228,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":631.68,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":229,"blockId":9,"value":"Ukrainian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":643.2,"width":39.6,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":230,"blockId":9,"value":"investors","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":210.72,"y":643.2,"width":35.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":231,"blockId":9,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":253.44,"y":643.2,"width":13.92,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":232,"blockId":9,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":274.56,"y":643.2,"width":18.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":233,"blockId":9,"value":"investments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":643.2,"width":47.04,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":234,"blockId":9,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":643.2,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":235,"blockId":9,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":368.16,"y":643.2,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":236,"blockId":9,"value":"Crimean","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":387.12,"y":643.2,"width":34.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":237,"blockId":9,"value":"Peninsula","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":643.2,"width":38.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":238,"blockId":9,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":645.6,"width":7.92,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":239,"blockId":9,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.64,"y":643.2,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":497.76,"Value":"Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":240,"blockId":9,"value":"21 March 2014;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":654.72,"width":63.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":227.28,"Value":"21 March 2014;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":241,"blockId":9,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":677.76,"width":6.72,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":242,"blockId":9,"value":"there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":677.76,"width":332.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":496.55999999999995,"Value":"2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":243,"blockId":9,"value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":689.28,"width":222.72,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":386.88,"Value":"allege to constitute “investments” under the Treaty; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":244,"blockId":9,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":712.08,"width":6.48,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":245,"blockId":9,"value":"the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":712.08,"width":332.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":496.31999999999994,"Value":"3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":246,"blockId":9,"value":"of the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":723.6,"width":53.28,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":163.92,"MarginRight":217.2,"Value":"of the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":497.76}}},{"Key":23,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":251,"columnEnd":253,"text":"<div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"127, 115, 368, 30","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":251,"blockId":10,"value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":115.2,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":252,"blockId":10,"value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":126.72,"width":368.64,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56,"Value":"merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":253,"blockId":10,"value":"of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":138.24,"width":68.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":196.8,"Value":"of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.56}}},{"Key":24,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":254,"columnEnd":261,"text":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.18","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.118","paragraphId":"pa1.18","paragraphLabel":"1.18","rectangle":"72, 162, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. ","averageFontSize":7.768421052631579,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":254,"blockId":12,"value":"1.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":162.48,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":255,"blockId":12,"value":"On 27 March 2017, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":162.48,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":256,"blockId":12,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":213.84,"y":162.48,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":257,"blockId":12,"value":"re-issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":162.48,"width":39.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":258,"blockId":12,"value":"the Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":300.48,"y":162.48,"width":86.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":259,"blockId":12,"value":"correcting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":392.88,"y":162.48,"width":44.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":260,"blockId":12,"value":"four typographical","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.32,"y":162.48,"width":82.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.18 On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":261,"blockId":12,"value":"errors.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":177.84,"width":27.6,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":127.19999999999999,"Value":"errors."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":25,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":262,"columnEnd":270,"text":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.119","paragraphId":"pa1.19","paragraphLabel":"1.19","rectangle":"72, 200, 452, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. ","averageFontSize":9.124809741248097,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":262,"blockId":13,"value":"1.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":200.4,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":263,"blockId":13,"value":"On 11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":200.64,"width":26.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":264,"blockId":13,"value":"July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.56,"y":200.4,"width":394.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.19 On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":265,"blockId":13,"value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":213.12,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (1) decided to bifurcate the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":266,"blockId":13,"value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":225.84,"width":426.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":267,"blockId":13,"value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":238.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":268,"blockId":13,"value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":251.04,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":269,"blockId":13,"value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":263.76,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":270,"blockId":13,"value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":276.48,"width":327.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":426.96000000000004,"Value":"in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":26,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":271,"columnEnd":286,"text":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.120","paragraphId":"pa1.20","paragraphLabel":"1.20","rectangle":"72, 301, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. ","averageFontSize":8.218289085545722,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":271,"blockId":14,"value":"1.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":301.92,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":272,"blockId":14,"value":"On the same day,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":301.92,"width":75.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":273,"blockId":14,"value":"11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":179.76,"y":301.92,"width":345.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999,"Value":"1.20 On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":274,"blockId":14,"value":"No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":314.64,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":275,"blockId":14,"value":"3,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":120.48,"y":314.64,"width":7.2,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":276,"blockId":14,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":314.4,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":277,"blockId":14,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":314.4,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":278,"blockId":14,"value":"addressed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.2,"y":314.4,"width":42.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":279,"blockId":14,"value":"15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":314.64,"width":8.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":280,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":256.32,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":281,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Parties—4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":302.16,"y":315.84,"width":76.8,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":282,"blockId":14,"value":"questions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":384.0,"y":314.4,"width":40.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":283,"blockId":14,"value":"to the Claimants and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":429.84,"y":315.84,"width":95.28,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties—4 questions to the Claimants and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":284,"blockId":14,"value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":100.8,"y":327.12,"width":424.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.8,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"11 questions to both Parties—regarding issues of liability and remaining issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":285,"blockId":14,"value":"admissibility.|","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":339.6,"width":66.96,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":166.56,"Value":"admissibility.|"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":286,"blockId":14,"value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":352.32,"width":232.32,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":331.44,"Value":"Il The Respondent did not submit any responses."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.5999999999999}}},{"Key":27,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":287,"columnEnd":293,"text":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.121","paragraphId":"pa1.21","paragraphLabel":"1.21","rectangle":"72, 377, 452, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. ","averageFontSize":8.021645021645021,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":287,"blockId":15,"value":"1.21","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":377.76,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":288,"blockId":15,"value":"On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":377.76,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.21 On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":289,"blockId":15,"value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":390.0,"width":425.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":290,"blockId":15,"value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":402.72,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":291,"blockId":15,"value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":415.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":292,"blockId":15,"value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":429.36,"width":425.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":293,"blockId":15,"value":"Respondent did not provide any comments.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":440.64,"width":190.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":290.15999999999997,"Value":"Respondent did not provide any comments."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":28,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":294,"columnEnd":313,"text":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.122","paragraphId":"pa1.22","paragraphLabel":"1.22","rectangle":"72, 466, 452, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":8.05043227665706,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":294,"blockId":16,"value":"1.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":466.32,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":295,"blockId":16,"value":"A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":466.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.22 A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":296,"blockId":16,"value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":478.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":297,"blockId":16,"value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":491.28,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":298,"blockId":16,"value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":504.0,"width":331.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":299,"blockId":16,"value":"all presented by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":436.32,"y":504.0,"width":88.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":300,"blockId":16,"value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":516.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":301,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":529.2,"width":32.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":302,"blockId":16,"value":"transcript was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":529.2,"width":62.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":303,"blockId":16,"value":"delivered","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":529.2,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":304,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":250.32,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":305,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":263.28,"y":529.2,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":306,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":281.28,"y":529.2,"width":52.8,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":307,"blockId":16,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":338.88,"y":529.2,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":308,"blockId":16,"value":"Parties were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":356.88,"y":529.2,"width":55.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":309,"blockId":16,"value":"further granted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.6,"y":529.2,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":310,"blockId":16,"value":"leave","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":529.2,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":311,"blockId":16,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":530.64,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":312,"blockId":16,"value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":541.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":313,"blockId":16,"value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":554.64,"width":163.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":263.03999999999996,"Value":"hearing, in post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":29,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":314,"columnEnd":316,"text":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.123","paragraphId":"pa1.23","paragraphLabel":"1.23","rectangle":"72, 579, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. ","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":314,"blockId":17,"value":"1.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":580.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":315,"blockId":17,"value":"NThe Russian Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":367.44,"y":579.6,"width":157.92,"height":10.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.23 NThe Russian Federation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":316,"blockId":17,"value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":592.56,"width":183.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":282.96000000000004,"Value":"did not file any post-hearing submissions."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":30,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":317,"columnEnd":319,"text":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.124","paragraphId":"pa1.24","paragraphLabel":"1.24","rectangle":"72, 618, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.61344537815126,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":317,"blockId":18,"value":"1.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":618.0,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":318,"blockId":18,"value":"By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.24 By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":319,"blockId":18,"value":"from the Parties,|G","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":630.48,"width":358.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":458.15999999999997,"Value":"from the Parties,|G"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}}},{"Key":31,"Value":{"pageNum":4,"columnStart":320,"columnEnd":335,"text":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.25","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.25","paragraphLabel":"1.25","rectangle":"72, 655, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). ","averageFontSize":7.85064935064935,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":320,"blockId":19,"value":"1.25","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":655.92,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":321,"blockId":19,"value":"On 4","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":322,"blockId":19,"value":"February","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":130.08,"y":655.92,"width":39.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":323,"blockId":19,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":175.68,"y":655.92,"width":24.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":324,"blockId":19,"value":"having","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":206.4,"y":655.92,"width":29.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":325,"blockId":19,"value":"deliberated,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":242.16,"y":655.68,"width":51.12,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":326,"blockId":19,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":299.52,"y":655.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":327,"blockId":19,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.96,"y":655.68,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":328,"blockId":19,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":362.88,"y":655.68,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":329,"blockId":19,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.24,"y":658.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":330,"blockId":19,"value":"unanimous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":655.92,"width":47.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":331,"blockId":19,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":461.04,"y":655.68,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":332,"blockId":19,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":495.6,"y":655.92,"width":29.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":333,"blockId":19,"value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":668.64,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"addressing the Respondent’s liability in respect of the Claimants’ claims under the Treaty, as well"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":334,"blockId":19,"value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.0,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"as all outstanding issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (the “Partial Award” and, together with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":335,"blockId":19,"value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":693.84,"width":155.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":254.88,"Value":"the Interim Award, the “Awards”)."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":32,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":340,"columnEnd":363,"text":"<div> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </div><div><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </div><div><br></div><div>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</div><div>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.26","paragraphId":"pa1.26","paragraphLabel":"1.26","rectangle":"72, 115, 425, 148","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></p><blockquote style=\"margin-right: 0px;\" dir=\"ltr\"><p>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </p><p><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </p><p><br></p><p>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</p><p>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </p></blockquote>","averageFontSize":7.01875,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":340,"blockId":22,"value":"1.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":115.44,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":341,"blockId":22,"value":"The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":248.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":348.48,"Value":"1.26 The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":342,"blockId":22,"value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":140.64,"width":198.48,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":326.4,"Value":"For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that:"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":343,"blockId":22,"value":"1.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":147.12,"y":163.68,"width":5.52,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":344,"blockId":22,"value":"the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":163.44,"width":287.52,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":147.12,"MarginRight":451.43999999999994,"Value":"1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty;"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":345,"blockId":22,"value":"2.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":186.72,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":346,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":186.48,"width":160.32,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":145.92,"MarginRight":324.24,"Value":"2. PrivatBank’s claims are admissible; and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":347,"blockId":22,"value":"3.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":146.16,"y":209.76,"width":6.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":348,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":163.92,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":349,"blockId":22,"value":"Russian","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":209.52,"width":31.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":350,"blockId":22,"value":"Federation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":220.08,"y":209.52,"width":42.48,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":351,"blockId":22,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":268.8,"y":209.52,"width":12.96,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":352,"blockId":22,"value":"breached","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":288.48,"y":209.52,"width":36.0,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":353,"blockId":22,"value":"Article","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":330.72,"y":209.52,"width":27.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":354,"blockId":22,"value":"5","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":364.8,"y":209.76,"width":3.84,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":355,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":375.84,"y":209.52,"width":8.88,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":356,"blockId":22,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":390.0,"y":209.52,"width":11.76,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":357,"blockId":22,"value":"Treaty","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":408.24,"y":209.76,"width":25.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":358,"blockId":22,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":440.64,"y":209.52,"width":7.2,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":359,"blockId":22,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.32,"y":210.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":360,"blockId":22,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":209.52,"width":9.12,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":146.16,"MarginRight":498.0,"Value":"3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":361,"blockId":22,"value":"PrivatBank’s investment.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":221.04,"width":100.08,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":164.16,"MarginRight":264.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s investment."},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":362,"blockId":22,"value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":245.04,"width":368.4,"height":6.96,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":496.32,"Value":"The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":363,"blockId":22,"value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":127.92,"y":258.0,"width":267.12,"height":5.52,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.92,"MarginRight":395.04,"Value":"costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":498.0}}},{"Key":33,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":364,"columnEnd":364,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.27","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.27","paragraphLabel":"1.27","rectangle":"72, 280, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":364,"blockId":23,"value":"11279","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":280.08,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999,"Value":"11279"}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":89.75999999999999}}},{"Key":34,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":365,"columnEnd":368,"text":" On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.28","paragraphId":"pa1.28","paragraphLabel":"1.28","rectangle":"72, 355, 452, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.117647058823529,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":365,"blockId":24,"value":"1.28","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":355.2,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":366,"blockId":24,"value":"On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.2,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.28 On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":367,"blockId":24,"value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":367.68,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":368,"blockId":24,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":54.96,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":154.56,"Value":"proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":35,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":369,"columnEnd":391,"text":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.29","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.129","paragraphId":"pa1.29","paragraphLabel":"1.29","rectangle":"72, 405, 452, 59","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. ","averageFontSize":8.882488479262673,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":369,"blockId":25,"value":"1.29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":405.36,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":370,"blockId":25,"value":"By","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":405.36,"width":12.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":371,"blockId":25,"value":"letter","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":119.04,"y":405.12,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":372,"blockId":25,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.08,"y":405.12,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":373,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":163.44,"y":405.12,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":374,"blockId":25,"value":"same","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":183.84,"y":407.76,"width":21.6,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":375,"blockId":25,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":212.4,"y":405.12,"width":20.4,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":376,"blockId":25,"value":"22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.0,"y":405.36,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":377,"blockId":25,"value":"March","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":257.52,"y":405.12,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":378,"blockId":25,"value":"2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":405.36,"width":24.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":379,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":323.76,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":380,"blockId":25,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":405.12,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":381,"blockId":25,"value":"recalled","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":388.08,"y":405.12,"width":34.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":382,"blockId":25,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":429.12,"y":405.12,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":383,"blockId":25,"value":"finding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":405.12,"width":31.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":384,"blockId":25,"value":"made","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.2,"y":405.12,"width":23.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":385,"blockId":25,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.44,"y":406.56,"width":7.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.8800000000001,"Value":"1.29 By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":386,"blockId":25,"value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":417.6,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.”"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":387,"blockId":25,"value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":430.32,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":388,"blockId":25,"value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":443.04,"width":390.24,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":389,"blockId":25,"value":"1","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":494.88,"y":443.28,"width":2.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":390,"blockId":25,"value":"April","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":443.04,"width":22.56,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":391,"blockId":25,"value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.76,"width":320.64,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":420.24,"Value":"2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":36,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":392,"columnEnd":419,"text":" On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going forward. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.30","paragraphId":"pa1.30","paragraphLabel":"1.30","rectangle":"72, 480, 452, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.335540838852097,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":392,"blockId":27,"value":"1.30","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":480.48,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":393,"blockId":27,"value":"On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":480.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.30 On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":394,"blockId":27,"value":"comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.4,"width":44.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":395,"blockId":27,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":150.72,"y":492.96,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":396,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.36,"y":492.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":397,"blockId":27,"value":"Respondent,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":196.56,"y":492.96,"width":54.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":398,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":256.8,"y":492.96,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":399,"blockId":27,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":276.0,"y":492.96,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":400,"blockId":27,"value":"issued","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":492.96,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":401,"blockId":27,"value":"Procedural","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.8,"y":492.96,"width":46.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":402,"blockId":27,"value":"Order No.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.08,"y":492.96,"width":46.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":403,"blockId":27,"value":"5,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":459.12,"y":493.44,"width":7.2,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":404,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":473.04,"y":492.96,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":405,"blockId":27,"value":"which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.96,"y":492.96,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":406,"blockId":27,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":519.84,"y":492.96,"width":5.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":407,"blockId":27,"value":"determined that,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.44,"width":72.72,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":408,"blockId":27,"value":"absent any reasoned","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":177.6,"y":505.44,"width":91.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":409,"blockId":27,"value":"application by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":274.32,"y":505.44,"width":64.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":410,"blockId":27,"value":"Finilon","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.2,"y":505.44,"width":31.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":411,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.44,"y":506.88,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":412,"blockId":27,"value":"continue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":505.44,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":413,"blockId":27,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":506.88,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":414,"blockId":27,"value":"participate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":447.84,"y":505.44,"width":46.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":415,"blockId":27,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.2,"y":505.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":416,"blockId":27,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":505.44,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":417,"blockId":27,"value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":518.16,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":418,"blockId":27,"value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":530.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":419,"blockId":27,"value":"forward.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":543.36,"width":36.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":136.32,"Value":"forward."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":37,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":420,"columnEnd":449,"text":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.31","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.131","paragraphId":"pa1.31","paragraphLabel":"1.31","rectangle":"72, 568, 452, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","averageFontSize":8.667431192660551,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":420,"blockId":28,"value":"1.31","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":568.32,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":421,"blockId":28,"value":"By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":568.56,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.31 By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":422,"blockId":28,"value":"useful","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":580.56,"width":26.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":423,"blockId":28,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":131.52,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":424,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":580.56,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":425,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.28,"y":580.56,"width":81.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":426,"blockId":28,"value":"further submissions on damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":580.56,"width":146.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":427,"blockId":28,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":406.8,"y":580.8,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":428,"blockId":28,"value":"take","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":428.16,"y":580.56,"width":17.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":429,"blockId":28,"value":"into","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":451.44,"y":580.56,"width":16.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":430,"blockId":28,"value":"account","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":473.28,"y":582.0,"width":33.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":431,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":580.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":432,"blockId":28,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":593.28,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":433,"blockId":28,"value":"findings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":151.92,"y":593.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":434,"blockId":28,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":193.92,"y":593.28,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":435,"blockId":28,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":208.8,"y":593.28,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":436,"blockId":28,"value":"Partial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":593.28,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":437,"blockId":28,"value":"Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":259.68,"y":593.28,"width":29.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":438,"blockId":28,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":593.52,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":439,"blockId":28,"value":"invited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":318.0,"y":593.28,"width":30.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":440,"blockId":28,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":593.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":441,"blockId":28,"value":"Claimant","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.16,"y":593.28,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":442,"blockId":28,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":420.48,"y":594.72,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":443,"blockId":28,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":435.12,"y":593.52,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":444,"blockId":28,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":464.88,"y":593.52,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":445,"blockId":28,"value":"revised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":493.44,"y":593.28,"width":31.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":446,"blockId":28,"value":"submissions by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":606.24,"width":68.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":447,"blockId":28,"value":"19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":606.0,"width":329.04,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":448,"blockId":28,"value":"July","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":507.12,"y":606.0,"width":18.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":449,"blockId":28,"value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":618.96,"width":409.68,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":509.28,"Value":"2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":38,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":450,"columnEnd":450,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.32","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.32","paragraphLabel":"1.32","rectangle":"72, 643, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":450,"blockId":29,"value":"1.32","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":643.44,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.32"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}}},{"Key":39,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":451,"columnEnd":453,"text":" By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s extension request by 21 May 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.33","paragraphId":"pa1.33","paragraphLabel":"1.33","rectangle":"72, 680, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":9.430769230769231,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":451,"blockId":30,"value":"1.33","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":680.88,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":452,"blockId":30,"value":"By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":681.12,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.33 By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":453,"blockId":30,"value":"extension request by 21 May 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":693.36,"width":153.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":253.44,"Value":"extension request by 21 May 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":40,"Value":{"pageNum":5,"columnStart":454,"columnEnd":454,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.34","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.34","paragraphLabel":"1.34","rectangle":"72, 718, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":454,"blockId":31,"value":"1.34","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":718.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.34"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}}},{"Key":41,"Value":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":459,"columnEnd":459,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.35","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.35","paragraphLabel":"1.35","rectangle":"72, 204, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":459,"blockId":32,"value":"1.35","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":204.24,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.35"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}}},{"Key":42,"Value":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":460,"columnEnd":460,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36","paragraphLabel":"1.36","rectangle":"72, 495, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":460,"blockId":33,"value":"1.36","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":495.12,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.36"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}}},{"Key":43,"Value":{"pageNum":6,"columnStart":461,"columnEnd":461,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.i","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"128, 735, 10, 8","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":461,"blockId":36,"value":"~ —--~","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":735.12,"width":10.8,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96,"Value":"~ —--~"}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":138.96}}},{"Key":44,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":466,"columnEnd":468,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.36.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"127, 115, 372, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.0,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":466,"blockId":37,"value":"<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":128.16,"y":115.2,"width":14.16,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":128.16,"MarginRight":142.32,"Value":"<"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":467,"blockId":37,"value":"e","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.44,"y":126.72,"width":372.0,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"e"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":468,"blockId":37,"value":".","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":127.68,"y":138.24,"width":371.76,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":127.68,"MarginRight":499.44,"Value":"."}],"MarginLeft":127.44,"MarginRight":499.44}}},{"Key":45,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":470,"columnEnd":474,"text":" By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37","paragraphId":"pa1.37","paragraphLabel":"1.37","rectangle":"72, 174, 452, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.886426592797784,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":470,"blockId":41,"value":"1.37","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":174.0,"width":17.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":471,"blockId":41,"value":"By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":174.24,"width":425.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.37 By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":472,"blockId":41,"value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":186.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":473,"blockId":41,"value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":199.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":474,"blockId":41,"value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":211.92,"width":277.92,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":377.52,"Value":"deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":46,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":475,"columnEnd":478,"text":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.38","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.37.138","paragraphId":"pa1.38","paragraphLabel":"1.38","rectangle":"72, 237, 452, 19","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. ","averageFontSize":7.559523809523809,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":475,"blockId":42,"value":"1.38","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.72,"y":237.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":476,"blockId":42,"value":"By letter dated 4 July 2019,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":237.6,"width":126.0,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":477,"blockId":42,"value":"at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":230.4,"y":238.8,"width":294.48,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.38 By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":478,"blockId":42,"value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":249.84,"width":300.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":399.84000000000003,"Value":"schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable."}],"MarginLeft":72.72,"MarginRight":524.88}}},{"Key":47,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":479,"columnEnd":479,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.39","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.39","paragraphLabel":"1.39","rectangle":"72, 275, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":479,"blockId":43,"value":"1.39","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":275.52,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"1.39"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.76}}},{"Key":48,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":480,"columnEnd":480,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.40","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.40","paragraphLabel":"1.40","rectangle":"72, 351, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":480,"blockId":44,"value":"1.40","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":351.36,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.40"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}}},{"Key":49,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":481,"columnEnd":481,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.41","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.41","paragraphLabel":"1.41","rectangle":"72, 414, 16, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":481,"blockId":45,"value":"1.41","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":414.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56,"Value":"1.41"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":88.56}}},{"Key":50,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":482,"columnEnd":499,"text":"<div>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.42","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.42o","paragraphId":"pa1.42","paragraphLabel":"1.42","rectangle":"72, 439, 452, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</p>","averageFontSize":6.321782178217822,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":482,"blockId":46,"value":"1.42","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":439.68,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":483,"blockId":46,"value":"o<","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":439.92,"width":12.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":484,"blockId":46,"value":"a.!—fi[~ (¢}=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":118.32,"y":442.32,"width":19.44,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":485,"blockId":46,"value":"Q.©-[¢}o, oN","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":140.64,"y":439.44,"width":36.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":486,"blockId":46,"value":"A=t[=]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":13.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":439.92,"width":9.36,"height":13.2,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":487,"blockId":46,"value":"=< o) P— \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":193.68,"y":442.32,"width":29.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":488,"blockId":46,"value":"-Bo H o=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":440.88,"width":29.04,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":489,"blockId":46,"value":"c=© B o©-Q&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":264.72,"y":442.08,"width":37.68,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":490,"blockId":46,"value":"o,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.36,"y":439.44,"width":5.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":491,"blockId":46,"value":"=©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO:","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.64,"y":439.44,"width":143.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":492,"blockId":46,"value":"-=o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":440.88,"width":12.96,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"1.42 o< a.!—fi[~ (¢}= Q.©-[¢}o, oN A=t[=] =< o) P— \\O -Bo H o= c=© B o©-Q& o, =©= - <Q<o w2=oo = »w2co =» o[¢} @o= oBO: -=o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":493,"blockId":46,"value":">","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":224.4,"y":446.16,"width":1.44,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":494,"blockId":46,"value":"[","fontName":"Times","fontSize":2.0,"color":null,"x":328.32,"y":447.36,"width":5.76,"height":1.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":224.4,"MarginRight":334.08,"Value":"> ["},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":495,"blockId":46,"value":"’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":263.52,"y":452.64,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":263.52,"MarginRight":265.2,"Value":"’"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":496,"blockId":46,"value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8=","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":455.04,"width":162.72,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":497,"blockId":46,"value":"w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":455.04,"width":59.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":498,"blockId":46,"value":"2o P","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.76,"y":452.4,"width":9.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":499,"blockId":46,"value":"&< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":353.28,"y":452.4,"width":90.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":443.28,"Value":"o3BS\"]Syo8 wn a- oe- = &s[¢] =a w2o&8a[¢]8= w a=[¢]-wn oQoo=@& 2o P &< &5a — ) eS5o oS . ©"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":524.88}}},{"Key":51,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":500,"columnEnd":513,"text":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.43","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.143","paragraphId":"pa1.43","paragraphLabel":"1.43","rectangle":"72, 477, 452, 33","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings.","averageFontSize":5.817204301075269,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":500,"blockId":47,"value":"1.43","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":477.6,"width":17.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":501,"blockId":47,"value":"low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":477.84,"width":139.68,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":502,"blockId":47,"value":"—=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":246.0,"y":478.8,"width":279.12,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"1.43 low)< o=[¢}— o&-oo, N ot >ogo72}- [\\> ek \\O —=o —~=2Ss=2 =2oOa(¢}o, —=o =ownoQo=Boo== =o o=]oSoo & oQoo« o— =w2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":503,"blockId":47,"value":"2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":240.48,"y":484.08,"width":1.44,"height":2.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":240.48,"MarginRight":241.92,"Value":"2"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":504,"blockId":47,"value":"<=(=\"","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":492.96,"width":17.76,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":505,"blockId":47,"value":"Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":491.52,"width":84.72,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":506,"blockId":47,"value":"w2 a e~ >2oa","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":211.44,"y":490.56,"width":42.96,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":507,"blockId":47,"value":"5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":258.96,"y":490.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":508,"blockId":47,"value":"o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a»","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":492.96,"width":107.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":509,"blockId":47,"value":"o=o g=Qo<o[¢]","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":431.52,"y":491.52,"width":45.84,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":510,"blockId":47,"value":"o= oo[oN&-o","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":482.16,"y":492.96,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"<=(=\" Qo= »<82oB7 B =&Bo w2 a e~ >2oa 5|=Qooaoo,—=aQ» o=ol B=oool oQ-t= =&2.a» o=o g=Qo<o[¢] o= oo[oN&-o"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":511,"blockId":47,"value":"s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":3.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":496.8,"width":1.68,"height":2.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":312.96,"MarginRight":314.64,"Value":"s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":512,"blockId":47,"value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":505.68,"width":162.48,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":513,"blockId":47,"value":"=B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":268.56,"y":505.68,"width":89.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":358.32,"Value":"-s}Ugo=g=agQ oBe =o5<o=- o[¢]<o,@o8[¢]B-w =B -=o@o )=Qooooo,==]aQ2"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":52,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":514,"columnEnd":514,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.44","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.44","paragraphLabel":"1.44","rectangle":"72, 528, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":514,"blockId":48,"value":"1.44","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":528.24,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0,"Value":"1.44"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":90.0}}},{"Key":53,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":515,"columnEnd":515,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa1.45","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa1.45","paragraphLabel":"1.45","rectangle":"72, 553, 17, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":515,"blockId":49,"value":"1.45","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":553.68,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001,"Value":"1.45"}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":89.52000000000001}}},{"Key":54,"Value":{"pageNum":7,"columnStart":516,"columnEnd":535,"text":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46","paragraphId":"pa1.46","paragraphLabel":"1.46","rectangle":"72, 692, 452, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. ","averageFontSize":8.202090592334494,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":516,"blockId":50,"value":"1.46","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":72.48,"y":692.64,"width":17.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":517,"blockId":50,"value":"As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":692.88,"width":426.0,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"1.46 As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":518,"blockId":50,"value":"informed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":705.36,"width":39.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":519,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":145.92,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":520,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.96,"y":705.36,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":521,"blockId":50,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":182.4,"y":705.36,"width":32.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":522,"blockId":50,"value":"numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":222.0,"y":708.0,"width":42.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":523,"blockId":50,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":271.92,"y":705.36,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":524,"blockId":50,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":331.44,"y":708.0,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":525,"blockId":50,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.24,"y":705.36,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":526,"blockId":50,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":370.32,"y":705.36,"width":21.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":527,"blockId":50,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":398.16,"y":706.56,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":528,"blockId":50,"value":"date,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":413.04,"y":705.36,"width":20.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":529,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":440.16,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":530,"blockId":50,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":705.36,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":531,"blockId":50,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":708.0,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":532,"blockId":50,"value":"by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":495.12,"y":705.36,"width":10.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":533,"blockId":50,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":705.36,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":534,"blockId":50,"value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":718.08,"width":425.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":535,"blockId":50,"value":"the present Order.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":730.8,"width":78.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":177.84,"Value":"the present Order."}],"MarginLeft":72.48,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":55,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":540,"columnEnd":540,"text":" Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"h2","paragraphIdAuto":"hThe","paragraphId":"h2","paragraphLabel":"2.","rectangle":"99, 115, 176, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":540,"blockId":51,"value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.92,"width":176.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":276.48}}},{"Key":57,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":541,"columnEnd":542,"text":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.i","paragraphIdAuto":"hi","paragraphId":"h2.i","paragraphLabel":"(i)","rectangle":"96, 227, 319, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","averageFontSize":8.19047619047619,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":541,"blockId":55,"value":"(i)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":227.52,"width":12.0,"height":12.0,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":542,"blockId":55,"value":"The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":228.48,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997,"Value":"(i) The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":416.15999999999997}}},{"Key":56,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":543,"columnEnd":563,"text":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><span class=\"supertext\">1</span></a>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.2","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.To","paragraphId":"pa2.2","paragraphLabel":"2.2","rectangle":"99, 254, 425, 108","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><sup>1</sup></a>","averageFontSize":7.9171597633136095,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":543,"blockId":54,"value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"To properly assess the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":544,"blockId":54,"value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":269.04,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":545,"blockId":54,"value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.12,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":546,"blockId":54,"value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":291.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":547,"blockId":54,"value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":304.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings, in respect of issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":548,"blockId":54,"value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.04,"width":425.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility."},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":549,"blockId":54,"value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":550,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":551,"blockId":54,"value":"remained","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":121.68,"y":342.48,"width":40.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":552,"blockId":54,"value":"outstanding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.0,"y":342.48,"width":51.12,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":553,"blockId":54,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":224.88,"y":342.48,"width":19.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":554,"blockId":54,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":342.48,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":555,"blockId":54,"value":"Interim Award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.64,"y":342.48,"width":66.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":556,"blockId":54,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":339.36,"y":342.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":557,"blockId":54,"value":"found","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.96,"y":342.48,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":558,"blockId":54,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":342.48,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":559,"blockId":54,"value":"“it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.0,"y":342.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":560,"blockId":54,"value":"has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":430.32,"y":342.48,"width":14.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":561,"blockId":54,"value":"jurisdiction","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.28,"y":342.48,"width":50.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":562,"blockId":54,"value":"over","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":506.16,"y":345.12,"width":19.2,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that “it has jurisdiction over"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":563,"blockId":54,"value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":354.96,"width":380.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":480.24,"Value":"PrivatBank’s claims under the Treaty” and that “PrivatBank’s claims are admissible.”!"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":58,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":564,"columnEnd":573,"text":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.3","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.3","paragraphLabel":"2.3","rectangle":"99, 380, 425, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.03,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":564,"blockId":58,"value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.4,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"The Tribunal’s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":565,"blockId":58,"value":"from which the Tribunal derives","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":393.12,"width":145.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":566,"blockId":58,"value":"its jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":250.56,"y":393.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":567,"blockId":58,"value":"the “arbitral award","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":321.12,"y":393.12,"width":84.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":568,"blockId":58,"value":"shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":409.92,"y":393.12,"width":115.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the “arbitral award shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":569,"blockId":58,"value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":408.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"upon both parties to the dispute.” Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":570,"blockId":58,"value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":418.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards “shall be final and binding"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":571,"blockId":58,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":433.92,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":572,"blockId":58,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.44,"y":431.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":573,"blockId":58,"value":"parties.”","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":431.04,"width":36.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":169.92,"Value":"on the parties.”"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":59,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":574,"columnEnd":580,"text":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.4","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.It","paragraphId":"pa2.4","paragraphLabel":"2.4","rectangle":"99, 481, 426, 83","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. ","averageFontSize":7.6716417910447765,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":574,"blockId":59,"value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":481.92,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":575,"blockId":59,"value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":494.16,"width":426.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":576,"blockId":59,"value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":506.88,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":577,"blockId":59,"value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":521.04,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":578,"blockId":59,"value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":532.08,"width":425.04,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal’s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":579,"blockId":59,"value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":544.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":580,"blockId":59,"value":"the Tribunal in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":557.52,"width":117.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":216.95999999999998,"Value":"the Tribunal in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}}},{"Key":60,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":581,"columnEnd":583,"text":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.6","paragraphIdAuto":"pa1.46.The","paragraphId":"pa2.6","paragraphLabel":"2.6","rectangle":"99, 680, 425, 22","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence","averageFontSize":8.870466321243523,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":581,"blockId":61,"value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":680.64,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":582,"blockId":61,"value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":693.36,"width":382.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":583,"blockId":61,"value":"evidence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.72,"y":693.36,"width":38.4,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants’ evidence"}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":61,"Value":{"pageNum":8,"columnStart":584,"columnEnd":586,"text":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn1","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"fn1","paragraphLabel":"1","rectangle":"72, 737, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":584,"blockId":63,"value":"! Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":72.0,"y":737.76,"width":62.64,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"! Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":585,"blockId":63,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":740.88,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":586,"blockId":63,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":738.48,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":72.0,"MarginRight":205.2}}},{"Key":62,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":591,"columnEnd":597,"text":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 425, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":8.889855072463767,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":591,"blockId":66,"value":"and argument over the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":102.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":592,"blockId":66,"value":"last two phases of the proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":115.44,"width":159.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":593,"blockId":66,"value":"in particular by putting numerous","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":115.44,"width":152.64,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":594,"blockId":66,"value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":174.24,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":595,"blockId":66,"value":"1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.88,"y":127.92,"width":246.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":596,"blockId":66,"value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":142.08,"width":425.52,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":597,"blockId":66,"value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":286.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":386.64,"Value":"examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":63,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":598,"columnEnd":681,"text":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><span class=\"supertext\">4</span></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.7","paragraphId":"pa2.7","paragraphLabel":"2.7","rectangle":"71, 178, 455, 276","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><sup>4</sup></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). ","averageFontSize":8.661600810536981,"rowsOfText":22,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":598,"blockId":67,"value":"2.7","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":178.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":599,"blockId":67,"value":"Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.8,"width":425.52,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.7 Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement ofthese proceedings, the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":600,"blockId":67,"value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":601,"blockId":67,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":602,"blockId":67,"value":"on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":158.4,"y":206.64,"width":10.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":603,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.24,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":604,"blockId":67,"value":"of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":204.96,"y":204.0,"width":84.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":605,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":294.48,"y":204.0,"width":56.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":606,"blockId":67,"value":"(as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":204.0,"width":12.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":607,"blockId":67,"value":"well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":373.2,"y":204.0,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":608,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":396.96,"y":206.64,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":609,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":204.0,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":610,"blockId":67,"value":"of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":204.0,"width":53.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":611,"blockId":67,"value":"Thus,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":500.88,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":612,"blockId":67,"value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":613,"blockId":67,"value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":231.84,"width":425.52,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":614,"blockId":67,"value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":244.56,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":615,"blockId":67,"value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":100.08,"y":254.64,"width":350.16,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":616,"blockId":67,"value":"(ii1) granted the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":455.04,"y":254.4,"width":70.08,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":100.08,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":617,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal’s written questions on substantive"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":618,"blockId":67,"value":"issues,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":279.84,"width":28.32,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":619,"blockId":67,"value":"including with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":279.84,"width":64.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":620,"blockId":67,"value":"respect to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":281.04,"width":43.44,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":621,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of jurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":279.84,"width":114.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":622,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":370.56,"y":279.84,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":623,"blockId":67,"value":"(as well","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":431.76,"y":280.08,"width":35.52,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":624,"blockId":67,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":282.48,"width":8.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":625,"blockId":67,"value":"issues of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":486.0,"y":279.84,"width":40.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":626,"blockId":67,"value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":292.56,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":627,"blockId":67,"value":"pleadings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":41.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":628,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":146.88,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":629,"blockId":67,"value":"other communications","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":167.76,"y":305.04,"width":99.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":630,"blockId":67,"value":"from the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.64,"y":305.04,"width":39.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":631,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":317.28,"y":305.04,"width":42.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":632,"blockId":67,"value":"including","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":305.04,"width":41.04,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":633,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":411.36,"y":305.04,"width":19.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":634,"blockId":67,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":435.84,"y":306.48,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":635,"blockId":67,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":471.84,"y":306.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":636,"blockId":67,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":485.52,"y":305.04,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":637,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":516.48,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001,"Value":"pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":638,"blockId":67,"value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":317.76,"width":426.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":639,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.24,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":640,"blockId":67,"value":"Claimant, to comment on the proposed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":117.84,"y":330.24,"width":180.0,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":641,"blockId":67,"value":"candidacy,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":302.88,"y":330.24,"width":46.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":642,"blockId":67,"value":"terms","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":354.48,"y":331.44,"width":23.76,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":643,"blockId":67,"value":"of reference and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":383.52,"y":330.24,"width":74.88,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":644,"blockId":67,"value":"reports of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":463.2,"y":331.68,"width":61.92,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":645,"blockId":67,"value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":425.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":646,"blockId":67,"value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":647,"blockId":67,"value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":368.16,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues ofjurisdiction and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":648,"blockId":67,"value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":380.88,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"(while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":649,"blockId":67,"value":"timely","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":27.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":650,"blockId":67,"value":"manner,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":132.72,"y":396.24,"width":35.04,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":651,"blockId":67,"value":"with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":173.28,"y":393.6,"width":19.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":652,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":653,"blockId":67,"value":"transcripts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":216.24,"y":393.6,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":654,"blockId":67,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":267.36,"y":393.6,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":655,"blockId":67,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":288.24,"y":393.6,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":656,"blockId":67,"value":"other documents","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":304.08,"y":393.6,"width":74.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":657,"blockId":67,"value":"submitted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":384.48,"y":393.6,"width":42.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":658,"blockId":67,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":432.72,"y":393.6,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":659,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":445.92,"y":393.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":660,"blockId":67,"value":"course","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":464.4,"y":396.24,"width":28.32,"height":5.28,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":661,"blockId":67,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.24,"y":393.6,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":662,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings;","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":406.08,"width":39.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":663,"blockId":67,"value":"and (vii) provided an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":406.08,"width":97.44,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":664,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunity","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":247.2,"y":406.08,"width":50.88,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":665,"blockId":67,"value":"for, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.12,"y":406.08,"width":35.76,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":666,"blockId":75,"value":"invited, the Respondent to comment on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":343.68,"y":406.08,"width":181.44,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":667,"blockId":67,"value":"anything","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":418.8,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":668,"blockId":67,"value":"said","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":144.72,"y":418.8,"width":17.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":669,"blockId":67,"value":"during","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":168.48,"y":418.8,"width":28.08,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":670,"blockId":67,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":203.04,"y":418.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":671,"blockId":67,"value":"hearings.*","fontName":"Times","fontSize":11.0,"color":null,"x":222.72,"y":418.08,"width":43.44,"height":11.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":672,"blockId":67,"value":"The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":272.88,"y":419.04,"width":16.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":673,"blockId":67,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":296.16,"y":419.04,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":674,"blockId":67,"value":"did","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.24,"y":419.04,"width":13.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":675,"blockId":67,"value":"not","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":420.48,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":676,"blockId":67,"value":"avail","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.8,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":677,"blockId":67,"value":"itself of any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":422.4,"y":419.04,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":678,"blockId":67,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":419.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":679,"blockId":67,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.8,"y":419.04,"width":22.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"anything said during the hearings.* The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":680,"blockId":67,"value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues ofjurisdiction and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":681,"blockId":67,"value":"admissibility (or issues of liability).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":444.24,"width":155.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":255.6,"Value":"admissibility (or issues of liability)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.5600000000001}}},{"Key":64,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":682,"columnEnd":687,"text":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.8","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.28","paragraphId":"pa2.8","paragraphLabel":"2.8","rectangle":"71, 469, 453, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":9.450777202072539,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":682,"blockId":68,"value":"2.8","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":469.68,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":683,"blockId":68,"value":"Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.8 Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":684,"blockId":68,"value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":685,"blockId":68,"value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":425.28,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":686,"blockId":68,"value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":687,"blockId":68,"value":"|||><g&","fontName":"Times","fontSize":48.0,"color":null,"x":99.12,"y":520.56,"width":34.08,"height":47.76,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.12,"MarginRight":133.2,"Value":"|||><g&"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":65,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":688,"columnEnd":707,"text":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.9","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.9","paragraphLabel":"2.9","rectangle":"71, 583, 454, 98","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. ","averageFontSize":8.710526315789474,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":688,"blockId":69,"value":"29","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":689,"blockId":69,"value":"The Tribunal is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.2,"width":70.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":690,"blockId":69,"value":"also mindful of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":174.96,"y":583.2,"width":86.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":691,"blockId":69,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":266.88,"y":583.2,"width":47.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":692,"blockId":69,"value":"interest","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.44,"y":583.2,"width":31.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":693,"blockId":69,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":355.92,"y":583.2,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":694,"blockId":69,"value":"the finality of the Awards and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":368.64,"y":583.2,"width":156.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"29 The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant’s interest in the finality of the Awards and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":695,"blockId":69,"value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":595.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Tribunal’s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":696,"blockId":69,"value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"delay would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request to reopen the Tribunal’s decisions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":697,"blockId":69,"value":"jurisdiction were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":621.12,"width":77.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":698,"blockId":69,"value":"granted. Moreover, now","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":180.72,"y":621.36,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":699,"blockId":69,"value":"that the Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":295.92,"y":621.12,"width":66.0,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":700,"blockId":69,"value":"courts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":367.2,"y":622.56,"width":26.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":701,"blockId":69,"value":"are","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":624.0,"width":12.96,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":702,"blockId":69,"value":"seised of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":417.12,"y":621.12,"width":58.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":703,"blockId":69,"value":"Set Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":481.44,"y":621.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":704,"blockId":69,"value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":634.08,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re-"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":705,"blockId":69,"value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":706,"blockId":69,"value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":707,"blockId":69,"value":"supervisory jurisdiction.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":672.0,"width":105.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":205.68,"Value":"supervisory jurisdiction."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":67,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":708,"columnEnd":711,"text":" In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10","paragraphId":"pa2.10","paragraphLabel":"2.10","rectangle":"71, 697, 454, 32","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":null,"averageFontSize":7.674496644295302,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":708,"blockId":73,"value":"2.10","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":697.44,"width":18.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":6,"id":709,"blockId":73,"value":"In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":697.68,"width":425.28,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.10 In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":710,"blockId":73,"value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will"},{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":711,"blockId":73,"value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal"}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":66,"Value":{"pageNum":9,"columnStart":712,"columnEnd":715,"text":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"fn4","paragraphId":"fn4","paragraphLabel":"4","rectangle":"71, 760, 228, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. ","averageFontSize":6.722222222222222,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":712,"blockId":72,"value":"4 See Interim Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.04,"y":760.56,"width":83.28,"height":4.56,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":154.32,"Value":"4 See Interim Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":713,"blockId":72,"value":"para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":763.92,"width":19.2,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":714,"blockId":72,"value":"154; Partial Award, para.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":180.96,"y":761.52,"width":99.12,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":715,"blockId":72,"value":"176.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":284.64,"y":761.52,"width":15.36,"height":7.2,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":157.44,"MarginRight":300.0,"Value":"para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176."}],"MarginLeft":71.04,"MarginRight":300.0}}},{"Key":68,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":720,"columnEnd":724,"text":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa","paragraphIdAuto":"pai.in","paragraphId":"pa","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 147, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.84,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":720,"blockId":74,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":115.44,"width":8.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":721,"blockId":74,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":115.68,"y":115.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":722,"blockId":74,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.04,"y":115.68,"width":13.2,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":723,"blockId":74,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.92,"y":115.44,"width":25.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":724,"blockId":74,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":115.44,"width":55.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96,"Value":"in the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":246.96}}},{"Key":69,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":725,"columnEnd":733,"text":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.11","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.211","paragraphId":"pa2.11","paragraphLabel":"2.11","rectangle":"71, 166, 453, 73","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. ","averageFontSize":9.064615384615385,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":725,"blockId":76,"value":"2.11","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":88.8,"Value":"2.11"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":726,"blockId":76,"value":"he Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":474.72,"y":178.56,"width":50.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":474.72,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"he Tribunal"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":727,"blockId":76,"value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":728,"blockId":76,"value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":425.28,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":729,"blockId":76,"value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":216.48,"width":189.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":730,"blockId":76,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":216.48,"width":10.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":731,"blockId":76,"value":"other applicable jurisdictional and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":308.88,"y":216.48,"width":155.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":732,"blockId":76,"value":"admissibility","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":468.72,"y":216.48,"width":56.4,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":733,"blockId":76,"value":"requirements under the Treaty.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":134.88,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":234.48,"Value":"requirements under the Treaty."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":70,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":734,"columnEnd":765,"text":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.12","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.212","paragraphId":"pa2.12","paragraphLabel":"2.12","rectangle":"71, 254, 454, 172","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","averageFontSize":9.06353591160221,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":734,"blockId":79,"value":"2.12","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":254.64,"width":18.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.12"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":735,"blockId":79,"value":"IAlthough the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":330.48,"width":102.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":736,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":207.12,"y":330.48,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":737,"blockId":79,"value":"could","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":264.24,"y":330.48,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":738,"blockId":79,"value":"have","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":293.76,"y":330.48,"width":20.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":739,"blockId":79,"value":"raised","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":319.68,"y":330.48,"width":25.92,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":740,"blockId":79,"value":"this","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.88,"y":330.48,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":741,"blockId":79,"value":"issue","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.24,"y":330.48,"width":21.12,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":742,"blockId":79,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":399.36,"y":331.92,"width":7.44,"height":6.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":743,"blockId":79,"value":"an","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":412.32,"y":333.12,"width":9.84,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":744,"blockId":79,"value":"earlier","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":427.92,"y":330.48,"width":27.84,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":745,"blockId":79,"value":"stage","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":461.28,"y":331.92,"width":21.84,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":746,"blockId":79,"value":"of these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":488.88,"y":330.48,"width":36.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"IAlthough the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":747,"blockId":79,"value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":342.96,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":748,"blockId":79,"value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":749,"blockId":79,"value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":368.4,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":750,"blockId":79,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":382.56,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":751,"blockId":79,"value":"minimize","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.48,"y":381.12,"width":40.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":752,"blockId":79,"value":"any","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":161.76,"y":383.76,"width":15.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":753,"blockId":79,"value":"delay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":183.6,"y":381.12,"width":23.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":754,"blockId":79,"value":"resulting","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":213.6,"y":381.12,"width":38.16,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":755,"blockId":79,"value":"from","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":258.24,"y":381.12,"width":20.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":756,"blockId":79,"value":"such","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.6,"y":381.12,"width":19.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":757,"blockId":79,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":311.76,"y":381.12,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":758,"blockId":79,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":381.12,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":759,"blockId":79,"value":"given","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":393.36,"y":381.12,"width":23.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":760,"blockId":79,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":423.6,"y":381.12,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":761,"blockId":79,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":381.12,"width":12.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":762,"blockId":79,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":465.6,"y":381.12,"width":59.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":763,"blockId":79,"value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":395.04,"width":425.28,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":764,"blockId":79,"value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":406.32,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":765,"blockId":79,"value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below).","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":419.04,"width":424.8,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"made in the Respondent’s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below)."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":71,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":766,"columnEnd":781,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.13","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:13","paragraphId":"pa2.13","paragraphLabel":"2:13","rectangle":"71, 444, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. ","averageFontSize":8.380434782608695,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":766,"blockId":80,"value":"2:13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":444.48,"width":18.24,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":767,"blockId":80,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:13 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":768,"blockId":80,"value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":769,"blockId":80,"value":"paragraph","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":43.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":770,"blockId":80,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.76,"y":469.68,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":771,"blockId":80,"value":"below)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":174.72,"y":469.44,"width":30.0,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":772,"blockId":80,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":211.2,"y":469.44,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":773,"blockId":80,"value":"Respondent may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":230.88,"y":469.44,"width":76.32,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":774,"blockId":80,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":313.44,"y":469.44,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":775,"blockId":80,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":343.44,"y":469.44,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":776,"blockId":80,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":403.2,"y":469.44,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":777,"blockId":80,"value":"respect","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":417.36,"y":470.88,"width":30.72,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":778,"blockId":80,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":454.56,"y":469.44,"width":10.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":779,"blockId":80,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":469.92,"y":469.44,"width":9.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":780,"blockId":80,"value":"Illegality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":486.24,"y":469.44,"width":39.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":781,"blockId":80,"value":"Objection.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":45.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":144.95999999999998,"Value":"Objection."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":72,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":782,"columnEnd":783,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.ii","paragraphIdAuto":"hii","paragraphId":"h2.ii","paragraphLabel":"(ii)","rectangle":"96, 506, 269, 12","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings","averageFontSize":8.307692307692308,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":782,"blockId":81,"value":"(ii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":506.64,"width":15.12,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":783,"blockId":81,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.32,"y":507.36,"width":229.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24,"Value":"(ii) The Respondent’s Requestfor a Stay ofProceedings"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":366.24}}},{"Key":73,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":784,"columnEnd":799,"text":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.14","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.214","paragraphId":"pa2.14","paragraphLabel":"2.14","rectangle":"71, 532, 454, 35","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.7631578947368425,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":784,"blockId":82,"value":"2.14","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":532.8,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":785,"blockId":82,"value":"In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":533.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.14 In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":786,"blockId":82,"value":"requests","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":546.72,"width":35.52,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":787,"blockId":82,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":141.84,"y":545.28,"width":16.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":788,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.4,"y":545.52,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":789,"blockId":82,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":184.08,"y":545.28,"width":37.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":790,"blockId":82,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":228.24,"y":546.72,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":791,"blockId":82,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":251.76,"y":545.28,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":792,"blockId":82,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":280.32,"y":545.28,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":793,"blockId":82,"value":"pending","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":339.6,"y":545.28,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":794,"blockId":82,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":381.36,"y":545.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":795,"blockId":82,"value":"outcome","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":401.04,"y":546.72,"width":37.2,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":796,"blockId":82,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":444.96,"y":545.28,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":797,"blockId":82,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":480.0,"y":545.76,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":798,"blockId":82,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":545.28,"width":24.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":799,"blockId":82,"value":"Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":55.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":155.28,"Value":"Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":74,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":800,"columnEnd":806,"text":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.15","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.215","paragraphId":"pa2.15","paragraphLabel":"2.15","rectangle":"71, 583, 453, 60","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":8.451965065502183,"rowsOfText":5,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":800,"blockId":83,"value":"2.15","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":583.44,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":801,"blockId":83,"value":"The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.44,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.15 The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":802,"blockId":83,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":596.4,"width":351.36,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":803,"blockId":83,"value":"law, that would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":455.76,"y":596.16,"width":69.36,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":804,"blockId":83,"value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":608.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":805,"blockId":83,"value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.12,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":806,"blockId":83,"value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":635.28,"width":313.44,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":413.28,"Value":"stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":75,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":807,"columnEnd":817,"text":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.16","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.10.2:16","paragraphId":"pa2.16","paragraphLabel":"2.16","rectangle":"71, 659, 453, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. ","averageFontSize":8.691358024691358,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":807,"blockId":84,"value":"2:16","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":659.52,"width":18.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":808,"blockId":84,"value":"The Tribunal considers that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":124.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":809,"blockId":84,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":228.72,"y":659.52,"width":5.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":810,"blockId":84,"value":"is for the Respondent to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.8,"y":659.52,"width":109.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":811,"blockId":84,"value":"establish that a stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":352.56,"y":659.52,"width":89.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":812,"blockId":84,"value":"is justified by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":446.16,"y":659.52,"width":78.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2:16 The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":813,"blockId":84,"value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":672.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":814,"blockId":84,"value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":815,"blockId":84,"value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":816,"blockId":84,"value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":817,"blockId":84,"value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":722.64,"width":375.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":475.20000000000005,"Value":"therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":76,"Value":{"pageNum":10,"columnStart":818,"columnEnd":819,"text":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn5","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.10.5","paragraphId":"fn5","paragraphLabel":"5","rectangle":"71, 760, 104, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. ","averageFontSize":5.038461538461538,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":818,"blockId":85,"value":"5 Set Aside Writ,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":66.96,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":138.24,"Value":"5 Set Aside Writ,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":819,"blockId":85,"value":"para. 83.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":141.36,"y":763.92,"width":34.08,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":141.36,"MarginRight":175.44,"Value":"para. 83."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":175.44}}},{"Key":77,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":824,"columnEnd":824,"text":"[REDACTED]","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.17","paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":"pa2.17","paragraphLabel":"2.17","rectangle":"71, 127, 18, 7","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"[REDACTED]","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":1,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":6,"id":824,"blockId":86,"value":"2.17","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":127.92,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76,"Value":"2.17"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":89.76}}},{"Key":78,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":825,"columnEnd":853,"text":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.18","paragraphId":"pa2.18","paragraphLabel":"2.18","rectangle":"71, 166, 455, 95","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. ","averageFontSize":8.048780487804878,"rowsOfText":8,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":825,"blockId":87,"value":"2.18","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":166.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":826,"blockId":87,"value":"The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":166.08,"width":215.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":827,"blockId":87,"value":"success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":319.92,"y":166.08,"width":205.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"2.18 The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent’s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":828,"blockId":87,"value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":179.76,"width":425.76,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":829,"blockId":87,"value":"deciding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":191.28,"width":37.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":830,"blockId":87,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":142.32,"y":191.28,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":831,"blockId":87,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":160.8,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":832,"blockId":87,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":225.84,"y":192.48,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":833,"blockId":87,"value":"aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":242.64,"y":191.28,"width":22.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":834,"blockId":87,"value":"application under Dutch","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":270.24,"y":191.28,"width":110.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":835,"blockId":87,"value":"law.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":385.68,"y":191.28,"width":17.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":836,"blockId":87,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":191.28,"width":59.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":837,"blockId":87,"value":"accordingly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":473.76,"y":191.28,"width":51.6,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"deciding the Respondent’s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":838,"blockId":87,"value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.0,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":839,"blockId":87,"value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":840,"blockId":87,"value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":229.2,"width":426.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":841,"blockId":87,"value":"Appeal,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":33.84,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":842,"blockId":87,"value":"ought","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":139.68,"y":241.92,"width":24.48,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":843,"blockId":87,"value":"nevertheless","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":169.92,"y":241.92,"width":53.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":844,"blockId":87,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":229.44,"y":243.12,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":845,"blockId":87,"value":"consider","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":243.36,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":846,"blockId":87,"value":"whether","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":285.84,"y":241.92,"width":35.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":847,"blockId":87,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":326.64,"y":244.56,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":848,"blockId":87,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":337.2,"y":243.12,"width":17.04,"height":8.88,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":849,"blockId":87,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.0,"y":241.92,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":850,"blockId":87,"value":"proceedings may","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":389.76,"y":241.92,"width":77.28,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":851,"blockId":87,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":472.32,"y":241.92,"width":37.2,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":852,"blockId":87,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.04,"y":241.92,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":853,"blockId":87,"value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":254.4,"width":250.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":350.4,"Value":"warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}}},{"Key":79,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":854,"columnEnd":897,"text":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.19","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.219","paragraphId":"pa2.19","paragraphLabel":"2.19","rectangle":"71, 279, 455, 86","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. ","averageFontSize":9.113138686131387,"rowsOfText":7,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":854,"blockId":88,"value":"2.19","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":280.08,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":855,"blockId":88,"value":"Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.19 Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":856,"blockId":88,"value":"jurisdictional","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.64,"y":292.56,"width":58.56,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":857,"blockId":88,"value":"objections","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":292.56,"width":44.64,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":858,"blockId":88,"value":"summarized","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":292.56,"width":53.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":859,"blockId":88,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":277.44,"y":292.56,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":860,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":292.56,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":861,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":312.96,"y":292.56,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":862,"blockId":88,"value":"recent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":379.68,"y":294.0,"width":26.64,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":863,"blockId":88,"value":"correspondence","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.52,"y":292.56,"width":68.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":864,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":489.6,"y":292.56,"width":15.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":865,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":292.56,"width":12.96,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.64,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent’s recent correspondence and the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":866,"blockId":88,"value":"Respondent’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":59.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":867,"blockId":88,"value":"Set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":166.08,"y":305.28,"width":13.44,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":868,"blockId":88,"value":"Aside","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":185.76,"y":305.04,"width":25.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":869,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":217.68,"y":305.04,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":870,"blockId":88,"value":"Revocation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":305.04,"width":49.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":871,"blockId":88,"value":"Writs,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":305.04,"width":26.64,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":872,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":329.04,"y":305.04,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":873,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":305.04,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":874,"blockId":88,"value":"concludes","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":392.64,"y":305.04,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":875,"blockId":88,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":442.56,"y":305.04,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":876,"blockId":88,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":465.36,"y":307.68,"width":4.32,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":877,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":476.4,"y":306.48,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":878,"blockId":88,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":499.92,"y":305.04,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":879,"blockId":88,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":515.52,"y":305.04,"width":9.6,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":880,"blockId":88,"value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration ofjustice. The continuation of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":881,"blockId":88,"value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":330.48,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":882,"blockId":88,"value":"failure","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":342.96,"width":28.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":883,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":133.44,"y":344.4,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":884,"blockId":88,"value":"stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":147.6,"y":344.4,"width":17.28,"height":8.64,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":885,"blockId":88,"value":"impede","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.4,"y":342.96,"width":31.68,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":886,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.84,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":887,"blockId":88,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":226.56,"y":342.96,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":888,"blockId":88,"value":"ability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":277.92,"y":342.96,"width":27.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":889,"blockId":88,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":311.04,"y":344.16,"width":7.92,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":890,"blockId":88,"value":"fully","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":324.96,"y":342.96,"width":20.16,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":891,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":350.64,"y":342.96,"width":15.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":892,"blockId":88,"value":"properly","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":371.52,"y":342.96,"width":37.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":893,"blockId":88,"value":"examine","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":414.48,"y":342.96,"width":36.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":894,"blockId":88,"value":"and","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":456.96,"y":342.96,"width":15.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":895,"blockId":88,"value":"decide","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":478.08,"y":342.96,"width":28.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":896,"blockId":88,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":342.96,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"failure to stay impede the Tribunal’s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":897,"blockId":88,"value":"remaining issues before it.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":115.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":214.8,"Value":"remaining issues before it."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}}},{"Key":80,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":898,"columnEnd":900,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.20","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.220","paragraphId":"pa2.20","paragraphLabel":"2.20","rectangle":"71, 380, 453, 20","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. ","averageFontSize":7.451851851851852,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":898,"blockId":89,"value":"2.20","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":381.12,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":899,"blockId":89,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.20 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":900,"blockId":89,"value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":395.04,"width":169.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":269.52,"Value":"outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88}}},{"Key":81,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":901,"columnEnd":903,"text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","indentLevel":2,"paragraphIdUser":"h2.iii","paragraphIdAuto":"h2.220.iii","paragraphId":"h2.iii","paragraphLabel":"(iii)","rectangle":"96, 417, 427, 21","alignment":0,"blockType":2,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum","averageFontSize":8.176991150442477,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":901,"blockId":90,"value":"(iii)","fontName":"Times","fontSize":12.0,"color":null,"x":96.96,"y":417.84,"width":16.56,"height":12.24,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":902,"blockId":90,"value":"The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":136.56,"y":418.8,"width":388.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64,"Value":"(iii) The Respondent’s Requestfor Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":903,"blockId":90,"value":"the Merits and Quantum","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":135.84,"y":431.52,"width":107.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":135.84,"MarginRight":243.12,"Value":"the Merits and Quantum"}],"MarginLeft":96.96,"MarginRight":524.64}}},{"Key":82,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":904,"columnEnd":908,"text":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.21","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.2220","paragraphId":"pa2.21","paragraphLabel":"2.21","rectangle":"71, 456, 453, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. ","averageFontSize":8.532212885154062,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":904,"blockId":91,"value":"2220","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":456.96,"width":17.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":2,"id":905,"blockId":91,"value":"Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":456.72,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2220 Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":906,"blockId":91,"value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":469.44,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":907,"blockId":91,"value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on"},{"columns":[{"type":2,"id":908,"blockId":91,"value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.64,"width":300.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":400.32000000000005,"Value":"the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12}}},{"Key":83,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":909,"columnEnd":949,"text":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><span class=\"supertext\">7</span></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.22","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.222","paragraphId":"pa2.22","paragraphLabel":"2.22","rectangle":"71, 520, 455, 149","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><sup>7</sup></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. ","averageFontSize":8.214634146341464,"rowsOfText":12,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":909,"blockId":92,"value":"2.22","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":520.32,"width":18.48,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":910,"blockId":92,"value":"In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":520.56,"width":425.04,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"2.22 In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that “the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":911,"blockId":92,"value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":533.04,"width":425.76,"height":9.84,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Treaty in respect of PrivatBank’s investments.”” Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":912,"blockId":92,"value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":545.52,"width":426.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":913,"blockId":92,"value":"proceedings","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":558.0,"width":52.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":914,"blockId":92,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":158.88,"y":558.0,"width":6.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":915,"blockId":92,"value":"unwarranted","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":171.6,"y":558.0,"width":54.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":916,"blockId":92,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":232.8,"y":558.0,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":917,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":246.72,"y":558.0,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":918,"blockId":92,"value":"present","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":265.92,"y":559.2,"width":31.68,"height":9.12,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":919,"blockId":92,"value":"circumstances","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":303.6,"y":558.0,"width":61.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":920,"blockId":92,"value":"for","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":372.0,"y":558.0,"width":12.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":921,"blockId":92,"value":"all","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":390.24,"y":558.0,"width":10.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":922,"blockId":92,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":407.04,"y":558.0,"width":27.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":923,"blockId":92,"value":"reasons","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":441.12,"y":560.88,"width":32.4,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":924,"blockId":92,"value":"set","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":480.24,"y":559.44,"width":11.52,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":925,"blockId":92,"value":"out","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":559.44,"width":13.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":926,"blockId":92,"value":"at","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":517.68,"y":559.44,"width":7.68,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.3599999999999,"Value":"proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":927,"blockId":92,"value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent’s similar request to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":928,"blockId":92,"value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":98.4,"y":583.44,"width":426.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":98.4,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":929,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":595.92,"width":53.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":930,"blockId":92,"value":"regarding","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":159.12,"y":595.92,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":931,"blockId":92,"value":"issues","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":595.92,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":932,"blockId":92,"value":"of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":239.52,"y":595.92,"width":9.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":933,"blockId":92,"value":"liability.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":254.4,"y":595.92,"width":35.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":934,"blockId":92,"value":"As","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":296.88,"y":596.4,"width":11.76,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":935,"blockId":92,"value":"with jurisdiction,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":314.88,"y":595.92,"width":77.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":936,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":937,"blockId":92,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":418.32,"y":596.16,"width":51.36,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":938,"blockId":92,"value":"missed","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":475.92,"y":595.92,"width":30.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":939,"blockId":92,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":595.92,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":940,"blockId":92,"value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":611.52,"width":425.76,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":941,"blockId":92,"value":"any compelling reason why it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":621.36,"width":137.04,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":942,"blockId":92,"value":"should now be allowed to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":241.92,"y":621.36,"width":147.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":943,"blockId":92,"value":"submissions","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":395.04,"y":621.36,"width":53.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":944,"blockId":92,"value":"long","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":453.6,"y":621.6,"width":18.72,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":945,"blockId":92,"value":"after","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":477.36,"y":621.36,"width":20.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":946,"blockId":92,"value":"those","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":502.32,"y":621.6,"width":22.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":947,"blockId":92,"value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":633.84,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants’ interest in the finality"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":948,"blockId":92,"value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":646.56,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent’s request were"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":949,"blockId":92,"value":"granted.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":659.52,"width":34.8,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":134.39999999999998,"Value":"granted."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.56}}},{"Key":85,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":950,"columnEnd":953,"text":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.23","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.223","paragraphId":"pa2.23","paragraphLabel":"2.23","rectangle":"71, 684, 454, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":true,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","averageFontSize":7.683848797250859,"rowsOfText":3,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":950,"blockId":95,"value":"2.23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":684.72,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":951,"blockId":95,"value":"The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":684.72,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.23 The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":952,"blockId":95,"value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":697.44,"width":425.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":953,"blockId":95,"value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":709.92,"width":425.52,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}}},{"Key":84,"Value":{"pageNum":11,"columnStart":955,"columnEnd":957,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn7","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.7","paragraphId":"fn7","paragraphLabel":"7","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 9","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":5.9375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":955,"blockId":93,"value":"7 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":4.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.8,"width":63.36,"height":4.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"7 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":956,"blockId":93,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.72,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":957,"blockId":93,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}}},{"Key":86,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":962,"columnEnd":970,"text":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><span class=\"supertext\">8</span></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":null,"paragraphIdAuto":null,"paragraphId":null,"paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"99, 115, 426, 70","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><sup>8</sup></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. ","averageFontSize":8.88030888030888,"rowsOfText":6,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":962,"blockId":96,"value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":115.44,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"remaining questions ofjurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":963,"blockId":96,"value":"event that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":127.92,"width":44.16,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":964,"blockId":96,"value":"liability","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":127.92,"width":34.08,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":965,"blockId":96,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":186.72,"y":127.92,"width":6.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":966,"blockId":96,"value":"established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":198.0,"y":127.92,"width":328.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56,"Value":"event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":967,"blockId":96,"value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":140.64,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":968,"blockId":96,"value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":153.36,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.® The Tribunal has"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":969,"blockId":96,"value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":166.08,"width":425.28,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":970,"blockId":96,"value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":178.56,"width":175.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":275.03999999999996,"Value":"Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award."}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":526.56}}},{"Key":87,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":971,"columnEnd":988,"text":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.24","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.224","paragraphId":"pa2.24","paragraphLabel":"2.24","rectangle":"71, 204, 454, 45","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. ","averageFontSize":9.137142857142857,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":971,"blockId":97,"value":"2.24","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":204.0,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":972,"blockId":97,"value":"In","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":204.24,"width":8.64,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":973,"blockId":97,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":114.72,"y":204.0,"width":22.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":974,"blockId":97,"value":"circumstances,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":143.52,"y":204.0,"width":64.56,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":975,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":214.56,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":976,"blockId":97,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":234.24,"y":204.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":977,"blockId":97,"value":"considers","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":278.4,"y":204.0,"width":40.8,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":978,"blockId":97,"value":"that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":325.68,"y":204.0,"width":16.32,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":979,"blockId":97,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":348.48,"y":204.0,"width":5.76,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":980,"blockId":97,"value":"would","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":360.48,"y":204.0,"width":27.36,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":981,"blockId":97,"value":"be","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":394.08,"y":204.0,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":982,"blockId":97,"value":"appropriate","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":410.64,"y":204.0,"width":49.68,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":983,"blockId":97,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":466.56,"y":205.2,"width":8.4,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":984,"blockId":97,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.68,"y":204.0,"width":24.0,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":985,"blockId":97,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":511.92,"y":204.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"2.24 In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":986,"blockId":97,"value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":216.48,"width":425.76,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant’s forthcoming revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":987,"blockId":97,"value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":229.2,"width":425.52,"height":10.08,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) ofthe UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":988,"blockId":97,"value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":241.92,"width":376.56,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":476.15999999999997,"Value":"that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":88,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":989,"columnEnd":1018,"text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.25","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.225","paragraphId":"pa2.25","paragraphLabel":"2.25","rectangle":"71, 267, 454, 136","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. ","averageFontSize":7.852441613588111,"rowsOfText":11,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":989,"blockId":98,"value":"225","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":267.12,"width":18.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":990,"blockId":98,"value":"The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":267.12,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"225 The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":991,"blockId":98,"value":"Claimant’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":279.84,"width":47.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":992,"blockId":98,"value":"claim on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":153.12,"y":279.84,"width":39.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":993,"blockId":98,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.24,"y":279.84,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":994,"blockId":98,"value":"merits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.72,"y":279.84,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":995,"blockId":98,"value":"and quantum insofar","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":249.36,"y":279.84,"width":94.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":996,"blockId":98,"value":"as","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":349.2,"y":282.48,"width":8.64,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":997,"blockId":98,"value":"it","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":363.36,"y":279.84,"width":5.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":998,"blockId":98,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":374.4,"y":279.84,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":999,"blockId":98,"value":"seeks","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":386.88,"y":279.84,"width":23.04,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1000,"blockId":98,"value":"a","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":415.44,"y":282.48,"width":4.56,"height":5.04,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1001,"blockId":98,"value":"reconsideration","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":425.04,"y":279.84,"width":67.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1002,"blockId":98,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":498.0,"y":279.84,"width":27.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1003,"blockId":98,"value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":292.56,"width":425.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1004,"blockId":98,"value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":305.04,"width":425.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1005,"blockId":98,"value":"the issues of compensation due","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":317.76,"width":140.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1006,"blockId":98,"value":"in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":245.28,"y":317.76,"width":279.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1007,"blockId":98,"value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":330.48,"width":308.16,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1008,"blockId":98,"value":"legal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":413.28,"y":330.48,"width":20.64,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1009,"blockId":98,"value":"authorities,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":438.96,"y":330.48,"width":48.48,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1010,"blockId":98,"value":"witness","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":492.48,"y":330.48,"width":32.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1011,"blockId":98,"value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":344.4,"width":425.28,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1012,"blockId":98,"value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":355.68,"width":198.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1013,"blockId":98,"value":"above, the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":9.0,"color":null,"x":303.84,"y":355.68,"width":45.6,"height":9.36,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1014,"blockId":98,"value":"Parties’","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":354.0,"y":355.68,"width":32.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1015,"blockId":98,"value":"submissions on compensation","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":391.92,"y":355.68,"width":133.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1016,"blockId":98,"value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":370.8,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1017,"blockId":98,"value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":380.88,"width":425.76,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1018,"blockId":98,"value":"witnesses, if any.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":393.6,"width":74.88,"height":9.6,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":174.48,"Value":"witnesses, if any."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.36}}},{"Key":89,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1019,"columnEnd":1033,"text":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.26","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.226","paragraphId":"pa2.26","paragraphLabel":"2.26","rectangle":"71, 419, 454, 48","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. ","averageFontSize":9.5423197492163,"rowsOfText":4,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1019,"blockId":99,"value":"2.26","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":419.28,"width":18.72,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1020,"blockId":99,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":419.04,"width":59.28,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1021,"blockId":99,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.64,"y":419.04,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1022,"blockId":99,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":198.48,"y":419.04,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1023,"blockId":99,"value":"Parties","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":216.96,"y":419.04,"width":29.52,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1024,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":251.52,"y":420.48,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1025,"blockId":99,"value":"revert","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":264.96,"y":420.48,"width":25.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1026,"blockId":99,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":295.68,"y":420.48,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1027,"blockId":99,"value":"it by Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":309.12,"y":419.04,"width":68.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1028,"blockId":99,"value":"23","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":382.8,"y":419.28,"width":10.08,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1029,"blockId":99,"value":"September 2019 with","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":398.88,"y":419.04,"width":101.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1030,"blockId":99,"value":"their","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":505.2,"y":419.04,"width":20.4,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6,"Value":"2.26 The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by Monday, 23 September 2019 with their"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1031,"blockId":99,"value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":431.52,"width":425.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1032,"blockId":99,"value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":444.24,"width":425.76,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant’s revised submission on"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1033,"blockId":99,"value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":456.96,"width":196.8,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":296.4,"Value":"damages and the Respondent’s reply thereto."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":525.6}}},{"Key":90,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1034,"columnEnd":1084,"text":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa2.27","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.227","paragraphId":"pa2.27","paragraphLabel":"2.27","rectangle":"71, 482, 455, 109","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. ","averageFontSize":8.516083916083916,"rowsOfText":9,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1034,"blockId":100,"value":"227","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":482.4,"width":18.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1035,"blockId":100,"value":"The Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":482.16,"width":59.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1036,"blockId":100,"value":"further reminds","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":164.16,"y":482.16,"width":69.12,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1037,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent that","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":238.56,"y":482.16,"width":90.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1038,"blockId":100,"value":"its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":334.56,"y":482.16,"width":9.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1039,"blockId":100,"value":"share","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":349.44,"y":482.16,"width":22.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1040,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":377.28,"y":482.16,"width":26.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1041,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":408.96,"y":482.16,"width":35.52,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1042,"blockId":100,"value":"requested by the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":449.52,"y":482.16,"width":75.36,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"227 The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1043,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal in these proceedings,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":494.88,"width":135.84,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1044,"blockId":100,"value":"in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.24,"y":494.88,"width":284.64,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1045,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":507.6,"width":51.84,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1046,"blockId":100,"value":"is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":157.44,"y":507.6,"width":6.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1047,"blockId":100,"value":"requested","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":170.16,"y":507.6,"width":42.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1048,"blockId":100,"value":"to make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":218.16,"y":509.04,"width":37.44,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1049,"blockId":100,"value":"these","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":261.84,"y":507.6,"width":22.32,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1050,"blockId":100,"value":"deposits","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":290.4,"y":507.6,"width":35.28,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1051,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":332.16,"y":507.6,"width":8.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1052,"blockId":100,"value":"fulfilment","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.32,"y":507.6,"width":43.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1053,"blockId":100,"value":"of its","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":396.0,"y":507.6,"width":24.72,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1054,"blockId":100,"value":"obligations","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":426.72,"y":507.6,"width":48.48,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1055,"blockId":100,"value":"under","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":481.2,"y":507.6,"width":25.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1056,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":512.16,"y":507.6,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1057,"blockId":100,"value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":520.32,"width":425.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":525.12,"Value":"UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1058,"blockId":100,"value":"necessary","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":535.68,"width":42.48,"height":7.44,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1059,"blockId":100,"value":"in","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":148.32,"y":532.8,"width":7.92,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1060,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":162.24,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1061,"blockId":100,"value":"light","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":181.68,"y":532.8,"width":19.44,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1062,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":207.36,"y":532.8,"width":27.6,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1063,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal’s","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":240.96,"y":532.8,"width":45.36,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1064,"blockId":100,"value":"above","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":292.56,"y":532.8,"width":25.68,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1065,"blockId":100,"value":"decision","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":324.48,"y":532.8,"width":36.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1066,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":366.48,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1067,"blockId":100,"value":"allow","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":380.88,"y":532.8,"width":24.24,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1068,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":410.88,"y":532.8,"width":12.96,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1069,"blockId":100,"value":"Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":430.08,"y":532.8,"width":51.6,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1070,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":487.44,"y":534.24,"width":8.16,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1071,"blockId":100,"value":"make","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":501.84,"y":532.8,"width":23.04,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"necessary in the light of the Tribunal’s above decision to allow the Respondent to make"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1072,"blockId":100,"value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.84,"y":545.52,"width":426.48,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.84,"MarginRight":526.32,"Value":"submissions on its [llegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1073,"blockId":100,"value":"the damages","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":558.0,"width":56.16,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1074,"blockId":100,"value":"phase","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":161.04,"y":558.0,"width":24.72,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1075,"blockId":100,"value":"of the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":191.28,"y":558.0,"width":26.88,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1076,"blockId":100,"value":"proceedings.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":223.2,"y":558.0,"width":55.2,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1077,"blockId":100,"value":"Accordingly,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":283.92,"y":558.0,"width":57.12,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1078,"blockId":100,"value":"the","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":346.56,"y":558.0,"width":13.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1079,"blockId":100,"value":"Tribunal","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":365.04,"y":558.0,"width":37.44,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1080,"blockId":100,"value":"invites","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":408.0,"y":558.0,"width":28.56,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1081,"blockId":100,"value":"the Respondent","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":441.84,"y":558.0,"width":70.08,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1082,"blockId":100,"value":"to","fontName":"Times","fontSize":6.0,"color":null,"x":516.96,"y":559.44,"width":7.92,"height":6.48,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":524.88,"Value":"the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1083,"blockId":100,"value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":10.0,"color":null,"x":99.36,"y":570.72,"width":426.0,"height":10.32,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.36,"MarginRight":525.36,"Value":"provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than Monday,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1084,"blockId":100,"value":"23 September 2019.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":99.6,"y":583.68,"width":91.2,"height":7.92,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":99.6,"MarginRight":190.8,"Value":"23 September 2019."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":526.32}}},{"Key":92,"Value":{"pageNum":12,"columnStart":1085,"columnEnd":1087,"text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"fn8","paragraphIdAuto":"fn2.8","paragraphId":"fn8","paragraphLabel":"8","rectangle":"71, 760, 133, 10","alignment":0,"blockType":6,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. ","averageFontSize":6.4375,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1085,"blockId":2,"value":"8 Partial Award,","fontName":"Times","fontSize":5.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":760.56,"width":63.36,"height":4.8,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":134.64,"Value":"8 Partial Award,"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1086,"blockId":2,"value":"p.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":7.0,"color":null,"x":137.76,"y":763.92,"width":6.96,"height":6.72,"fontStyle":null},{"type":3,"id":1087,"blockId":2,"value":"100, Decision.","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":149.04,"y":761.52,"width":56.16,"height":8.4,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":137.76,"MarginRight":205.2,"Value":"p. 100, Decision."}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":205.2}}},{"Key":91,"Value":{"pageNum":13,"columnStart":1092,"columnEnd":1093,"text":"<div><br></div><div>&nbsp;<strong></strong></div><div><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </div><div><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</div>","indentLevel":1,"paragraphIdUser":"pa99","paragraphIdAuto":"pa2.Date:12","paragraphId":"pa99","paragraphLabel":"","rectangle":"71, 115, 223, 34","alignment":0,"blockType":3,"joinedToNextBlock":false,"concatenateText":true,"spacesBeforePx":0,"spacesAfterPx":0,"imageBase64":null,"paragraphIdOverride":false,"htmlEditorText":"<p><br></p><p>&nbsp;<strong></strong></p><p><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </p><p><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</p>","averageFontSize":8.0,"rowsOfText":2,"IsCentered":false,"IsBold":false,"PdfBlock":{"rows":[{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1092,"blockId":101,"value":"Date: 12 September 2019","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":115.68,"width":113.52,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":184.8,"Value":"Date: 12 September 2019"},{"columns":[{"type":3,"id":1093,"blockId":101,"value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands","fontName":"Times","fontSize":8.0,"color":null,"x":71.28,"y":142.56,"width":223.68,"height":7.68,"fontStyle":null}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004,"Value":"Place of Arbitration: The Hague, the Netherlands"}],"MarginLeft":71.28,"MarginRight":294.96000000000004}}}],"OrderedListOfDocumentBlocksBlockManager":[{"BlockID":3,"ID":"pa0","Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div> IN&nbsp;THE MATTER OF AN ARBITRATION BEFORE A TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH </div><div><br></div><div>THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AND THE CABINET OF MINISTERS OF UKRAINE ON THE ENCOURAGEMENT AND MUTUAL PROTECTION OF INVESTMENTS DATED 27 NOVEMBER 1998 </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE ARBITRATION RULES OF THE UNITED NATIONS COMMISSION ON INTERNATIONAL TRADE LAW, 1976 </div><div><br></div><div>PCA CASE NO. 2015-21 </div><div><br></div><div>- between - </div><div><br></div><div>JSC CB PRIVATBANK </div><div>The Claimant </div><div><br></div><div>-and- </div><div><br></div><div>THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION </div><div>The Respondent </div><div><br></div><div>PROCEDURAL ORDER NO. 7 </div><div><br></div><div><strong>The Arbitral Tribunal </strong></div><div>Professor Pierre-Marie Dupuy (Presiding Arbitrator) </div><div>Sir Daniel Bethlehem QC </div><div>Dr. Vaclav Mikulak</div><div><br></div><div><strong>Registry</strong> </div><div>Permanent Court of Arbitration </div><div><br></div><div>12 September 2019</div>"},{"BlockID":4,"ID":"h1","Type":"Heading","Text":" Procedural Background"},{"BlockID":5,"ID":"pa1.1","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 13 April 2015, JSC CB PrivatBank (&#x201C;PrivatBank&#x201D; or the &#x201C;Claimant&#x201D;) and Finance Company Finilon LLC (&#x201C;Finilon&#x201D; and, together with PrivatBank, the &#x201C;Claimants&#x201D;) commenced these arbitral proceedings [REDACTED] pursuant to Article 9(2)(c) of the Agreement Between the Government of the Russian Federation and the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine on the Encouragement and Mutual Protection of Investments dated 27 November 1998 (the &#x201C;Treaty&#x201D;) and the Arbitration Rules of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law, as adopted in 1976 (the &#x201C;UNCITRAL Rules&#x201D;)."},{"BlockID":6,"ID":"pa1.2","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":7,"ID":"pa1.3","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal was constituted on 6 July 2015."},{"BlockID":8,"ID":"pa1.4","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On the same date, 6 July 2015, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it had received a copy of the Respondent’s Letters from the PCA, and that it considered the content of these letters to constitute an objection by the Respondent to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and to the admissibility of the Claimants’ claims under Article 21 of the UNCITRAL Rules. "},{"BlockID":9,"ID":"pa1.5","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 18 August 2015, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 1 and Rules of Procedure, providing that the PCA would act as registry in these proceedings, fixing The Hague as the place of arbitration, and establishing an initial timetable. Pursuant to the initial timetable, the Claimants were to file a Statement of Claim by 30 November 2015 and the Respondent was to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility, including any Application for Bifurcation, by 29 February 2016. "},{"BlockID":10,"ID":"pa1.6","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":11,"ID":"pa1.7","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Respondent did not file a Statement of Defence or any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility or any Application for Bifurcation by the deadline set in the Rules of Procedure. The Respondent did not request an extension of this deadline or otherwise communicate with the Tribunal. "},{"BlockID":12,"ID":"pa1.8","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":13,"ID":"pa1.9","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 19 March 2016, in view of the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence, and having sought the Respondent&rsquo;s views but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 2, in which it (i) ordered, pursuant to Article 28(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules, that these proceedings continue notwithstanding the Respondent&rsquo;s failure to communicate a Statement of Defence; (i1) decided to bifurcate the proceedings to address issues of jurisdiction and admissibility in a preliminary phase, including in a hearing to be held from 12-14 July 2016; and (ii1) addressed 25 questions to the Parties&#x2014;one question to the Claimants and 24 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. The Parties were to respond to"},{"BlockID":14,"ID":null,"Type":"Textblock","Text":"the Tribunal’s questions by 22 April 2016. Thereafter, each Party had until 29 April 2016 to indicate whether it wished to comment on the responses provided by the other Party. "},{"BlockID":16,"ID":"pa1.10","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":15,"ID":"pa1.11","Type":"Textblock","Text":" May 2016, having sought the views of the Parties on the experts’ selection and terms of reference, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal appointed experts on Russian and Ukrainian law in accordance with Article 27 of the UNCITRAL Rules, to report to it in writing on certain issues of Ukrainian civil law and Russian civil law. "},{"BlockID":17,"ID":"pa1.12","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 3 June 2016, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal admitted into the record of these proceedings a non-disputing party submission by Ukraine addressing certain issues of jurisdiction, and invited the Parties&rsquo; comments thereon. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any comments. "},{"BlockID":18,"ID":"pa1.13","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 10 and 14 June 2016, the Tribunal communicated the reports of its experts on Russian and Ukrainian law to the Parties for their comments. [REDACTED] the Respondent did not submit any comments. "},{"BlockID":19,"ID":"pa1.14","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The hearing on jurisdiction and admissibility was held in Geneva from 12 to 14 July 2016. Although invited, the Respondent did not attend or otherwise participate. During the hearing, the Tribunal put questions to witnesses presented by the Claimants. The experts appointed by the Tribunal also answered questions from the Claimants and the Tribunal. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and they were granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions to be filed by 14 October 2016. "},{"BlockID":20,"ID":"pa1.15","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED] The Respondent did not file any post-hearing submissions. "},{"BlockID":21,"ID":"pa1.16","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 24 February 2017, the Tribunal issued its unanimous Interim Award, in which it addressed certain issues of jurisdiction and admissibility and joined the consideration of all other issues of jurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings (the &#x201C;<strong>Interim Award</strong>&#x201D;). "},{"BlockID":22,"ID":"pa1.17","Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div> The operative part of the Interim Award reads as follows: </div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: </div><div><br>1. the Russian Federation has assumed obligations under the Treaty in respect of Ukrainian investors and their investments in the Crimean Peninsula as of 21 March 2014; </div><div><br>2. there is a dispute between the Parties arising in connection with what the Claimants allege to constitute &#x201C;investments&#x201D; under the Treaty; and 3. the Claimants have satisfied the notice and negotiation requirements under Article 9 of the Treaty.</div></div></div></div>"},{"BlockID":23,"ID":null,"Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>The Tribunal joins the consideration of all other issues ofjurisdiction or admissibility to the merits of the proceedings and defers any decision on the costs of arbitration to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>"},{"BlockID":24,"ID":"pa1.18","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 27 March 2017, the Tribunal re-issued the Interim Award, correcting four typographical errors. "},{"BlockID":25,"ID":"pa1.19","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 11 July 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no reply from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 3, in which it: (i) decided to bifurcate the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages; (ii) established a procedural calendar for the first of these two phases, in which the Tribunal would put questions to the Parties in advance of a hearing that would take place from 1 to 4 November 2017. "},{"BlockID":26,"ID":"pa1.20","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On the same day, 11 July 2017, in accordance with the timetable established in Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal addressed 15 questions to the Parties&#x2014;4 questions to the Claimants and 11 questions to both Parties&#x2014;regarding issues of liability and remaining issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. [REDACTED] The Respondent did not submit any responses. "},{"BlockID":27,"ID":"pa1.21","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 8 September 2017, having sought the views of the Parties, but having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal instructed the expert in Russian law whom it had appointed in the earlier phase of the proceedings to produce a report on additional specific issues arising from the Claimants’ submissions. The expert’s written report was communicated to the Parties for their comments on 18 October 2017.|G, The Respondent did not provide any comments. "},{"BlockID":28,"ID":"pa1.22","Type":"Textblock","Text":" A hearing on the remaining issues of admissibility and jurisdiction, as well as on liability, was held in The Hague from 1 to 3 November 2017. Although invited, the Russian Federation did not attend the hearing or otherwise participate. In the course of the hearing, the Tribunal examined three fact witnesses, one expert in Russian law and one valuation expert, all presented by the Claimants. The Tribunal-appointed expert on Russian law also appeared for examination. The hearing transcript was delivered to the Parties, and the Parties were further granted leave to address questions raised by the Tribunal in the hearing, as well as other matters arising out of the hearing, in post-hearing submissions. "},{"BlockID":29,"ID":"pa1.23","Type":"Textblock","Text":"&nbsp;[REDACTED] The Russian Federation did not file any post-hearing submissions. "},{"BlockID":30,"ID":"pa1.24","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letters dated 5 July and 3 December 2018, the Tribunal requested certain additional documents from the Parties, [REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":31,"ID":"pa1.25","Type":"Textblock","Text":"1.25 On 4 February 2019, having deliberated, the Tribunal issued a unanimous Partial Award addressing the Respondent&rsquo;s liability in respect of the Claimants&rsquo; claims under the Treaty, as well as all outstanding issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (the &#x201C;<strong>Partial Award</strong>&#x201D; and, together with the Interim Award, the &#x201C;<strong>Awards</strong>&#x201D;). "},{"BlockID":32,"ID":"pa1.26","Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div> The operative part of the Partial Award reads as follows: For the foregoing reasons, the Tribunal finds that: <br></div><div class=\"paraPadding\"><div class=\"paraPaddingText lineheight paratag\"><div style=\"padding-top:20px;\" class=\"linespace paratag\"><div>1. the Tribunal has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty; </div><div><br>2. PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible; and </div><div><br></div><div>3. the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investment.</div><div>&nbsp;<br>The issue of compensation due in the light of this finding of liability and any decision on the costs of arbitration are deferred to the next phase of the arbitration. </div></div></div></div>"},{"BlockID":33,"ID":"pa1.27","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":34,"ID":"pa1.28","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 22 March 2019, having sought the views of the Respondent, but having received no reply, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 4, confirming the change of PrivatBank’s counsel in these proceedings. "},{"BlockID":35,"ID":"pa1.29","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letter of the same date, 22 March 2019, the Tribunal recalled the finding made at paragraph 187 of its Partial Award that “Finilon’s claims fall outside the Tribunal’s jurisdiction.” The Tribunal consequently invited PrivatBank and Finilon to indicate what continuing status or role, if any, Finilon held or was envisaged to have in these proceedings. By letter dated 1 April 2019, the Tribunal also invited the Respondent to comment on this issue. "},{"BlockID":36,"ID":"pa1.30","Type":"Textblock","Text":" On 3 May 2019, having considered PrivatBank’s and Finilon’s responses and having received no comments from the Respondent, the Tribunal issued Procedural Order No. 5, in which it determined that, absent any reasoned application by Finilon to continue to participate in the proceedings as a party having a direct interest in the proceedings, or on some other basis, which the Tribunal is required to address, Finilon may no longer participate in the proceedings going forward. "},{"BlockID":37,"ID":"pa1.31","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letter dated 8 May 2019, the Tribunal informed the Parties that it considered that it would be useful for the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal’s findings in its Partial Award and invited the Claimant to make these revised submissions by 19 June 2019. The Tribunal also invited the Respondent to indicate, by 3 July 2019, whether it wished to submit a reply to the Claimant’s revised submissions on damages."},{"BlockID":38,"ID":"pa1.32","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":39,"ID":"pa1.33","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letter dated 14 May 2019, the Tribunal invited the Respondent to comment on the Claimant’s extension request by 21 May 2019. "},{"BlockID":40,"ID":"pa1.34","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":41,"ID":"pa1.35","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":42,"ID":"pa1.36","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":43,"ID":"pa1.36.i","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":44,"ID":"pa1.36.ii","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":45,"ID":"pa1.37","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letter dated 25 June 2019, the Tribunal recalled that the Respondent had thus far failed to pay its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal to cover its fees and expenses, which share was therefore paid by the Claimant, and requested that the Respondent pay its outstanding share of the deposits, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, by 26 July 2019. "},{"BlockID":46,"ID":"pa1.38","Type":"Textblock","Text":" By letter dated 4 July 2019, at the request of the Respondent, the Tribunal confirmed that the schedule set forth in its letter of § May 2019 is no longer applicable. "},{"BlockID":47,"ID":"pa1.39","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":48,"ID":"pa1.40","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":49,"ID":"pa1.41","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":50,"ID":"pa1.42","Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div>By letter dated 26 July 2019, the Tribunal indicated that it would shortly issue its decision on the application set out in the Respondent's letters dated 21 May and 18 June 2019.</div>"},{"BlockID":51,"ID":"pa1.43","Type":"Textblock","Text":"By letter dated 21 August 2019, the Tribunal requested the Respondent to provide a copy of its writ of summons in the Set Aside Proceedings, and invited both Parties to provide an update regarding any relevant developments in those Proceedings."},{"BlockID":52,"ID":"pa1.44","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":53,"ID":"pa1.45","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":54,"ID":"pa1.46","Type":"Textblock","Text":" As noted in the covering letter to this Order, the Tribunal considers that it has been sufficiently informed by the Parties’ numerous submissions on this issue to date, as well as by the Respondent’s Set Aside and Revocation Writs. The Tribunal is accordingly in a position to issue the present Order. "},{"BlockID":55,"ID":"h2","Type":"Heading","Text":" Tribunal’s Ruling and Directions"},{"BlockID":57,"ID":"h2.i","Type":"Heading","Text":" The Respondent’s Request to Make Submissions on Jurisdiction"},{"BlockID":56,"ID":"pa2.2","Type":"Textblock","Text":" To properly assess the Respondent&rsquo;s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, it is necessary to consider it in the context of the entire proceedings. As described above, the Tribunal has already conducted two phases of these proceedings in which both Parties have been given a full opportunity to make written and oral submissions, including during two hearings, in respect of issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). The Tribunal has also already issued two Awards addressing issues of jurisdiction and admissibility. In particular, in its Partial Award, the Tribunal decided all issues of jurisdiction and admissibility that remained outstanding after its Interim Award and found that &#x201C;it has jurisdiction over PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims under the Treaty&#x201D; and that &#x201C;PrivatBank&rsquo;s claims are admissible.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn1\"><span class=\"supertext\">1</span></a>"},{"BlockID":58,"ID":"pa2.3","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal&rsquo;s Awards are final and binding on the Parties. Pursuant to Article 9(3) of the Treaty, from which the Tribunal derives its jurisdiction, the &#x201C;arbitral award shall be final and binding upon both parties to the dispute.&#x201D; Article 32(2) of the UNCITRAL Rules, which apply by virtue of Article 9(2)(c) of the Treaty, similarly provides that arbitral awards &#x201C;shall be final and binding on the parties.&#x201D; [REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":59,"ID":"pa2.4","Type":"Textblock","Text":" It follows that the question for the Tribunal is not simply whether to allow the Respondent to make submissions on issues of jurisdiction, but whether to reopen the proceedings in respect of those issues with a view to potentially reconsidering the final and binding jurisdictional decisions set out in its Awards. Regardless of whether the Tribunal has the power to do so, be it under Dutch law, the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules, the Tribunal&rsquo;s inherent powers or otherwise, the Tribunal considers that the present circumstances do not warrant reopening the decisions already made by the Tribunal in its Awards. "},{"BlockID":60,"ID":"pa2.6","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal has taken seriously its obligation to satisfy itself of its own jurisdiction despite the non-participation of the Respondent in the proceedings, having tested the Claimants&rsquo; evidence"},{"BlockID":61,"ID":"fn1","Type":"Footnote","Text":"Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. "},{"BlockID":62,"ID":null,"Type":"Textblock","Text":"and argument over the last two phases of the proceedings, in particular by putting numerous questions to the Parties (see paragraphs 1.9 to 1.10 and 1.20 above) and appointing independent experts on Ukrainian and Russian law (see paragraphs 1.11 to 1.14 and 1.21 to 1.22 above), before examining and deciding upon these issues in detail in its Awards. "},{"BlockID":63,"ID":"pa2.7","Type":"Textblock","Text":" Moreover, in the more than four years since the commencement of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that it has given the Respondent an equal and full opportunity to participate and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability). Thus, Tribunal has (1) afforded the Respondent, as with the Claimant, an opportunity to express its views on each proposed procedural step throughout the proceedings, including by inviting its comments on drafts of procedural timetables; (i) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to file a Statement of Defence and any Objection to Jurisdiction and/or Admissibility; (ii1) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to respond to the Tribunal&rsquo;s written questions on substantive issues, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (iv) granted the Respondent equal and sufficient time to submit responses to the written pleadings and other communications from the Claimant, including with respect to issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (as well as issues of liability); (v) invited the Respondent, as with the Claimant, to comment on the proposed candidacy, terms of reference and reports of the independent experts on Russian and Ukrainian law appointed by the Tribunal, notably to address questions relevant to jurisdiction and admissibility; (vi) provided the Respondent adequate notice of the two hearings it has held, both of which addressed issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (while the second hearing also addressed issues of liability); (vii) provided the Respondent, in a timely manner, with the transcripts and all other documents submitted in the course of the hearings; and (vii) provided an opportunity for, and invited, the Respondent to comment on anything said during the hearings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn4\"><span class=\"supertext\">4</span></a> The Respondent did not avail itself of any of these opportunities to participate in the proceedings and make submissions on issues of jurisdiction and admissibility (or issues of liability). "},{"BlockID":64,"ID":"pa2.8","Type":"Textblock","Text":" Having failed to abide by any of the deadlines set by the Tribunal or otherwise make its views known upon any of the dozens of invitations extended by the Tribunal prior to the issuance of its Awards, the Tribunal is unable to see any compelling reason why the Respondent should now be allowed to make submissions on issues that have already been decided by the Tribunal in those Awards. [REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":65,"ID":"pa2.9","Type":"Textblock","Text":"The Tribunal is also mindful of the Claimant&rsquo;s interest in the finality of the Awards and the Tribunal&rsquo;s duty to conduct the proceedings in an efficient and proportionate manner. Substantial delay would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request to reopen the Tribunal&rsquo;s decisions on jurisdiction were granted. Moreover, now that the Dutch courts are seised of the Set Aside Proceedings and will have the final word as the courts of the legal seat of this arbitration, a re- examination by the Tribunal of issues which it has already considered and decided in detail in its Awards is neither necessary nor likely to materially assist the Dutch courts in discharging their supervisory jurisdiction. "},{"BlockID":67,"ID":"pa2.10","Type":"Textblock","Text":" In contrast, the Tribunal considers that the Respondent will not suffer prejudice if the Tribunal denies its request to reopen the entire proceedings on jurisdiction before this Tribunal, as it will have the opportunity to make all of its jurisdictional arguments before the Hague Court of Appeal"},{"BlockID":66,"ID":"fn4","Type":"Footnote","Text":" See Interim Award, para. 154; Partial Award, para. 176. "},{"BlockID":68,"ID":"pa","Type":"Textblock","Text":" the Set Aside Proceedings. [REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":69,"ID":"pa2.11","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED] the Tribunal considers that its Awards address both the threshold jurisdictional issue of the application of the Treaty between the Russian Federation and Ukraine in respect of the Crimean Peninsula in the period from February 2014 onwards, and all other applicable jurisdictional and admissibility requirements under the Treaty. "},{"BlockID":70,"ID":"pa2.12","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED] Although the Respondent could have raised this issue at an earlier stage of these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that, in view of the substantial new evidence now adduced by the Respondent, as well as the serious nature of its allegations, it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Illegality Objection, should it wish to do so. In order to minimize any delay resulting from such submissions and given that the Respondent&rsquo;s arguments and evidence in respect of the Illegality Objection will likely also be relevant to the damages issues in these proceedings, the Tribunal considers that any such submissions should be made in the Respondent&rsquo;s submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below)."},{"BlockID":71,"ID":"pa2.13","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request for permission to make written and oral submissions on jurisdiction, save that in its submissions on compensation (as to which, see paragraph 2.24 below) the Respondent may make submissions in respect of its Illegality Objection. "},{"BlockID":72,"ID":"h2.ii","Type":"Heading","Text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for a Stay of Proceedings"},{"BlockID":73,"ID":"pa2.14","Type":"Textblock","Text":" In the alternative to its request for permission to make submissions on jurisdiction, the Respondent requests that the Tribunal stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. "},{"BlockID":74,"ID":"pa2.15","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Respondent does not cite, and the Tribunal is not aware of, any provision of the Treaty, the UNCITRAL Rules or Dutch law, or any other applicable rule of international law, that would require the Tribunal to stay the proceedings. The question is thus whether the Tribunal should, in the exercise of its discretion to conduct the arbitration in such manner as it considers appropriate, stay its proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. "},{"BlockID":75,"ID":"pa2.16","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal considers that it is for the Respondent to establish that a stay is justified by the circumstances. Article 1036(3) of the DCCP requires the Tribunal to “guard against unreasonable delay in the proceedings.” Yet, substantial delay is likely to result from a stay ofthese proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, particularly if a decision of the Hague Court of Appeal is thereafter appealed to the Hoge Raad (Dutch Supreme Court). The Respondent must therefore demonstrate that this delay is reasonable and justified by the circumstances. "},{"BlockID":76,"ID":"fn5","Type":"Footnote","Text":" Set Aside Writ, para. 83. "},{"BlockID":77,"ID":"pa2.17","Type":"Textblock","Text":"[REDACTED]"},{"BlockID":78,"ID":"pa2.18","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The issue of the likelihood of the Respondent&rsquo;s success in the Set Aside Proceedings is not a matter for this Tribunal, but for the Hague Court of Appeal, as the authority duly charged with deciding the Respondent&rsquo;s set aside application under Dutch law. The Tribunal accordingly considers that deference requires it to forebear from any comment on its appreciation of the issues engaged in the Set Aside Proceedings. Yet, the Tribunal, in common with any tribunal of law and aside from the consideration of questions that will properly be addressed by the Hague Court of Appeal, ought nevertheless to consider whether a stay of its proceedings may properly be warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. "},{"BlockID":79,"ID":"pa2.19","Type":"Textblock","Text":" Having regard to its Awards, the issues that remain to be addressed in these proceedings, and the jurisdictional objections summarized in the Respondent&rsquo;s recent correspondence and the Respondent&rsquo;s Set Aside and Revocation Writs, the Tribunal concludes that a stay of its proceedings is not warranted in the interests of the administration of justice. The continuation of the proceedings will not prejudice the proper conduct of the Set Aside Proceedings. Nor will the failure to stay impede the Tribunal&rsquo;s ability to fully and properly examine and decide the remaining issues before it. "},{"BlockID":80,"ID":"pa2.20","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings. "},{"BlockID":81,"ID":"h2.iii","Type":"Heading","Text":" The Respondent&rsquo;s Request for Permission to Raise Objections in relation to the Claim on the Merits and Quantum"},{"BlockID":82,"ID":"pa2.21","Type":"Textblock","Text":" Having denied the Respondent’s request to make submissions on jurisdiction and declined to stay these proceedings pending the outcome of the Set Aside Proceedings, the Tribunal must address the Respondent’s request for permission to raise objections in relation to the Claimants’ claim on the merits and quantum, including by way of an evidentiary hearing. "},{"BlockID":83,"ID":"pa2.22","Type":"Textblock","Text":" In its Partial Award, the Tribunal held that &#x201C;the Russian Federation has breached Article 5 of the Treaty in respect of PrivatBank&rsquo;s investments.&#x201D;<a href=\"#UN011730_fn7\"><span class=\"supertext\">7</span></a> Insofar as the Respondent is now requesting that the Tribunal reconsider that finding of liability, the Tribunal considers that such a reopening of proceedings is unwarranted in the present circumstances for all of the reasons set out at paragraphs 2.2-2.9 above in respect of the Respondent&rsquo;s similar request to make submissions on jurisdiction. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent has had an equal and full opportunity to make submissions regarding issues of liability. As with jurisdiction, the Respondent missed the numerous deadlines set by the Tribunal for its submissions on issues of liability, and has not cited any compelling reason why it should now be allowed to make submissions long after those deadlines have expired. Here too, the Tribunal is mindful of the Claimants&rsquo; interest in the finality of the Awards and of the delay that would inevitably result if the Respondent&rsquo;s request were granted. "},{"BlockID":85,"ID":"pa2.23","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The situation is different with respect to the part of the Respondent’s request that concerns the issue of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. In Procedural Order No. 3, the Tribunal bifurcated the proceedings between a phase in which it would address the"},{"BlockID":84,"ID":"fn7","Type":"Footnote","Text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. "},{"BlockID":86,"ID":null,"Type":"Textblock","Text":"remaining questions of jurisdiction and admissibility, as well as questions of liability, and, in the event that liability is established, a phase in which it would address questions of quantum of damages. In its Partial Award, the Tribunal accordingly deferred the issue of compensation due in the light of its finding of liability to a subsequent phase of the proceedings.<a href=\"#UN011730_fn8\"><span class=\"supertext\">8</span></a> The Tribunal has since invited the Claimant to make further submissions on damages that take into account the Tribunal&rsquo;s findings in its Partial Award. "},{"BlockID":87,"ID":"pa2.24","Type":"Textblock","Text":" In these circumstances, the Tribunal considers that it would be appropriate to allow the Respondent a full opportunity to respond to the Claimant&rsquo;s forthcoming revised submission on damages, in accordance with Article 15(1) of the UNCITRAL Rules. Indeed, the Claimant accepts that the Respondent is entitled to participate in the quantum phase of the proceedings. "},{"BlockID":88,"ID":"pa2.25","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal accordingly denies the Respondent’s request to raise objections in relation to the Claimant’s claim on the merits and quantum insofar as it is seeks a reconsideration of the Tribunal’s finding in its Partial Award that the Respondent has breached Article 5 of the Treaty, and grants the Respondent’s request insofar as it seeks an opportunity to make submissions on the issues of compensation due in the light of the Tribunal’s finding of liability. Each Party’s submission on compensation may be accompanied by any exhibits, legal authorities, witness statements or expert reports that the Party wishes to rely on in support of its submission. In view of the Tribunal’s decision at paragraph 2.13 above, the Parties’ submissions on compensation may also address the Respondent’s Illegality Objection. In due course, a hearing may be held to allow each Party to make oral submissions and cross-examine the other Party’s fact and expert witnesses, if any. "},{"BlockID":89,"ID":"pa2.26","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal invites the Parties to revert to it by <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong> with their respective proposals for the procedural calendar to be established for the damages phase of the proceedings, including time limits to be set for the filing of the Claimant&rsquo;s revised submission on damages and the Respondent&rsquo;s reply thereto. "},{"BlockID":90,"ID":"pa2.27","Type":"Textblock","Text":" The Tribunal further reminds the Respondent that its share of the deposits requested by the Tribunal in these proceedings, in the total amount of EUR 500,000, remains outstanding. The Respondent is requested to make these deposits in fulfilment of its obligations under the UNCITRAL Rules and the Rules of Procedure. The Tribunal further observes that this deposit is necessary in the light of the Tribunal&rsquo;s above decision to allow the Respondent to make submissions on its Ilegality Objection at a late stage of the proceedings and to meet the costs of the damages phase of the proceedings. Accordingly, the Tribunal invites the Respondent to provide an update on the status of this payment as soon as possible and by no later than <strong><u>Monday, 23 September 2019</u></strong>. "},{"BlockID":92,"ID":"fn8","Type":"Footnote","Text":" Partial Award, p. 100, Decision. "},{"BlockID":91,"ID":"pa99","Type":"Textblock","Text":"<div><br></div><div>&nbsp;<strong></strong></div><div><strong>Date</strong>:&nbsp;September 2019 </div><div><strong>Place of Arbitration</strong>: The Hague, the Netherlands</div>"}]}